Skip to content

Poverty, the state and development

Pearson Edexcel · International A-Level · Economics · Topic 8

Video lesson for this topic Open the video page
30:21

Poverty, the state and development

Why it matters. In 1981 about 88% of China's people lived below the World Bank's extreme-poverty line of the time. On 25 February 2021 China's government…

English narration · English and 中文 subtitles you can switch

8.1

Poverty, the state and development

Why it matters. In 1981 about 88% of China's people lived below the World Bank's extreme-poverty line of the time. On 25 February 2021 China's government announced that extreme poverty in the countryside had been eliminated: by its own national line of 2,300 yuan a year (at 2010 prices), almost 99 million rural people had left poverty since 2012 alone. No country has reduced poverty so fast or for so many people. Yet over the same years income inequality in China rose to one of the highest levels in Asia. Fast growth lifted the poorest out of poverty without making incomes more equal. This unit explains how economists measure poverty and inequality, how governments tax, spend and borrow, and why some countries develop while others stay poor.

In this unit you will:

  • distinguish absolute from relative poverty and explain what changes them;
  • measure inequality with a Lorenz curve and calculate a Gini coefficient;
  • classify public spending and taxes, and use the Laffer curve;
  • distinguish a fiscal deficit from the national debt, and structural from cyclical deficits;
  • evaluate macroeconomic policies and the problems policymakers face;
  • measure development with the HDI, explain the constraints on growth and evaluate development strategies.
8.1

Poverty

Absolute poverty 绝对贫困 means a person cannot afford basic needs: food, clean water, shelter and clothing. The World Bank's international extreme-poverty line was updated in June 2025 to 3.00 dollars per person per day, measured at 2021 purchasing power parity 购买力平价 (PPP), so that it buys the same basket in every country. When you compare poverty figures, state the line, the PPP year and the date.

Relative poverty 相对贫困 means being poor compared with others in the same society. The UK and the EU count a household as poor if its income is below 60% of the median 中位数 household income. Relative poverty can rise when everyone is getting richer, if the poorest gain more slowly than the middle.

Worked example: absolute and relative lines. In a country the median household income is 30,000 a year.

  • The relative poverty line at 60% of the median is $0.6 \times 30{,}000 = 18{,}000$.
  • Ten years later the median has risen to 40,000. The relative line rises to $0.6 \times 40{,}000 = 24{,}000$.
  • A household whose income rose from 17,000 to 22,000 has escaped absolute poverty if the absolute line is fixed below 17,000, but it is still in relative poverty: 22,000 is below 24,000.
An income distribution with the absolute poverty line of 3.00 dollars a day at 2021 PPP near the bottom and a relative line set as a share of the median; the relative line moves when the median moves
The absolute line is a fixed amount near the bottom of the distribution; the relative line is a share of the median, so it moves when the median moves.

What changes poverty?

  • Economic growth raises incomes and usually cuts absolute poverty, but relative poverty falls only if the poor share in the gains.
  • Education and training raise the earnings of the poor.
  • Welfare benefits 福利 and cash transfers: Brazil's Bolsa Família, begun in 2003, paid poor families a monthly sum if their children attended school and had vaccinations; by 2013 it reached about 14 million families.
  • Changes in the tax system, for example a higher tax-free allowance.
  • Structural change 结构性变化: when coal mines and steel works close, whole regions fall behind, as in northern England in the 1980s and north-east China in the 1990s.
  • Aid, and civil wars and conflict, which destroy farms, schools and jobs: Syria and Yemen saw poverty rise sharply in the 2010s.
Vocabulary Train
English
absolute poverty/ˈæbsəluːt ˈpɒvəti/
purchasing power parity/ˈpɜːtʃɪsɪŋ ˈpaʊə ˈpærɪti/
relative poverty/ˈrelətɪv ˈpɒvəti/
median/ˈmiːdiːən/
welfare benefits
structural change
8.1

Inequality

Wealth inequality 财富不平等 is unequal ownership of assets: houses, land, shares and savings. Wealth is a stock. Income inequality 收入不平等 is unequal flows of wages, profits, rent and interest. Wealth is usually far more unequal than income, because wealth earns income and can be passed on through inheritance 继承.

The Lorenz curve 洛伦兹曲线 plots the cumulative share of income against the cumulative share of households, from the poorest upwards. If income were shared equally, the curve would be the 45° line of equality 绝对平等线. The further the curve sags below that line, the more unequal the incomes. The Gini coefficient 基尼系数 measures the sag:

$$\text{Gini} = \frac{\text{area between the line of equality and the Lorenz curve}}{\text{whole area below the line of equality}}$$

It runs from 0 (everyone has the same income) to 1 (one household has everything). South Africa's Gini is about 0.63, among the highest in the world; Slovakia's is about 0.24, among the lowest. China's official Gini peaked at 0.49 in 2008 and was still about 0.47 in 2022.

Worked example: a Gini from quintile shares. The poorest 20% of households receive 5% of income, the next 20% receive 10%, then 15%, 20%, and the richest 20% receive 50%.

