Defining Devolutionary Factors
مُقدَّم| English | المعنى |
|---|---|
| devolution/dɪvəˈluːʃn/ | اللامركزية |
| devolutionary factors/dɪvəˈluːʃənəri ˈfæktəz/ | عوامل التفويض |
| separatism/ˈsepərətɪzəm/ | الفصل |
Two votes in one country
- In 2014, Scotland voted on leaving the United Kingdom: 55% chose to stay. Three years later, Catalonia held a referendum on leaving Spain; Spain's courts called it illegal, and the Spanish government took direct control of the region for several months.
- Both are examples of pressure for devolution 权力下放: the transfer of power from a central government to regions. The causes are called devolutionary factors 权力下放因素.
The devolutionary factors
| Factor | How it pushes for devolution | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Physical geography | distance, mountains or water separate a region from the capital | Corsica (France); the islands of Indonesia |
| Ethnic separatism | a group with its own language or culture wants self-rule | Catalans (Spain), Québécois (Canada) |
| Ethnic cleansing | violent removal of one group creates demands for separation | Bosnia in the 1990s |
| Terrorism | violent groups attack to force political change | ETA in the Basque Country (1959–2018) |
| Economic and social problems | a rich region resents subsidising others, or a poor one feels ignored | Catalonia; northern Italy |
| Irredentism | a state claims land where people of its nationality live in another state | Russia's annexation of Crimea (2014) |
أي عامل من عوامل اللامركزية؟
Sort each cause of devolution by its type.
Match each example to its devolutionary factor.
الصعوبة 2/5 · 140 عملة + مكافأة صغيرة عند الإنجاز الأول اليوم
Each factor pushes for devolution in a different way.
What is irredentism?
الصعوبة 1/5 · 100 عملة + مكافأة صغيرة عند الإنجاز الأول اليوم
Irredentism looks across a border at "its" people.
Scotland: several factors at once
- Scotland has a distinct history and identity (it was a separate kingdom until 1707), is far from London, and its waters hold most of the UK's North Sea oil.
- Cause → result: these factors fed a long campaign → a 1997 referendum created the Scottish Parliament (1999), which controls education, health and some taxes → the 2014 independence vote was the next step.

Put the steps of Scottish devolution in order.
الصعوبة 3/5 · 200 عملة + مكافأة صغيرة عند الإنجاز الأول اليوم
Devolution came first; the independence vote followed.
Devolution can unite or divide
- Giving regions their own parliaments can satisfy demands and keep a state together: Spain's autonomous communities and the UK's devolved governments.
- If demands are ignored or repressed, they can grow into separatism 分离主义, a movement for full independence, and sometimes into violence.
A devolved region has left the state and become independent.
الصعوبة 1/5 · 100 عملة + مكافأة صغيرة عند الإنجاز الأول اليوم
It stays inside the state with some powers of its own; independence is separatism's goal.
Worked FRQ answer
(A) Define devolution. The transfer of power from a state's central government to regional governments.
(B) Explain how economic factors can lead to devolution, using an example. Catalonia is one of Spain's richest regions and pays more in taxes than it receives in spending. Many Catalans resent this, which strengthens demands for more control over their own taxes, or for independence.
(C) Explain how irredentism can threaten a state's sovereignty. A neighbouring state may claim territory where people of its nationality live, and support or annex it, as Russia did with Crimea in 2014, taking land from Ukraine.
- Why it scores: names a specific factor, explains its mechanism, and anchors it in a real case.
Devolution is not the same as independence. A devolved region stays inside the state with some powers of its own. Separatism aims to leave entirely.
Devolution moves power from the centre to regions. Devolutionary factors: physical geography, ethnic separatism, ethnic cleansing, terrorism, economic and social problems, and irredentism. Devolution can satisfy regions and hold a state together, or, if ignored, grow into separatism.
FRQ practice. A coastal region speaks a different language from the capital and its leaders demand their own parliament. (A) Identify the devolutionary factor. (B) Explain ONE way granting devolution could keep the state together. (C) Explain ONE way it could lead to further division.
Devolution can work both ways - explain how.