Economic methodology
Introduit| English | Sens |
|---|---|
| positive/ˈpɒzɪtɪv/ | positif |
| normative/ˈnɔːmətɪv/ | normatif |
| value judgement/ˈvæljuː ˈdʒʌdʒmənt/ | jugement de valeur |
| ceteris paribus/ˈsetərɪs ˈpærɪbəs/ | ceteris paribus |
| models/ˈmɒdlz/ | modèles |
| assumptions/əˈsʌmpʃnz/ | hypothèses |
Two sentences about the minimum wage
- "Raising the minimum wage by 10% reduced teenage employment by 1%." "The government should raise the minimum wage." The first can be checked against data; the second depends on what you think is fair.
- Economics is a social science: it studies how people make choices, using evidence and models, but it cannot run perfect laboratory experiments on whole economies. This lesson covers the tools economists use to think clearly.
Positive and normative statements
| Positive 实证的 | Normative 规范的 | |
|---|---|---|
| About | what is, was or will be | what ought to be |
| Can be tested? | yes, with evidence (it may be true or false) | no: it contains a value judgement 价值判断 |
| Signal words | is, will, causes, rose by | should, ought, fair, too high, better |
| Example | "Unemployment is 6%." | "The government ought to cut unemployment." |
- A positive statement can be wrong and still be positive: "Higher taxes always raise revenue" is testable, even though it is false.
Lab méthode économique
Classify statements by the role they play in economic reasoning.
Match each statement to its type.
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Testable facts are positive; judgements are normative.
"Higher taxes always raise revenue" is a normative statement because it is false.
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
It is positive, because it can be tested, even though it is false.
Ceteris paribus and models
- Ceteris paribus 其他条件不变 means "all other things being equal". Economists change one factor at a time and hold the rest constant: "a rise in price reduces quantity demanded, ceteris paribus" (income, tastes and other prices unchanged).
- A model 模型 is a simplified picture of reality, such as a demand-and-supply diagram, built on assumptions 假设 (for example, that consumers try to get the most satisfaction). A model is judged by how well it explains and predicts, not by being fully realistic.
What does ceteris paribus mean?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
It holds every other factor constant.
Time periods
| Period | What can change | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Short run | at least one factor of production is fixed | a café can hire more staff, but not move to a bigger shop |
| Long run | all factors of production can change | the café can open a second, larger shop |
| Very long run | technology and institutions can also change | new machines change how coffee is made and served |
Match each change to its time period.
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Short run has a fixed factor; long run has none; very long run changes technology.
Decisions at the margin
- Economists study marginal decisions: the effect of one more (or one less) unit. Should a firm make one more car? Should a student study one more hour?
- The rule: do one more unit if its extra benefit is greater than its extra cost. A student should study another hour if the gain in marks is worth more to them than the hour of free time given up.
One more hour of overtime earns a worker £15. The worker values that hour of free time at £20. What should the worker do, thinking at the margin?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
The extra cost (£20) is greater than the extra benefit (£15).
Worked exam answer
Distinguish between a positive and a normative statement, using an example of each from the market for cigarettes. [4]
A positive statement is about what is, and can be tested with evidence: "A 10% rise in the price of cigarettes reduces smoking by about 4%." A normative statement is about what ought to be and contains a value judgement: "The government should ban cigarettes." The first can be checked with data; the second depends on views about freedom and health, so it cannot be proved true or false.
- Why it scores: both definitions, one clear example of each from the same market, and an explanation of why each belongs to its type.
"Positive" does not mean "true" or "good". A positive statement is testable; it may turn out to be false. A normative statement is not "wrong", it is a judgement.
Economics is a social science. Positive statements are testable; normative statements contain value judgements. Ceteris paribus holds other factors constant; models simplify reality using assumptions. The short run has a fixed factor, the long run none, and the very long run allows new technology. Decisions are made at the margin: do one more unit if its extra benefit exceeds its extra cost.
Exam practice. A report says: "Unemployment is 6 percent. The government ought to cut this rate." Identify the positive and normative statements and explain your answer. [4]
Look for signal words such as ought and should.