  1. Cumulative points: (0, 0), (20, 5), (40, 15), (60, 30), (80, 50), (100, 100).
  2. The area under the Lorenz curve is five trapezoids, each 20 wide: $\tfrac{0+5}{2}\times 20 + \tfrac{5+15}{2}\times 20 + \tfrac{15+30}{2}\times 20 + \tfrac{30+50}{2}\times 20 + \tfrac{50+100}{2}\times 20$.
  3. That is $50 + 200 + 450 + 800 + 1500 = 3000$.
  4. The area under the line of equality is $\tfrac{1}{2} \times 100 \times 100 = 5000$.
  5. Gini $= \tfrac{5000 - 3000}{5000} = 0.40$: a fairly unequal distribution.
The Lorenz curve and Gini coefficient
Quintile shares of 5, 10, 15, 20 and 50 per cent give a Lorenz curve with a Gini coefficient of 0.40.

Causes of inequality within a country: differences in skills and education, so wages differ; differences in wealth and inheritance; weak trade unions or low minimum wages; tax and benefit systems that redistribute little; and globalisation and technology, which raise the pay of skilled workers more than that of unskilled ones. Causes between countries: different histories of growth, institutions, geography, and access to world markets and capital.

Impacts of inequality:

  • some inequality gives incentives to work, train and start firms;
  • very high inequality can waste talent, because poor children cannot afford good schooling;
  • the rich save more of their income, so high inequality can hold back consumption;
  • it pushes people to migrate in search of better pay;
  • it is linked with gaps in health and life expectancy 预期寿命, and with crime and lower trust.

The economist Simon Kuznets suggested in 1955 that inequality first rises as a country industrialises, because a few people move into well-paid factory and city jobs, and then falls as most workers make the move: the Kuznets curve 库兹涅茨曲线. Free-market economies reward scarce skills and the owners of capital, so they create inequality as a side effect of the incentives that make them grow.

Homes of different kinds close to one another
A favela beside wealthier districts of Rio de Janeiro: income and wealth inequality in one view.
Vocabulary Train
English
wealth inequality/welθ ɪniːˈkwɒlɪti/
income inequality/ˈɪŋkʌm ɪniːˈkwɒlɪti/
inheritance/ɪnˈherɪtəns/
Lorenz curve/ˈlɒrənts kɜːv/
line of equality
Gini coefficient/ˈdʒiːni ˌkəʊɪˈfɪʃənt/
life expectancy/laɪf ekˈspektənsi/
Kuznets curve
8.1

Public expenditure, taxation and borrowing

Government spending comes in three kinds:

  • capital expenditure 资本支出: spending on assets that last, such as railways, hospitals and schools;
  • current expenditure 经常性支出: day-to-day running costs, such as teachers' and nurses' pay and medicines;
  • transfer payments 转移支付: pensions and benefits, which move income from taxpayers to others without buying any output.

The size of the state differs widely: general government spending was about 57% of GDP in France in 2023 and under 20% in Singapore. Spending tends to rise as countries get richer (people want more health care and education) and as populations age: more than 29% of Japan's people were 65 or over in 2023, and pensions and health care take a growing share of its budget. Its effects depend on what it buys. Spending on infrastructure and education can raise productivity 生产率 and growth; high spending financed by borrowing can cause crowding out 挤出效应, where government borrowing pushes up interest rates and reduces private investment; and high spending needs high taxes, which may weaken incentives.

Direct taxes 直接税 fall on income and wealth: income tax, corporation tax, inheritance tax. Indirect taxes 间接税 fall on spending: VAT (13% standard rate in China), excise duties on fuel, alcohol and tobacco. A tax system can be:

  • progressive 累进税: the average tax rate rises as income rises. China's income tax rises in bands from 3% to 45%;
  • proportional 比例税: everyone pays the same share of income;
  • regressive 累退税: the average rate falls as income rises. Taxes on tobacco take a bigger share of a poor smoker's income than of a rich smoker's.

Worked example: classifying taxes.

Income Tax paid (scheme X) Average rate Tax paid (scheme Y) Average rate
10,000 1,000 10% 5,000 50%
40,000 8,000 20% 5,000 12.5%
100,000 30,000 30% 5,000 5%

Scheme X is progressive: the average rate rises. Scheme Y, a fixed charge of 5,000 on everyone, is strongly regressive, even though everyone pays the same amount. A flat 25% on every income would be proportional.

Average tax rates by income
Average tax rates by income: rising under a progressive scheme, flat under a proportional one, falling under a regressive one.

A change in tax rates affects incentives to work, government revenue, the distribution of income, real output and employment, the price level (indirect taxes raise prices), the trade balance (lower taxes raise spending on imports) and inflows of FDI (low corporation tax attracts TNCs). The Laffer curve 拉弗曲线, named after the US economist Arthur Laffer, shows that above some rate a higher tax rate raises less revenue, because people work less, avoid tax or move away.

