Three facts, one paragraph
- A student arguing that cities should charge for plastic bags has three pieces of evidence: about 9% of all plastic ever made has been recycled (Geyer and colleagues, 2017); after Ireland put a 15-cent levy on plastic bags in 2002, their use fell by over 90%; and the student once counted 40 bags on one beach. Which should go in the paragraph, and why?
- Before you use any evidence, finish this sentence: I am using this because it... If you cannot finish it, the evidence has been found, not chosen.
The jobs evidence can do
| Job | When you need it | From the plastic-bag set |
|---|---|---|
| Prove the problem exists | readers doubt there is a problem | only about 9% of plastic is recycled |
| Prove the solution works | readers accept the problem but doubt your fix | Ireland's levy cut bag use by over 90% |
| Make it concrete | the claim feels abstract | 40 bags on one beach |
| Build credibility | readers may doubt you | a named study or a government result |
Why was this piece chosen?
Match each piece of evidence to the reason it earns its place.
Match each piece of evidence to the job it does in an argument for a plastic-bag charge.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
Choose evidence for the job the claim needs.
Choose by the claim, then cut
- The paragraph's claim decides the evidence. If the claim is "a charge changes behaviour", the Ireland result does the main work; the recycling figure proves a different point.
- Two pieces doing the same job are one piece and wasted words. Under time pressure, one well-explained piece beats three listed ones.

Claim: "A charge changes behaviour more than a request does." Which evidence fits best?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
It directly shows a charge changing behaviour.
Worked paragraph
Claim: A small charge changes behaviour more than a request does.
Evidence (chosen to prove the solution works): when Ireland added a 15-cent levy to plastic bags in 2002, use fell by over 90%.
Commentary (from the reason it was chosen): this matters because shoppers had been asked for years to bring their own bags with little effect; a cost of a few cents, felt at the moment of choosing, achieved what appeals could not. A city that wants fewer bags therefore needs a price, not a poster.
- Why it works: the reason the evidence was chosen ("it proves a charge works") became the first sentence of the commentary. The beach count and the recycling figure belong in other paragraphs, or nowhere.
From reason to commentary
- The reason you chose a piece of evidence is the start of your commentary: "I chose this because it shows X" becomes "This matters because it shows X".
- Check: read the claim and the commentary, skipping the evidence. Do they still connect? If the commentary only makes sense with the quotation in view, it is summary.
You chose a quotation "because it shows the risk was known in advance". What is the best first sentence of commentary?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
The reason for choosing becomes the commentary.
More evidence is not safer. Each piece must do a job the others do not. A list of statistics with no commentary scores lower than one statistic explained well.
Including three statistics that prove the same point is stronger than one statistic with two sentences of commentary.
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
Repeated evidence leaves no room for the commentary that earns marks.
Choose evidence for a stated reason: to prove a problem, prove a solution, make a claim concrete, or build credibility. Let the paragraph's claim decide which piece fits, and cut evidence that repeats a job. The reason you chose a piece becomes the first sentence of your commentary.
Practice. Claim: "Schools should start later for teenagers." Evidence available: (a) the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends secondary schools start at 8:30 a.m. or later; (b) a student says they feel tired in first period; (c) teenagers' body clocks shift later in adolescence. Choose ONE, say why, and write two sentences of commentary.
Choose for a job, then explain.