| English | 释义 | 拼音 |
|---|---|---|
| credibility/ˌkredɪˈbɪlɪti/ | 可信度 | kě xìn dù |
| concede/kənˈsiːd/ | 让步 | ràng bù |
| rebut/rɪˈbʌt/ | 反驳 | fǎn bó |
| refute/rɪˈfjuːt/ | 驳倒 | bó dǎo |
"Because a child has thrived upon milk", 1776
- In Common Sense (1776), Thomas Paine faced a popular argument: America had done well under Britain, so it should stay. He stated it fairly, then took it apart: "We may as well assert that because a child has thrived upon milk, that it is never to have meat." What worked in the colonies' childhood, he argued, proves nothing about their future.
- Strong arguments engage the views already in the conversation. Writers build credibility 可信度 when they concede 让步, rebut 反驳 or refute 驳倒 opposing arguments, and each move does a different job.
Three moves
| Move | What it does | Signal phrases | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Concede | accepts part of the opposing claim, or a limit of your own | "Admittedly...", "It is true that..." | "It is true that America has prospered under Britain." |
| Rebut | offers a contrasting view or other evidence | "However...", "Yet this ignores..." | "Yet this prosperity came from trade with Europe, not from British rule." |
| Refute | shows the opposing claim is false or its logic fails | "This does not follow, because..." | Paine's milk-and-meat analogy: past success does not prove future need |

Concede, rebut, or refute?
Sort each move by what the writer is doing to the opposing claim.
Match each sentence to its move.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
Accept, counter, or show the claim fails.
Paine compares America's past under Britain to a child thriving on milk. What does the analogy do?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
It refutes the logic of the opposing argument.
Why concede at all?
- Conceding shows the reader you have considered other views fairly, so they trust you more. It can also narrow your claim to the part you can actually defend.
- A concession usually leads into a rebuttal or refutation: "Admittedly X; however Y." The second half should carry more weight than the first.
Conceding a point always weakens your argument.
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
A fair concession followed by a response builds credibility.
Choose the move your evidence supports
- Refute only when you can show the opposing claim is false or illogical. Rebut when you have a strong alternative but cannot disprove the other side. Concede when the other side is partly right.
- Claiming to refute when you only have a contrasting opinion weakens your credibility.
You disagree with an opposing claim but have no evidence that it is false, only a strong alternative view. Which move fits?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
Refute only when you can show the claim is false or illogical.
Worked exam skill: a counterargument paragraph
Prompt: Argue whether students should be allowed to use AI tools for homework.
"Concede: Admittedly, AI tools can explain a hard idea in seconds, and banning them completely would ignore a skill students will need at work. Rebut: However, homework exists to make students practise, and a tool that writes the answer removes the practice that builds memory and skill. Refute: The claim that 'everyone will use AI anyway, so homework should allow it' does not follow: calculators are everywhere, yet students still learn arithmetic, because understanding is what lets them check the machine. So: schools should allow AI for explanations but not for producing the work that is marked."
- Why it scores: the concession is fair and specific; the rebuttal answers it with a reason; the refutation uses an analogy to show a flaw in logic; the conclusion is a qualified position, which helps the sophistication point.
Do not concede and then stop. An unanswered concession weakens your argument. Always follow it with why your position still stands.
Writers gain credibility by engaging opposing views. To concede is to accept part of a competing claim; to rebut is to offer a contrasting view or other evidence; to refute is to show the claim is false or illogical. Choose the move your evidence supports, and follow every concession with your answer.
Practice. Prompt: argue whether cities should build more parks or more housing. Write a counterargument paragraph that concedes, rebuts and ends with your position.
Concede, answer, conclude.