Worked example: the Laffer model. Suppose revenue $= t(1 - t) \times 400$, where $t$ is the tax rate.

  • At $t = 0.3$: revenue $= 0.3 \times 0.7 \times 400 = 84$.
  • At $t = 0.5$: revenue $= 0.5 \times 0.5 \times 400 = 100$, the maximum.
  • At $t = 0.7$: revenue $= 0.7 \times 0.3 \times 400 = 84$.

Raising the rate from 50% to 70% loses 16 of revenue. In practice nobody knows where the peak is. The UK cut its top income-tax rate from 50% to 45% in 2013 partly on evidence that high earners had moved income to avoid the 50% rate.

The Laffer curve
In the model, revenue t(1 − t) × 400 peaks at 100 when the rate is 50%; 30% and 70% raise the same 84.

Borrowing. A fiscal deficit 财政赤字 is the gap in one year between government spending and tax revenue. The national debt 国债 is the total amount the government owes, built up from past deficits. The deficit is a flow; the debt is a stock. Japan's government debt is about 250% of GDP, the highest among rich countries.

Worked example: debt as a share of GDP. Debt is 900 and GDP is 1,000, so debt is 90% of GDP. Next year the deficit is 50 and nominal GDP grows by 5%. Debt becomes $900 + 50 = 950$ and GDP $1{,}050$: $\tfrac{950}{1050} \times 100 \approx 90.5\%$. A deficit raises the debt, but faster GDP growth can keep the ratio nearly flat.

  • Automatic stabilisers 自动稳定器 change the budget without any decision: in a recession tax revenue falls and benefit spending rises, which supports demand.
  • Discretionary fiscal policy 相机抉择的财政政策 is a deliberate change in tax rates or spending.
  • A cyclical deficit 周期性赤字 exists only because the economy is in a downturn and disappears in recovery. A structural deficit 结构性赤字 remains even at full employment. If the actual deficit is 5% of GDP and 2 percentage points of it are cyclical, the structural deficit is 3% of GDP.

Deficits and debt grow in recessions, with banking rescues (Ireland's deficit reached 32% of GDP in 2010 after it saved its banks) and as populations age. They matter because of interest rates (heavy borrowing can raise them and crowd out investment), debt interest 债务利息 that takes money from schools and hospitals, the country's credit rating 信用评级, and intergenerational equity 代际公平: borrowing today must be repaid by tomorrow's taxpayers. In 2010 Greece, with debt above 140% of GDP and markets refusing to lend, had to accept rescue loans with deep spending cuts.

Vocabulary Train
English
capital expenditure/ˈkæpɪtl ekˈspendɪtʃə/
current expenditure
transfer payments/ˈtrænsfɜː ˈpeɪmənts/
productivity/ˌprɒdəkˈtɪvɪti/
crowding out/ˈkraʊdɪŋ aʊt/
direct taxes
indirect taxes/ɪndaɪˈrekt ˈtæksɪz/
progressive/prəˈɡresɪv/
proportional/prəˈpɔːʃənl/
regressive/rɪˈɡresɪv/
Laffer curve/ˈlæfə kɜːv/
fiscal deficit/ˈfɪskl ˈdefɪsɪt/
national debt/ˈnæʃənl det/
automatic stabilisers
discretionary fiscal policy
cyclical deficit
structural deficit/ˈstrʌktʃərəl ˈdefɪsɪt/
debt interest
credit rating
intergenerational equity
8.1

Macroeconomic policies and the state

Governments use fiscal policy, monetary policy, exchange-rate policy, supply-side policies and direct controls 直接管制 (price or wage controls, limits on bank lending) to reduce deficits and debt, control inflation, respond to external shocks and cut poverty and inequality.

The 2008 global financial crisis. Banks failed, credit froze and world output fell in 2009. Governments responded with demand-side policies: the US, UK and others rescued banks; central banks cut interest rates close to zero and began quantitative easing 量化宽松; China launched its ¥4 trillion stimulus. During the COVID-19 lockdowns of 2020 the UK went further: its furlough scheme paid 80% of the wages of workers who could not work, up to £2,500 a month.

Controlling TNCs. TNCs can cut their tax bills by transfer pricing 转移定价: a subsidiary in a high-tax country buys inputs or brand rights at inflated prices from a subsidiary in a low-tax country, so profits appear where taxes are low. Governments respond with rules that prices between subsidiaries must match market prices, and in 2021 about 136 countries agreed a global minimum corporate tax 全球最低企业税 of 15%. The limits: TNCs can move production, and countries compete to attract them.

A policy decided in one place affects others: a US interest-rate rise strengthens the dollar and raises the cost of dollar debts in poor countries. Policymakers also face inaccurate information (GDP figures are revised for years), time lags, risks and uncertainty, and external shocks they cannot control, such as the jump in energy prices after Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022.

