Riis takes readers up the stairs, 1890
- In How the Other Half Lives (1890), Jacob Riis wanted comfortable New Yorkers to support housing reform. Statistics on crowded tenements already existed, and readers ignored them. So Riis led them into a building: "Be a little careful, please! The hall is dark and you might stumble over the children pitching pennies back there."
- Riis chose narration because his readers' obstacle was not a lack of facts but a lack of feeling. Choose a method of development by asking: what stops this audience from accepting my claim?
Match the obstacle to the method
| The audience's obstacle | Method | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| They know the facts but do not feel them | narration | puts the reader inside one person's experience |
| They accept two facts but not the link between them | cause and effect | explains the step from A to B |
| They cannot picture something abstract | description | makes it visible with concrete detail |
| They misunderstand a key term | definition | fixes what the word must mean |

这种障碍需要哪种方法?
Match each audience obstacle to the method that removes it.
Match each audience obstacle to the best method.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
Choose by the obstacle, not the topic.
Why did Riis lead readers through a tenement instead of giving more statistics?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
Narration removes the obstacle of distance.
Writing narration well
- Keep the story short, choose the detail that carries your claim (Riis's children playing in a dark hall), and end on a reflection in your own voice that links the story to the argument.
- A story with no reflection is an anecdote, not evidence.
A narration paragraph is complete once the story is told.
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
End on a reflection that links the story to the claim.
Writing cause and effect well
- State the cause, state the effect, then spend most of your sentences on the step between them, because that step is what a reader can dispute.
- "Higher fees led to fewer students" is a claim. How (fees due in August, loans paid in October) is the development.
In a cause-and-effect paragraph, most sentences should explain the step between cause and effect.
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
That step is what a reader can dispute.
Worked example: same claim, two methods
Claim: The university's new fee deadline is driving poorer students away.
Narration (for readers who do not feel the problem): "Mei had her place, her loan letter and a train ticket. What she did not have, on 1 August, was the £900 deposit her loan would not pay until October. She stayed home."
Cause and effect (for readers who doubt the link): "The deposit is due on 1 August, but student loans arrive in October. Students without family savings must find the money from nowhere for two months, so the deadline, not the fee itself, is what turns them away."
- Why each works: the narration makes the reader feel the loss through one specific case; the cause-and-effect version proves the step (the timing gap) that a sceptic would question.
Do not choose a method because the topic "feels like" a story. Choose it because of what your audience needs. Check: what does this method do that another would not?
Choose a method of development by the audience's obstacle: narration when readers must feel a situation, cause and effect when they doubt a link, description when they cannot picture it, definition when a term is disputed. In cause and effect, develop the step between cause and effect; in narration, end on a reflection.
Practice. Claim: "Closing the town library hurts children most." Your readers agree the library is closing but think children can use the internet instead. Choose a method, say why, and write three sentences.
The obstacle chooses the method.