| English | 释义 | 拼音 |
|---|---|---|
| line of reasoning/laɪn ɒv ˈriːzənɪŋ/ | 推理线索 | tuī lǐ xiàn suǒ |
| specious/ˈspiːʃəs/ | 似是而非 | sì shì ér fēi |
An argument built like a proof, 1776
- The Declaration of Independence is famous for its words about equality, but its structure is what made it persuasive. It moves in three steps: a principle about what governments are for, a long list of the king's actions, and the conclusion that the colonies are free to separate. Shuffle those parts and the argument collapses.
- A line of reasoning 推理线索 is the path from claim to claim that leads a reader to the writer's conclusion. Describing it is a skill the exam tests in multiple-choice and rhetorical analysis questions.
The Declaration's path
| Step | What it says | Job in the reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Principle | governments exist to secure rights such as "Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness"; when a government destroys them, the people may "alter or to abolish it" | the general rule the reader is asked to accept |
| 2. Evidence | a list of more than twenty actions by the king, each introduced with "He has..." | facts showing this government has destroyed those rights |
| 3. Conclusion | the colonies "are, and of Right ought to be Free and Independent States" | follows if steps 1 and 2 are accepted |
- The reasoning is deductive: if the principle is true and the facts fit it, the conclusion must follow. A reader who accepts step 1 is led towards step 3.
Put the steps of the Declaration's reasoning in order.
难度 3/5 · 今日首次完成可获 200 金币及少量额外奖励
Principle, evidence, conclusion.
Two legitimate orders
- Some writers state the claim first and then justify it. Others lead readers through reasoning and only then arrive at the thesis, as the Declaration does.
- Do not assume every text follows the "thesis first" shape you were taught to write.

路径、堆叠,还是缺陷?
Sort each essay structure by what it has.
A writer must always state the thesis before giving the reasoning.
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
Some writers lead the reader through reasoning and arrive at the thesis.
How to describe a line of reasoning
- Step 1: write one sentence per paragraph or section, saying what it does (establishes a principle, gives evidence, answers an objection, draws a conclusion), not only what it says.
- Step 2: read your list and name the links: "because", "therefore", "however". The links are the reasoning.
Match each section to what it does in an argument.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
Describe what each section does, not only what it says.
Worked exam skill: answering a reasoning question
Question: How does the list of the king's actions function in the Declaration's argument?
Answer: The list supplies the evidence that the general principle applies to this case. Having argued that people may abolish a government that destroys their rights, the writers must show that the king's government has done exactly that; the repeated "He has..." builds a record so long that the conclusion, independence, appears forced by the facts rather than chosen.
- Why it works: it names the function of the section (evidence for the principle), links it to the steps before and after, and comments on how the repetition strengthens the reasoning.
A flaw in reasoning is a step that does not follow, not just a false fact. A reasoning can be specious 似是而非 (it looks sound but is not), for example when the evidence does not actually match the principle it is meant to prove.
Which is a flaw in reasoning?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
The step from evidence to conclusion does not follow.
A line of reasoning is the sequence of claims that leads to a conclusion. Writers may state the thesis first or arrive at it. Describe reasoning by saying what each section does and naming the links between them. A flaw is a step that does not follow, which can make an argument specious.
Practice. An editorial has four paragraphs: (1) libraries are the only free indoor public space; (2) teenagers in our town have nowhere safe to go after school; (3) some say libraries should stay quiet, but a separate study room solves that; (4) the library should open until 8 p.m. Describe the line of reasoning in two or three sentences.
Function and links, not summary.