Vocabulary Train
English
direct controls
quantitative easing/ˈkwɒntɪteɪtɪv ˈiːzɪŋ/
transfer pricing/ˈtrænsfɜː ˈpraɪsɪŋ/
global minimum corporate tax
8.2

Growth and development

Economic growth is a rise in real GDP. Economic development 经济发展 is a wider improvement in people's lives: health, education, freedom and the chance to live a long and decent life. The Human Development Index 人类发展指数 (HDI), published by the UN Development Programme since 1990, combines three indices, each between 0 and 1:

  • health: life expectancy at birth;
  • education: mean years of schooling of adults and expected years of schooling of children;
  • income: GNI per head 人均国民总收入 at PPP, on a log scale, so each extra dollar counts for less in a rich country.

The HDI is the geometric mean 几何平均数 of the three: $\text{HDI} = \sqrt[3]{\text{health} \times \text{education} \times \text{income}}$. In the 2023/24 report Switzerland ranked first at 0.967; China scored 0.788 and India 0.644.

Worked example: why a geometric mean? A country's health index is 0.90, education 0.70 and income 0.80.

  • $\text{HDI} = \sqrt[3]{0.90 \times 0.70 \times 0.80} = \sqrt[3]{0.504} \approx 0.796$.
  • The ordinary average would be $\tfrac{0.90 + 0.70 + 0.80}{3} = 0.80$.
  • The geometric mean is lower because one weak dimension pulls it down: a country cannot make up for poor schooling with high income.
Health, education and income indices, each between 0 and 1, combined by a geometric mean into the HDI; it hides distribution, freedom, environment and gender gaps
Health, education and income indices, each between 0 and 1, combine by a geometric mean into the HDI.

The HDI is broader than GDP per head, easy to compare and simple to understand. But it is an average, so it hides inequality; it leaves out political freedom, the environment and gender gaps; and the data for poor countries can be weak. Other measures of development include the share of adult men working in agriculture, the share of people with clean water, energy use per head, and mobile phones, internet users and doctors per thousand people.

An aerial view of a busy market in a developing economy
A tomato market in Lagos, Nigeria: growth raises output, development asks whether lives improve.

Economic constraints on growth and development:

  • primary product dependency 初级产品依赖: copper earns about 70% of Zambia's export revenue, so a price fall cuts its income. By the Prebisch–Singer hypothesis 普雷维什-辛格假说, prices of primary products tend to fall over time compared with prices of manufactures, so the terms of trade of commodity exporters worsen;
  • volatile commodity prices, which make incomes and tax revenue unpredictable;
  • the savings gap 储蓄缺口: by the Harrod–Domar model 哈罗德-多马模型, growth = savings ratio ÷ capital–output ratio, and poor households save little;
  • the foreign currency gap 外汇缺口: too few exports to pay for imported machines and fuel;
  • capital flight 资本外逃: the rich move their savings abroad;
  • fast population growth, high debt, little access to credit, poor infrastructure, and low levels of education and skills.

Worked example: the savings gap. A country saves 12% of GDP and needs 4 units of capital for each extra unit of output.

  • Growth $= \tfrac{12\%}{4} = 3\%$ a year.
  • If the population also grows by 3% a year, GDP per head does not grow at all.
  • To grow GDP per head by 2%, GDP must grow by 5%, which needs savings of $5\% \times 4 = 20\%$ of GDP. The gap of 8 percentage points must come from abroad (FDI, aid or loans) or from more saving at home.

Non-economic constraints: corruption 腐败, poor governance, civil war (South Sudan has been at war for most years since independence in 2011), migration of skilled workers abroad, and terrorism.

Development strategies

Type Strategies Real example
market-orientated 市场导向 trade liberalisation, attracting FDI, removing subsidies, privatisation, floating exchange rates, microfinance 小额信贷 Shenzhen special economic zone from 1980; Grameen Bank's small loans to poor women in Bangladesh (Nobel Peace Prize 2006)
interventionist 干预主义 spending on education and health, protection of infant industries, managed exchange rates, infrastructure, joint ventures 合资企业 with TNCs, buffer stocks 缓冲库存 South Korea's state-backed steel, ships and cars in the 1960s–80s; the International Tin Agreement's buffer stock, which collapsed in 1985
other industrialisation, tourism, developing primary industries, debt relief 债务减免, aid Botswana's diamond-funded growth; the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries debt relief from 1996

The Lewis dual-sector model 刘易斯二元经济模型 explains industrialisation. A poor economy has a large farm sector with surplus labour, where extra workers add almost nothing to output, and a small modern sector. Factories can hire workers from the farms at wages a little above farm incomes. Their profits are reinvested, the modern sector grows and draws in more workers, and output per head rises. China's roughly 300 million rural migrant workers are the largest example. The model assumes that surplus labour exists and that profits are reinvested at home rather than sent abroad.

