Skip to content

IGCSE Physics · November 2021 · Paper 53 · Difficulty 3 · Standard

Question 1

1

In this experiment, you will investigate the effect of insulation on the cooling of water.

Carry out the following instructions, referring to Fig. 1.1.

Beaker A is covered with material that is a thermal insulator.

Beaker B is identical to beaker A but has no insulation.

Fig. 1.1
(a)

• Remove the lid from beaker A.

  • Pour $150\text{ cm}^3$ of hot water into beaker A and replace the lid.
  • Place the thermometer in the water in beaker A.

In the first row of Table 1.1, record the temperature $\theta$ of the water at $t = 0$ and immediately start the stop-clock.

Record, in Table 1.1, the temperature $\theta$ of the water at times $t = 30\text{ s}$, $t = 60\text{ s}$, $t = 90\text{ s}$, $t = 120\text{ s}$, $t = 150\text{ s}$ and $t = 180\text{ s}$.[1]

  • Remove the thermometer from the beaker.
(b)
(i)

Repeat (a) for beaker B.[2]

(ii)

Add units to the column headings in Table 1.1.[1]

Table 1.1

beaker A
with insulation
beaker B
without insulation
$t /$$\theta /$$\theta /$
0
30
60
90
120
150
180
(c)

Write a conclusion stating whether the insulation affects the rate of cooling of the water. Justify your answer by reference to values from your results.[2]

(d)
(i)

Calculate the average cooling rate $x_1$ during the first half of the experiment for the water in beaker B. Use your readings for beaker B from Table 1.1 and the equation

$$x_1 = \frac{\theta_0 - \theta_{90}}{T},$$

where $T = 90\text{ s}$ and $\theta_0$ and $\theta_{90}$ are the temperatures of the water in beaker B at $t = 0$ and $t = 90\text{ s}$.

Include the unit.

$x_1 =$ [1]

(ii)

Calculate the average cooling rate $x_2$ during the second half of the experiment for the water in beaker B. Use your readings for beaker B from Table 1.1 and the equation

$$x_2 = \frac{\theta_{90} - \theta_{180}}{T},$$

where $T = 90\text{ s}$ and $\theta_{90}$ and $\theta_{180}$ are the temperatures of the water in beaker B at $t = 90\text{ s}$ and $t = 180\text{ s}$.

Include the unit.

$x_2 =$ [1]

(e)
(i)

Suggest an additional experiment to test whether the lid affects the cooling rate of the water in beaker B. State how the readings are used to show the effect.

You are not required to carry out this additional experiment.[1]

(ii)

A student suggests that the temperature of the water in beaker B at $t = 0$ for this additional experiment must be the same as in (b)(i) for the comparison to be fair.

State whether your results support this suggestion.

Use your results from (d) to explain whether this precaution is necessary.

statement

explanation [2]

[Total: 11]

Show the mark scheme

These are the official mark-scheme rows. Each point that matches your answer earns a mark.

Tap the mark scheme to open it full size.

Show a worked answer

How to reach each mark, step by step. Try the question yourself first.

1(a)

  • Read the thermometer at each stated time and record each temperature to the nearest $1\,\mathrm{°C}$. The readings should fall as the water cools.
  • For example, readings at $0, 30, 60, 90, 120, 150, 180\,\mathrm{s}$ could be $\mathbf{80, 79, 78, 77, 76, 75, 74}\,\mathrm{°C}$. Use your own readings.

1(b)(i)

  • Repeat the measurements for beaker B and record the temperatures to at least the nearest $1\,\mathrm{°C}$. They should fall faster than those for A.
  • For example, at $0, 30, 60, 90, 120, 150, 180\,\mathrm{s}$, B could read $\mathbf{80, 78, 76, 74, 72.5, 71, 70}\,\mathrm{°C}$. Use your own readings.

1(b)(ii)

  • Time is measured in seconds and temperature in degrees Celsius. The headings are $t / \mathrm{s}$ and $\theta / {}^\circ\mathrm{C}$ for each beaker.

1(c)

  • Compare the temperature drops over $180\,\mathrm{s}$. For example, A might fall from $80$ to $74\,\mathrm{°C}$, while B falls from $80$ to $70\,\mathrm{°C}$.
  • A falls by $6\,\mathrm{°C}$ and B by $10\,\mathrm{°C}$ in the same time, so the insulation makes the water cool more slowly. Use your own results to decide.

1(d)(i)

  • Use $x_1 = (\theta_0-\theta_{90})/T$ with the readings for beaker B.
  • For example, if $\theta_0=80\,\mathrm{°C}$ and $\theta_{90}=74\,\mathrm{°C}$, then $x_1=(80-74)\,\mathrm{°C}/(90\,\mathrm{s})=\mathbf{0.067}\,\mathrm{°C/s}$. Use your own readings.

1(d)(ii)

  • Use $x_2 = (\theta_{90}-\theta_{180})/T$ with the readings for beaker B.
  • For example, if $\theta_{90}=74\,\mathrm{°C}$ and $\theta_{180}=70\,\mathrm{°C}$, then $x_2=(74-70)\,\mathrm{°C}/(90\,\mathrm{s})=\mathbf{0.044}\,\mathrm{°C/s}$. Use your own readings.

1(e)(i)

  • Repeat the experiment with beaker B without its lid. Calculate its cooling rate and compare it with the rate with the lid on.

1(e)(ii)

  • Compare your values of $x_1$ and $x_2$. For example, if $x_1=0.067\,\mathrm{°C/s}$ and $x_2=0.044\,\mathrm{°C/s}$, the results support the suggestion.
  • The water cools faster when it is hotter, so different starting temperatures could change the cooling rates even if the lid had no effect. Use your own results to decide.
Original question

Log in or create account

IGCSE, A-Level & AP