Why it matters. In 1979 prices in the USA were rising by more than 13% a year. Paul Volcker, the new chair of the Federal Reserve, decided to stop inflation whatever it cost. He let interest rates rise until the main Fed rate passed 19% in 1981. Mortgages and car loans became almost unaffordable, builders posted pieces of wood to the Fed in protest at the lost house sales, and unemployment reached 10.8% at the end of 1982, the highest since the 1930s. But by 1983 inflation had fallen to about 3%, and it stayed low for decades. Volcker's choice shows the hardest question in macroeconomics: when a government's objectives conflict, which one should come first, and which tools should it use?
In this unit you will:
name the six macroeconomic objectives and how each is measured;
explain the four main conflicts between them, including the Phillips curve;
compare free-market and interventionist supply-side policies;
explain fiscal and monetary policy and the roles of a central bank;
evaluate policies by their timing, side effects and risks of government failure.
4.1
宏观经济目标与冲突 (2.3.6.1-2)
English
Governments usually aim for six things:
economic growth: rising real GDP, measured by its growth rate;
low and stable inflation, measured by the CPI. Many central banks have an inflation target 通胀目标: the Bank of England's is 2% CPI inflation, and China sets an annual CPI target, which was "around 3%" in 2024;
low unemployment, measured by the ILO unemployment rate;
balance of payments equilibrium on the current account, so that a country does not build up foreign debts it cannot repay;
a balanced government budget over the economic cycle, so that public debt stays affordable;
greater equality of income, measured by the Gini coefficient or income shares.
Each objective has a trade-off 权衡 with at least one other. Policy is about choosing between them.
Six objectives and their measures; the red links mark the four main conflicts
Inflation versus unemployment. In 1958 the New Zealand economist Bill Phillips plotted almost a century of British data and found that years of low unemployment were years of fast wage inflation. The short-run Phillips curve 菲利普斯曲线 shows this trade-off: when demand is strong, firms hire more and compete for workers, so wages and prices rise faster.
Worked example: reading a Phillips curve.
The curve passes through (unemployment 4%, inflation 8%), (6%, 5%), (8%, 3%) and (10%, 2%).
To cut inflation from 8% to 3%, the economy moves from 4% to 8% unemployment.
The cost of five points less inflation is four points more unemployment in the short run.
The trade-off is not fixed. In the 1970s oil shocks pushed inflation and unemployment up together, called stagflation 滞胀. And once people expect low inflation, as they did after Volcker, wage demands are lower and the whole curve shifts down.
Moving along the short-run Phillips curve: lower inflation costs higher unemployment
Growth versus the environment. Faster growth usually means more energy, more transport and more waste. In November 2016, with India's economy growing by over 7% a year, Delhi closed 1,800 schools for three days because of severe smog.
Inflation versus the current account. If the government raises demand, incomes rise and people buy more imports. Faster inflation also makes exports less competitive. Both push the current account towards deficit.
Growth versus equality. Growth that rewards skills, cities and capital owners can widen gaps even as average incomes rise. China's official Gini coefficient rose from about 0.3 in the early 1980s to a peak of about 0.49 in 2008.
In an exam, name the conflict, explain the mechanism, and weigh how large the trade-off is in that context.
Supply-side policies 供给侧政策 aim to raise productivity, competition and incentives so that LRAS shifts to the right. Then output can grow without extra inflation.
Free-market policies reduce the role of the state:
deregulation 放松监管: removing rules that block entry or raise costs, such as the opening of airline routes to new low-cost carriers in Europe in the 1990s;
privatisation 私有化: selling state firms, so they face the discipline of profit. The UK sold British Telecom in 1984 and British Gas in 1986;
lower taxes on income and profits, to reward work and investment;
welfare reform: Germany's Hartz reforms of 2003–2005 cut long-term unemployment benefits and tightened job-search rules;
cutting bureaucracy 官僚程序 and red tape for firms.