International institutions also act:

  • the World Bank 世界银行 lends for long-term projects such as roads, power and schools, often at low interest rates;
  • the International Monetary Fund 国际货币基金组织 (IMF) lends to countries in a balance-of-payments crisis, with conditionality 附加条件: the loans come with required policies, such as cutting deficits or floating the currency, as in Egypt's 2024 programme;
  • non-governmental organisations 非政府组织 (NGOs), such as BRAC in Bangladesh, run local schools, health clinics and small-loan schemes.
Vocabulary Train
English
economic development/ˌiːkəˈnɒmɪk dɪˈveləpmənt/
Human Development Index/ˈhjuːmən dɪˈveləpmənt ˈɪndeks/
GNI per head
geometric mean
primary product dependency/ˈpraɪməri ˈprɒdʌkt dɪˈpendənsi/
Prebisch–Singer hypothesis
savings gap/ˈseɪvɪŋz ɡæp/
Harrod–Domar model
foreign currency gap
capital flight/ˈkæpɪtl flaɪt/
corruption
market-orientated/ˈmɑːkɪt ˈɔːrɪənteɪtɪd/
microfinance/ˌmaɪkrəʊfaɪˈnæns/
interventionist/ˌɪntəˈvenʃənɪst/
joint ventures/dʒɔɪnt ˈventʃəz/
buffer stocks
debt relief
Lewis dual-sector model/ˈluːɪs ˈdjuːəl ˈsektə ˈmɒdl/
World Bank/wɜːld bæŋk/
International Monetary Fund/ˌɪntəˈnæʃənl ˈmʌnɪtəri fʌnd/
conditionality
non-governmental organisations
8.2

Data-response practice (Section B style)

Extract. Bangladesh has been one of the world's fastest-growing economies since 2000, with real GDP growth often above 6% a year. Ready-made garments earn more than 80% of its export revenue, and the industry employs about four million workers, most of them women who moved from farms to factories in the cities. Extreme poverty has fallen sharply, and life expectancy is now above 70 years. But wages in the garment industry are among the lowest in the world, and in 2013 the collapse of the Rana Plaza factory building killed more than 1,100 workers. In 2026 Bangladesh is due to leave the United Nations' list of Least Developed Countries, which means losing some tariff-free access to markets such as the EU over the following years.

Stacked bars comparing the sector shares of workers in a developing and a developed country
As a country develops, workers shift out of the primary sector and into the secondary and then the tertiary (services) sector.

Questions

  • (a) Bangladesh's GDP is about US$450 billion and its population about 173 million. Calculate GDP per head. [2]
  • (b) Explain two limitations of GDP per head as a measure of development, using the extract. [4]
  • (c) Explain, with reference to the Lewis dual-sector model, how the growth of the garment industry has helped to reduce poverty. [6]
  • (d) Examine two risks of Bangladesh's dependence on garment exports. [8]
  • (e) Evaluate the policies Bangladesh could use to keep developing after it loses its Least Developed Country status. [12]

Model answers

(a) $\tfrac{450 \text{ billion}}{173 \text{ million}} \approx \$2{,}600$ per head.

(b) It hides distribution: an average says nothing about whether garment workers, many on very low wages, share in the growth. It ignores quality of life and working conditions: GDP counts the output of unsafe factories in the same way as safe ones; the Rana Plaza deaths and long hours do not lower GDP. (Also: it omits health and education, which the HDI includes, and it is not adjusted for purchasing power unless PPP is used.)

(c) The Lewis model has a large traditional (farming) sector with surplus labour, whose marginal product is close to zero, and a modern (industrial) sector. Factories can hire workers from the farms at a wage only a little above farm incomes. As garment firms grow, workers move to the cities, total output rises, and the profits are reinvested in more factories, so the modern sector keeps expanding. Workers, especially women, earn more than on farms, which reduces poverty and gives them more independence. Evaluation: the model assumes profits are reinvested at home and that there is surplus labour; once surplus labour runs out, wages must rise.

(d) Demand and price risk: if world demand for clothes falls (a recession in the EU or US) or buyers move orders to cheaper countries, export revenue and jobs fall sharply, because there is little else to export. Loss of preferential access: leaving the Least Developed Country list means facing tariffs in some markets, which raises prices for buyers and could cut orders. Also: automation could replace low-wage sewing jobs. Evaluation: the risks are smaller if firms move into higher-value products and if Bangladesh signs new trade agreements.

(e) Diversification: developing new export industries (electronics, pharmaceuticals, food processing) reduces dependence on garments. This needs infrastructure (ports, power, roads) and skills, which take time and money.

Human capital: more spending on education and health raises productivity and lets workers move into higher-paid jobs, and it improves the HDI directly. The returns come over many years.

Trade agreements and FDI: negotiating free-trade agreements can replace lost tariff-free access; attracting foreign direct investment brings capital and technology. But foreign firms may repatriate profits and look for the cheapest place to produce.

Better working conditions and higher wages: safer factories and minimum wages protect workers and meet buyers' demands for responsible supply chains, but too fast a rise in costs may move orders to other countries.

Judgement: the most important policies are diversification and human capital, because they reduce the main risk (one export) and raise long-run productivity. In the short run, trade agreements to keep market access are urgent. The best mix depends on how fast tariffs change after 2026 and on whether Bangladesh can fund infrastructure without excessive debt.

