From "zoos are bad" to a thesis that wins
- An AP argument prompt asks: Do zoos do more good than harm? A student writes at once: "Zoos are bad for animals." Then they look at their evidence: some species, such as the Arabian oryx, survived only because zoos bred them and returned them to the wild. One counter-example, and the thesis falls.
- A strong thesis is usually refined after you check your evidence: made arguable, specific and qualified to the ground your evidence actually covers.
A thesis ladder
| Version | Problem |
|---|---|
| "Zoos are an important topic." | not arguable: nobody disagrees |
| "Zoos are bad for animals." | too broad: one success story defeats it |
| "Zoos harm large, wide-ranging animals." | specific, but gives no reason or line of reasoning |
| "Zoos do more good than harm only when they breed endangered species for release, because large animals kept simply for display suffer in spaces far smaller than their natural range." | arguable, specific, qualified, with reasons |

按顺序过三道论点关卡
A sentence can be beautifully arguable and still answer a prompt you were not set.
Put these theses in order from weakest to strongest.
难度 3/5 · 今日首次完成可获 200 金币及少量额外奖励
Arguable, then specific, then qualified with reasons.
Narrow it until it rules something out
- A useful thesis constrains what follows. Test: name a paragraph your thesis rules out. The final zoo thesis rules out a paragraph praising zoos as family entertainment; "Zoos are an important topic" rules out nothing.
- Qualifiers such as only when, for this group, where X holds name the ground your claim stands on. A qualified thesis is not weaker; it is defensible.
Thesis: "Zoos do good only when they breed endangered species for release." Which paragraph does it rule out?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
A useful thesis rules some paragraphs out.
Four checks before you write
- (1) Could a reasonable person disagree? (2) Does it answer the prompt as asked? (3) Does my evidence reach this far? (4) Can I name a paragraph it rules out?
- If the evidence does not support your first thesis while you draft, change the thesis. There are no marks for predicting your own conclusion.
Which questions belong in the four thesis checks?
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
The fourth check is whether it rules a paragraph out.
Worked example: fitting the thesis to the evidence
Prompt: Should schools require students to do community service?
Evidence the student has: a survey from their own school's Year 11, where 70% of volunteers said it helped them choose a career; a news report of students forced to volunteer who did the minimum.
First thesis: "All schools should require community service." (The evidence covers one year group and shows forced service can fail.)
Refined thesis: "Schools should offer community service as a credit-bearing choice for older students rather than a requirement, because the benefits come from students who choose to serve, while forced hours produce only box-ticking."
- Why it scores: the thesis now matches what the evidence can prove, takes a clear position, and previews a line of reasoning (chosen service helps; forced service fails).
All your evidence comes from Year 11 students, but your thesis is about the whole school. What should you do?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
The thesis must match what the evidence can prove.
Do not write the thesis before you look at the evidence. Plan first; then write the thesis that your evidence can defend.
Refine a thesis until it is arguable, specific enough to rule something out, and qualified to the ground your evidence covers, with reasons that preview the line of reasoning. Check it against your evidence, and change it if the evidence points elsewhere.
Practice. Refine this thesis using the ladder: "Fast food is unhealthy." Write the final version with a qualifier and a reason.
Arguable, specific, qualified.