Interventionist policies use the state to build capacity:
investment in education, training and skills, such as Singapore's SkillsFuture credits for adult training (2015);
tax incentives and subsidies for investment;
infrastructure 基础设施: China's high-speed rail network grew from nothing in 2008 to about 45,000 km by 2023, cutting travel times for workers and firms;
finance for business start-ups;
regional policy 区域政策: China's Western Development strategy, from 2000, sent investment to poorer western provinces.
Worked example: a supply-side success on the model.
Aggregate demand is $P = 90 - Y/2$. LRAS shifts from $Y = 85$ to $Y = 105$.
Real output rises by 20 while the price level falls by 10: growth without inflation.
Free-market policies are cheap to announce and sharpen incentives, but they can widen inequality, and their effect on effort is uncertain. Interventionist policies tackle real bottlenecks, but they are expensive and slow, and they risk government failure 政府失灵: some of China's regional airports and industrial parks were built where there was too little demand to use them.
LRAS shifts right from 85 to 105: output rises and the price level falls from 47.5 to 37.5
Reflationary 扩张性 policy raises AD: more government spending, lower taxes, lower interest rates, quantitative easing. Deflationary 紧缩性 policy does the opposite. In 2009 the USA's American Recovery and Reinvestment Act added about US$800 billion of spending and tax cuts; the same year China's ¥4 trillion stimulus did the same job on a bigger scale relative to GDP.
Worked example: fiscal policy and capacity.
The multiplier is 2, and the government raises spending by 10.
With spare capacity, AD shifts right and real income rises by up to $2 \times 10 = 20$.
Close to full capacity (a vertical LRAS), the same rise mainly raises the price level 价格水平.
So the right policy depends on the size of the output gap.
Quantitative easing is the central bank's purchase of government or corporate bonds 债券 with newly created money. It pushes down long-term interest rates and gives banks more money to lend, which supports consumption, investment and AD. The Bank of England began QE in March 2009, when it also cut Bank Rate to 0.5%, and had bought £895 billion of bonds by 2021. Japan first used QE in 2001 to fight deflation.
The base rate 基准利率 is the interest rate the central bank sets, which other rates follow. In October 2016 the Reserve Bank of India cut its policy rate from 6.5% to 6.25% to make borrowing cheaper. The People's Bank of China often changes the reserve requirement ratio, the share of deposits banks must hold in reserve: a cut frees money for loans.
The Bank of England sets Bank Rate, its main monetary-policy tool
A central bank 中央银行 has four main roles:
it carries out monetary policy, setting the base rate and running QE;
it pursues the inflation target; if people trust it, they expect low inflation, so wage demands stay moderate and the Phillips trade-off eases;
it is banker to the government, managing its accounts and debt;
it is banker to the banks and lender of last resort 最后贷款人. In September 2007 savers queued outside Northern Rock, the first run on a British bank since 1866, until the Bank of England lent it emergency money.
Monetary policy is quick to change and usually independent of politics, but it works indirectly with long and variable time lags 时滞, often a year or two. Fiscal policy acts directly on demand and can target particular groups or regions, but it is slow to pass into law, may crowd out 挤出 private spending, and raises the budget deficit 预算赤字.
The policy map: demand-side or supply-side, and the instruments in each
Extract. Inflation in the euro area reached 10.6% in October 2022, driven mainly by energy and food prices after Russia's invasion of Ukraine. The European Central Bank (ECB) raised its deposit rate from −0.5% in July 2022 to 4.0% by September 2023, the fastest rise in its history. By November 2023 inflation had fallen to 2.4%. Real GDP grew by only about 0.5% in 2023, but the unemployment rate stayed close to a record low of about 6.5%. Wholesale gas prices in Europe, which had risen more than tenfold from early 2021 to their peak in August 2022, fell back sharply during 2023. Many firms kept their workers despite weak sales, because skilled staff were hard to find.