What examiners reward: a GDP-per-head calculation with units, limitations linked to the extract, a correct explanation of the Lewis model with its assumptions, examined risks, and a judgement that ranks policies by time scale.

8.2

Sources for this lesson

  • World Bank, June 2025 Update to the Poverty and Inequality Platform (the 3.00-dollar line at 2021 PPP), and Poverty and Inequality Platform data.
  • State Council Information Office, Poverty Alleviation: China's Experience and Contribution (April 2021); National Bureau of Statistics of China, Gini coefficients and migrant-worker monitoring report.
  • UNDP, Human Development Report 2023/2024.
  • S. Kuznets, "Economic Growth and Income Inequality", American Economic Review 45 (1955); W. A. Lewis, "Economic Development with Unlimited Supplies of Labour" (1954).
  • OECD, statement on the two-pillar solution to the tax challenges of the digitalisation of the economy (October 2021).
  • IMF, World Economic Outlook and Fiscal Monitor databases (government spending and debt).
  • Pearson Edexcel International A Level Economics specification (WEC14), Issue 2, sections 4.3.4–4.3.6.
8.2

Common errors

  • Saying poverty has fallen when only absolute poverty has. Relative poverty can rise while everyone gets richer.
  • Mixing up wealth (a stock of assets) and income (a flow).
  • Reading a higher Gini as more equal. A higher Gini means more inequality.
  • Calling a tax progressive because the rich pay more money. Look at the average rate, not the amount.
  • Confusing the deficit (one year's gap) with the debt (the total owed).
  • Treating the HDI as a full measure of development. It leaves out distribution, freedom and the environment.
  • Describing the Lewis model without its assumptions: surplus farm labour and profits reinvested at home.
8.2

Key terms

  • Absolute / relative poverty: unable to meet basic needs / poor compared with the society's median.
  • Lorenz curve: cumulative share of income against cumulative share of households.
  • Gini coefficient: area between the line of equality and the Lorenz curve ÷ area below the line of equality.
  • Progressive / proportional / regressive tax: average rate rises / stays the same / falls as income rises.
  • Laffer curve: tax revenue first rises and then falls as the tax rate rises.
  • Fiscal deficit / national debt: one year's excess of spending over revenue / total government debt.
  • Structural / cyclical deficit: a deficit that remains at full employment / one caused by a downturn.
  • HDI: geometric mean of health, education and income indices.
  • Primary product dependency: relying on a few raw materials for export earnings.
  • Conditionality: policies a country must adopt to receive an IMF or World Bank loan.
8.2

Check yourself

  1. Median income rises from 25,000 to 35,000. By how much does a relative poverty line at 60% of the median rise?
  2. The poorest 50% of households receive 20% of income and the richest 50% receive 80%. Using two strips, calculate the Gini coefficient.
  3. Taxes of 2,000, 6,000 and 10,000 are paid on incomes of 10,000, 40,000 and 100,000. Is the tax progressive, proportional or regressive?
  4. On the Laffer model revenue $= t(1-t) \times 400$, what revenue does a 20% rate raise?
  5. The actual deficit is 6% of GDP; the structural deficit is 4%. What is the cyclical deficit, and what happens to it in a recovery?
  6. A country's health, education and income indices are each 0.64. Calculate its HDI, and explain why a country with indices 0.95, 0.40 and 0.64 scores lower.

Answers: 1. From 15,000 to 21,000: a rise of 6,000. 2. Area under the curve $= \tfrac{0+20}{2} \times 50 + \tfrac{20+100}{2} \times 50 = 500 + 3000 = 3500$; Gini $= \tfrac{5000 - 3500}{5000} = 0.30$. 3. Regressive: the average rates are 20%, 15% and 10%. 4. $0.2 \times 0.8 \times 400 = 64$. 5. 2% of GDP; it shrinks and disappears as tax revenue rises and benefit spending falls. 6. $\sqrt[3]{0.64^3} = 0.64$; $\sqrt[3]{0.95 \times 0.40 \times 0.64} = \sqrt[3]{0.2432} \approx 0.62$, lower because the geometric mean punishes the weak education index more than the high health index makes up.

Additional notes PDF
Poverty, public finance, growth and development

Scope and prerequisites

This package now covers the full IA2 targets of specification sections 4.3.4–4.3.6 (32 objectives), grounded in specification pages 49–53 and WEC14 January 2025 and June 2025 papers and mark schemes. Read the native introduction first.

Key terms

development 发展; debt service 偿债支出; absolute poverty 绝对贫困; relative poverty 相对贫困; Lorenz curve 洛伦兹曲线; Gini coefficient 基尼系数; progressive tax 累进税; regressive tax 累退税; fiscal deficit 财政赤字; national debt 国债; Human Development Index 人类发展指数; capital flight 资本外逃.

