“Looks good” cannot repair a method mismatch
- A peer reads the materials proposal and writes, “Nice topic and neat layout.” The encouragement is welcome, but it misses a problem: one draft paragraph still says the team will ask whether participants like the labels, while the question concerns sorting accuracy.
- This original GAC033-aligned lesson treats peer review as a reasoned check of the proposal. It is not permission to run a study or a judgement of the author's character. Useful feedback identifies a specific issue and why it matters.
为什么“有趣的题目和整洁的布局”作为唯一评审是不够的?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
表面的正面评论可能忽略实质性的不匹配。鼓励与批判性审视可以共存。
Review the argument before the appearance
- Read in this order: purpose and question, evidence, method, ethics, analysis, feasibility, then clarity and presentation. A well-written sentence can still promise a measure the procedure never collects. Check the connections between sections.
- Apply criteria consistently. Does the background support the question? Is the outcome measurable? Could another helper follow the procedure? Is participation voluntary? Are claims limited to the sample and task? Do not require the team to obtain your preferred result.

安排这些评审任务的优先级顺序。
难度 3/5 · 今日首次完成可获 200 金币及少量额外奖励
实质连贯性和保障措施优先于表面润色。
Write a comment with a reason and a next step
- Use location → issue → consequence → suggestion. “Method paragraph 2 asks about preference, but the question concerns complete sorting success. This would leave the main question unanswered. Use the four-item task and keep preference, if collected at all, as a separate outcome.”
- Distinguish a necessary correction from an optional idea. Correcting the mismatch is necessary; adding a decorative colour theme is optional. If a detail is genuinely unclear, ask for clarification instead of claiming it is definitely absent from the whole project.
Specific feedback: “The consent script says sheets are anonymous, but the draft sheet asks for names. Remove the name field or explain and justify a different approved data plan; the current versions contradict each other.”
哪两项细节使反馈评论具有可操作性?
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
位置、议题和后果标识出修改目标。人身攻击和期望结果是适当的评审标准。
Receive criticism without defending every sentence
- Pause and restate the concern before replying. “You noticed that our question and survey measure differ” shows understanding. Ask which part needs clarification and compare the comment with the actual draft, rather than assuming criticism means the project is worthless.
- You need not accept every suggestion. Reject one with a reason tied to scope or evidence: “We will not add a memory test because our question concerns immediate sorting and the extra task would change the approved procedure.” Respectful disagreement is compatible with useful review.
Peer approval does not replace teacher approval, participant information or source verification. A positive review can still overlook a problem. Keep the relevant checks in the action plan.
即使建议改变了项目超出批准范围,也必须接受每一个同伴建议。
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
考虑建议并给出理由。超范围的更改可能需要拒绝或进一步批准。
Make revisions traceable
- Keep a response log showing the comment, decision, change and reason. Mark accepted, partly accepted or not accepted; then identify the revised section. “Done” alone does not tell the reviewer whether the underlying issue was fixed.
- Recheck linked parts after a change. Removing a name field may affect data handling and withdrawal instructions. Changing the outcome requires updating the question and analysis. A revision that fixes one paragraph but leaves contradictions elsewhere is incomplete.
| Comment | Decision | Revision and reason |
|---|---|---|
| Preference measure does not answer accuracy question | Accept | Restore the fixed sorting task and success count |
| Add a second memory task | Do not accept | Outside the question and current scope |
| Name field conflicts with anonymous plan | Accept | Remove field and check information script |
移除姓名字段后,还应检查什么?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
相互关联的部分必须与匿名收集计划保持一致。
Close the review with a new check
- Give the reviewer the revised version and response log. Ask them to check whether the question, outcome and procedure now match. This is a focused follow-up, not a request to praise the entire project.
- Review a partner's one-page proposal using two substantive comments and one clear strength. Then revise your own draft and record one decision you did not accept, with a defensible reason. Keep all versions labelled so the final presentation uses the approved candidate.
Useful peer review is specific, criteria-based and respectful. A response log connects feedback with a justified revision and a check that the revision solved the problem.