The extract's figures on one chart
Questions
(a) Calculate the change in the ECB's deposit rate between July 2022 and September 2023, in percentage points. [2]
(b) With the help of an AD/AS diagram, explain how a rise in interest rates can reduce inflation. [6]
(c) Examine two reasons why unemployment in the euro area did not rise much while inflation fell. [8]
(d) Evaluate whether higher interest rates were the main reason for the fall in euro-area inflation. [12]
Model answers
(a) $4.0 - (-0.5) = 4.5$ percentage points.
(b) A higher interest rate raises the cost of borrowing and the reward for saving. Households cut consumption, especially on goods bought with credit; firms delay investment; higher rates may also raise the euro's exchange rate, reducing net exports. AD shifts left from $AD_1$ to $AD_2$. On the AD/SRAS diagram the price level falls below where it would otherwise be and real output falls: inflation slows. The effect works with lags, often of a year or more.
(c) Falling energy costs shifted SRAS right. The extract says gas prices fell sharply in 2023. Lower costs shift SRAS to the right, which lowers the price level while raising output, so inflation fell without the usual rise in unemployment. This is the reverse of the cost-push shock of 2022. Labour hoarding and labour shortages. Firms kept skilled workers despite weak sales because they were hard to replace; with an ageing population, labour supply is tight. So the fall in demand showed up in lower hours and productivity rather than job losses. Evaluation: hoarding cannot last if weak demand continues; firms will cut jobs if profits fall for long.
(d) For interest rates as the main reason: the rise of 4.5 percentage points was very large and fast. It reduced credit growth and investment, and the stronger signal of a credible central bank stopped expected inflation from rising, so wage demands stayed moderate. Without the rate rises, high inflation might have spread into wages and become persistent (second-round effects).
Against: the inflation was mainly cost-push from energy and food, and the fall in gas prices removed much of the cause, whatever interest rates did. Monetary policy works with long lags of 12–24 months, so rate rises from late 2022 and 2023 could only have had part of their effect by November 2023. Unemployment stayed low, which suggests demand did not fall much, so the demand channel may have been weak.
Weighing: the timing suggests that falling energy prices explain most of the fall in headline inflation in 2023, while higher interest rates mattered more for core inflation (excluding energy and food) and for keeping expectations anchored. The two worked together: rate rises would have needed to be much larger, with far higher unemployment, if energy prices had stayed high.
Judgement: higher interest rates were not the main reason for the fall in headline inflation, but they were an important reason why inflation did not stay high once the energy shock faded. Their main contribution was to anchor expectations, which is hard to measure but explains why the fall came without a rise in unemployment.
What examiners reward: the calculation in percentage points (not per cent), a diagram used in the explanation, reasons tied to the extract's evidence with evaluation in part (c), and in part (d) a weighing of the causes that uses timing and lags, ending in a supported judgement.
4.2
本课资料
English
Federal Reserve Bank historical data (federal funds rate, 1979–1983); US Bureau of Labor Statistics (unemployment, December 1982).
A. W. Phillips, "The Relation between Unemployment and the Rate of Change of Money Wage Rates in the United Kingdom, 1861–1957", Economica 25 (1958).
Bank of England, Bank Rate history and Asset Purchase Facility reports.
European Central Bank and Eurostat, inflation and policy-rate data (2022–2023).
Pearson Edexcel International AS Economics specification (WEC12), Issue 2, section 2.3.6, and the WEC12 Sample Assessment Materials.
4.2
常见错误
English
Saying supply-side policies work quickly. Most take years; demand-side policies act in the short run.
Treating the Phillips curve as fixed. Supply shocks and inflation expectations shift it.
Writing "the government sets interest rates" in most advanced economies. An independent central bank does.
Confusing a budget deficit (one year's borrowing) with the national debt (the total owed).
Ending a policy answer with no judgement. Say which policy works best, in what conditions and over what time.
Describing QE as "printing banknotes". The central bank creates reserves to buy bonds.
Phillips curve: the short-run trade-off between inflation and unemployment.
Supply-side policy: a policy to raise productive capacity, shifting LRAS right.