Supported explanation

Growth describes an increase in real output; development also concerns health, education, capabilities and living conditions. Absolute poverty concerns meeting basic needs, while relative poverty compares resources with a society's usual standard. Inequality describes distribution. Average real income can rise while some people remain poor, so choose a measure suited to the claim.

Finance can enable investment but repayment, access, risk and currency terms matter. Aid can fund useful services or emergency relief; its effects depend on the recipient's needs, coordination, conditions and ability to maintain provision. Debt can finance future capacity, but servicing it uses resources and foreign-currency obligations can become harder after depreciation. Institutions affect dependable implementation, rights and accountability; a name or single index does not prove a project will work. Sustainable strategies compare present benefits with maintenance, distribution and environmental consequences. These are supported introductory mechanisms; complete development models, prescribed applications and detailed criteria remain in the held IA2 queue.

Cost bars from zero: road 45, clinic 40, and a stacked bar for both of 85 rising 25 above a dashed budget line at 60; per-household costs are printed inside the bars.

Worked case

A fictional district has a 60-million-unit budget. A road costs 45 million and is expected to connect 200 households to markets. A clinic costs 40 million and is expected to reach 150 households. A report recommends the road because its cost per household is lower. Evaluate the decision.

Road cost per household = 45 million/200 = 0.225 million units/household. Clinic cost per household = 40 million/150 = approximately 0.267 million units/household. Both together cost 45 + 40 = 85 million, exceeding the budget by 25 million. The ratios measure different benefits, so they do not establish that the road is the better development choice. Check the main bottleneck, expected health and market effects, maintenance, access for disadvantaged households and environmental impacts. Compare feasible scaled options and financing terms; do not assume promised reach is actual reach.

Independent transfer

A foreign-currency loan can fund both projects, but a depreciation increases domestic debt-service cost. Propose a qualified decision and an evidence-based review.

Checked original model

Compare repayment and currency risk with credible project benefits and continuing service costs. Funding both now may displace later health, education or maintenance spending if debt service rises. Seek affordable terms or a feasible phased plan, examining distribution and environmental effects with affected people. Monitor actual access, health or market outcomes and repayment burden, not GDP or construction completion alone. A conditional choice explains the binding bottleneck and what evidence would change it. The detailed IA2 poverty, public-finance and development analysis is now taught in the sections below.

Poverty

Absolute poverty is inability to meet basic needs, measured against a stated minimum standard. In June 2025 the World Bank updated its international extreme-poverty line to 3.00 international dollars per person per day at 2021 purchasing-power parity. Comparisons must state the amount, PPP basis and reference date; this is not an ordinary exchange-rate conversion. Reference: World Bank poverty-line update. Relative poverty is poverty compared with the society around you — typically below a set share (often 60%) of median household income. Absolute poverty can fall while relative poverty rises, if growth lifts the poorest above the fixed line but the median rises faster.

Poverty changes with economic growth (lifts incomes, but distribution decides how much reaches the poor), education and training (raises earning power), welfare benefits, changes in the tax structure, structural change (declining industries strand workers), aid, and civil wars and conflict, which destroy assets and displace people.

Inequality

Income inequality concerns flows (wages, profits, benefits); wealth inequality concerns stocks (property, savings, shares). Wealth is usually far more unequally held than income because assets compound across generations.

Original diagram: the Lorenz curve bows below perfect equality; the Gini coefficient is A/(A+B).

The Lorenz curve plots the cumulative share of income received by the cumulative share of households, poorest first. The Gini coefficient is A/(A+B): 0 is perfect equality and 1 is maximum inequality (as a percentage, multiply by 100 — Uruguay's rise from 39.4 to 41.0 between 2017 and 2021, tested in June 2025, means inequality increased and the Lorenz curve moved away from the line of equality). Causes within countries include skill-biased technical change, asset ownership, tax/benefit design and labour-market power; between countries, different resource endowments, institutions and development levels.

Impacts to evaluate: inequality can sharpen incentives and enterprise and raise saving among the rich, but extreme gaps cut the poor's access to education and health (lowering life expectancy), fuel emigration, and can weaken social trust and demand. Development often widens inequality first as a modern sector grows, then narrows it — an empirical question, not a law. Capitalism rewards asset ownership and risk-taking, so free markets tend to generate inequality; the evaluation is whether the resulting incentives and growth fund redistribution, or whether market power and inherited wealth entrench it.

Public expenditure and taxation

Public spending splits into capital expenditure (infrastructure that lasts), current expenditure (salaries, supplies) and transfer payments 转移支付 (benefits and pensions — no output in return). Its size and pattern shift internationally with incomes (richer states spend more), age distributions (ageing raises pension and health costs) and expectations of what the state should do. A high spending-to-GDP ratio can raise productivity and growth (better infrastructure, education) but risks crowding out 挤出效应 (state borrowing raises interest rates or absorbs funds private firms could use) and needs higher taxation.

Direct taxes 直接税 fall on income and wealth (income tax, corporation tax); indirect taxes 间接税 fall on spending (sales taxes, excise duties). A progressive tax takes a rising share as income rises, a proportional tax 比例税 a constant share, a regressive tax a falling share (indirect taxes are usually regressive because the poor spend a larger share of income).

