| English | 释义 | 拼音 |
|---|---|---|
| Commentary/ˈkɒməntri/ | 评述 | píng shù |
The quotation is there; the marks are not
- In the AP evidence-and-commentary row (0–4 points), a 2-point essay usually has evidence. What it lacks is commentary: sentences explaining how the evidence proves the point. Readers see the quotation, but not why the student thinks it matters.
- A strong body paragraph has three working parts: an arguable claim, embedded evidence, and commentary 评述 that connects them.
The three parts
| Part | Job | Test |
|---|---|---|
| Claim | states the point of this paragraph, narrower than the thesis | could a reasonable person disagree? |
| Evidence | specific facts, examples or short quotations, built into your sentence | is it specific (a name, number, date or exact words)? |
| Commentary | explains how the evidence supports the claim | does it begin with "because", "so", "which means", "this shows"? |

按比例搭一个段落
The commonest failure is a paragraph where the evidence is present and the explanation is absent.
Match each sentence to its part of the paragraph.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
Point, proof, explanation.
Embed, then explain
- Introduce evidence inside your own sentence and quote only the words you will discuss. A long quotation you never analyse costs time and earns nothing.
- Start commentary with a word that forces a relationship: because, which means, so, the effect of this is. These words cannot be followed by a simple restatement.
Which sentence is real commentary?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
It explains how the evidence supports the claim.
It is better to quote a whole paragraph from a source than only the words you will discuss.
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
Quote only what you analyse; long quotations waste time.
Worked revision: from 2 points to 4
Prompt: Argue whether new technology always improves people's lives.
Weak (evidence without commentary): "Technology does not always help people. In the early 1800s, English textile workers called Luddites broke new weaving machines. This shows technology is not always good."
Strong: "New technology can improve a society while ruining the people it replaces. When power looms spread through England's textile towns in the early 1800s, cloth became far cheaper, yet skilled hand-weavers saw their wages collapse, and some, the Luddites, smashed the machines in protest. Their anger was not ignorance of progress: the same invention that clothed the country more cheaply took away the skill that had fed their families, which means that whether technology 'improves lives' depends on whose lives we count."
- Why the second scores higher: the claim is precise and arguable; the evidence is specific (power looms, wages, the Luddites); the commentary explains the mechanism (cheaper cloth vs lost skill) and links back to the prompt's word "lives".
Put the parts of a strong body paragraph in a typical order.
难度 3/5 · 今日首次完成可获 200 金币及少量额外奖励
Claim, evidence, commentary, link.
Check your own paragraph
- Cover the evidence: does the claim still make sense? It should. Delete the commentary: does the paragraph still say the same? If so, you had no commentary.
- Aim for at least as many words of commentary as of evidence.
"This shows that..." followed by the claim again is not commentary. Commentary must say how or why the evidence proves the claim.
A body paragraph needs an arguable claim, specific embedded evidence, and commentary that explains how the evidence supports the claim. Commentary earns most of the 4 evidence-and-commentary points: start it with because, so or which means, and give it at least as many words as the evidence.
Practice. Prompt: argue whether mobile phones should be banned in schools. Write one body paragraph with a claim, one piece of specific evidence, and at least two sentences of commentary.
Commentary should be at least as long as the evidence.