Fiscal policy: changes in government spending and taxation.
Monetary policy: changes in interest rates, the money supply and credit.
Quantitative easing: central-bank purchases of bonds with newly created money.
Lender of last resort: the central bank's role of lending to banks in a crisis.
4.2
自我检测
English
Using the Phillips curve points in this unit, what is the cost of cutting inflation from 5% to 2%?
Why did unemployment rise in the USA in 1981–1982?
Classify each as free-market or interventionist supply-side policy: privatising a railway; building a new port; cutting the top rate of income tax; subsidising apprenticeships.
With a multiplier of 2.5, how much must government spending rise to raise income by ¥100 billion if there is spare capacity?
Explain one reason why monetary policy may fail to reduce inflation quickly.
Evaluate whether infrastructure spending is a demand-side or a supply-side policy.
Answers: 1. Unemployment rises from 6% to 10%. 2. Interest rates near 20% cut borrowing, spending and investment, so AD fell and firms laid off workers. 3. Free-market; interventionist; free-market; interventionist. 4. ¥40 billion. 5. Time lags: rate rises affect spending only after a year or more, or inflation may be cost-push, which higher rates do not remove. 6. Both: in the short run the spending adds to AD (G rises); in the long run better roads and rail cut costs and raise productivity, shifting LRAS right.
Supported transfer: Inflation, unemployment and policy judgement
Scope and prerequisite teaching
Issue 2, June 2018. All four units have a complete lettered objective map; IAS and IA2 target teaching authored; qualification rubric certified from recent WEC11–WEC14 schemes.
This focused rehearsal adopts the linked native explanations; it does not replace them or certify a whole qualification. Supported objective IDs: 2.3.6.1a, 2.3.6.1b, 2.3.6.1c, 2.3.6.1d, 2.3.6.1e, 2.3.6.1f, 2.3.6.2a, 2.3.6.2b, 2.3.6.2c, 2.3.6.2d, 2.3.6.3a, 2.3.6.3b, 2.3.6.3c, 2.3.6.3d, 2.3.6.4a, 2.3.6.4b, 2.3.6.4c, 2.3.6.4d, 2.3.6.4e.
Disinflation means slower price rises; deflation means a falling general price level. Unemployment requires the applicable labour-force definition; an inactive person is not automatically unemployed. Fiscal policy affects spending/taxation, monetary policy affects interest/monetary conditions, and supply-side measures target productive capability or incentives. The cause of the problem and lags matter.
Worked case
In a fictional economy, inflation falls from 8% to 3% while imported energy remains costly. Evaluate the claim that prices fell and that a higher policy rate repairs the energy shortage.
Positive inflation at 3% means the general price level still rises, more slowly than at 8%. A higher rate can reduce interest-sensitive spending, shifting AD left relative to the counterfactual; it does not itself increase energy supply. It may limit second-round demand pressure but can reduce output and employment. Effects depend on debt, confidence, exchange-rate responses and transmission lags. Compare targeted support or feasible supply measures, considering finance, incentives and implementation. A conditional judgement weighs the source of inflation and the cost of weak demand rather than declaring rates universally effective.
Independent transfer
A training programme is proposed during a demand-driven downturn. Give a short-run limitation, a longer-run mechanism and a qualified policy mix.
Checked original model
Training can improve skills and employability over time, especially where structural mismatch exists. It cannot by itself guarantee vacancies when firms lack demand, and completion/placement take time. Appropriate temporary demand support could complement training if finances, inflation and delivery allow, while targeted design checks actual vacancies and access. Evaluate employment outcomes rather than course enrolments alone. Explain trade-offs with budget, distribution and stability; this is authored evaluation, not a prescribed official essay formula.
Evidence and assessment limits
The tasks and marking points here are original, not official questions or mark schemes. The essay rubric follows the actual WEC11–WEC14 schemes (20-mark essays: 12 KAA + 8 evaluation, with Level-3 caps for missing diagram or context).