Original diagram: revenue is zero at 0% and at 100%; between them lies a revenue-maximising rate.

Effects of tax-rate changes to evaluate: work incentives (higher marginal rates may discourage extra work); the Laffer curve 拉弗曲线 hypothesis — revenue is zero at 0% and at 100%, so beyond some rate a further rise shrinks revenue through evasion and reduced effort (a hypothesis about shape, not a measured fact); income distribution; real output and employment; the price level (indirect-tax rises feed inflation); the trade balance (demand compression cuts imports); and FDI flows (investors compare after-tax returns).

Deficits, debt and macroeconomic policy

Distinguish carefully: a fiscal deficit is a year's shortfall (spending above revenue); the national debt is the accumulated stock of past borrowing; a surplus is the reverse flow. Automatic stabilisers 自动稳定器 (benefit spending rises and tax revenue falls in a downturn) work without new decisions; discretionary policy is a deliberate change. A structural deficit 结构性赤字 persists at full employment; a cyclical deficit comes from the downturn itself. Deficit size and debt size depend on growth, interest rates, demography, wars and crises.

Significance: larger borrowing can push interest rates up; debt service (interest and scheduled principal repayments) crowds out other spending — Italy's public expenditure rising from 47.1% to 56.7% of GDP between 2002 and 2022 (examined in June 2025) illustrates the debate; and high debt shifts costs to future taxpayers, an intergenerational-equity question.

Governments combine fiscal, monetary, exchange-rate and supply-side policies and direct controls to cut deficits and debt, control inflation, respond to external shocks and reduce poverty. In the 2008 global financial crisis, demand-side policy dominated: interest rates cut near zero, quantitative easing, and large fiscal stimulus and bank rescues — followed by arguments over austerity. Controlling TNC tax avoidance means regulating transfer pricing and coordinating across borders; limits are real: capital is mobile, information is asymmetric, and national law stops at the border. Policy changes act at local, national and global levels at once. And policymakers work with inaccurate data, risk and uncertainty, and external shocks they cannot control — reasons to build in review rather than claim certainty.

Growth and development

The Human Development Index combines three components: health (life expectancy at birth), education (mean and expected years of schooling) and income (GNI per capita, log-scaled). It beats GDP alone because development is broader than output; its limits are that it says nothing about inequality, sustainability or political freedom, and data quality varies. Other indicators: the share of adult male labour in agriculture (falls as economies develop), access to clean water, energy use per head, and internet, mobile-phone and doctor access per thousand people.

Constraints on growth and development — economic: commodity-price volatility and primary-product dependency (the Prebisch-Singer hypothesis: primary exporters' terms of trade worsen over time because demand for raw materials grows slowly with income); the savings gap (the Harrod-Domar logic: low income → low saving → low investment → low growth); the foreign-currency gap (export earnings too small to pay for needed capital imports); capital flight; demography (youth bulges, ageing, migration); household and overseas debt; weak credit and banking access; poor infrastructure; low education and skills. Non-economic: corruption, poor governance, civil wars, migration of skilled workers, terrorism.

Strategies to promote growth and development divide into market-oriented (trade liberalisation, FDI promotion, subsidy removal, privatisation, floating exchange rates, microfinance 小额信贷), interventionist (human-capital development, protectionism, managed exchange rates, infrastructure, joint ventures with TNCs, buffer stocks 缓冲库存 to stabilise commodity prices) and others: industrialisation through the Lewis dual-sector model (labour moves from low-productivity traditional agriculture to a higher-productivity modern sector, funding investment from the surplus), tourism, developing primary industries, debt relief and aid. International institutions: the World Bank 世界银行 funds long-run development projects; the IMF 国际货币基金组织 supports balance-of-payments stability with conditions; NGOs deliver targeted local programmes. Every strategy needs evaluation in context — property rights, governance and the binding constraint differ by country.

WEC14 assessment demand for this topic

Section A has tested HDI-based development strategies (January 2025 Q1), index-number calculation (Q4) and reading a Gini-coefficient chart (June 2025 Q6). Section C essays include reducing income inequality in a developed country (January 2025 Q8), development constraints in a named developing country (June 2025 Q9) and the effects of a rising public-expenditure share (June 2025 Q10). The 12 + 8 rubric and the named-country requirement apply exactly as certified for topics 5 and 7.

Source boundary

XEC11/YEC11, 2018 specification, Issue 2. Evidence: specification pages 49–53 (sections 4.3.4–4.3.6), WEC14 January 2025 QP/MS (Section A Q1, Q4; Section C Q8) and June 2025 QP/MS (Section A Q6; Section C Q9, Q10). Local authored marking guidance is not an official qualification scheme.

Interactive lessons on this topic

Work through it step by step, with instant-check exercises.

More topics in Pearson Edexcel · International A-Level · Economics

Log in or create account

IGCSE, A-Level & AP