Contradictory Narrators
Introduzido| English | Significado |
|---|---|
| narrator/nəˈreɪtə/ | The voice that tells a story. |
"A capital fellow!", 1847
- Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights has two narrators. Lockwood, a visitor, meets Heathcliff in the first chapter and decides they are "such a suitable pair": "A capital fellow!"
- Nelly Dean, the housekeeper, then tells him the family's history, full of Heathcliff's cruelty. In her story Catherine calls him "a fierce, pitiless, wolfish man".
What does Lockwood first call Heathcliff?
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
He misreads him completely.
Narrators disagree
- When a text has more than one narrator 叙述者, their accounts can contradict each other. Each sees through their own experience, interests and limits.
- Lockwood misreads everything at the Heights: he mistakes a heap of dead rabbits for cats and the wrong woman for the mistress.
Lockwood mistakes a heap of dead rabbits for cats.
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
He misreads everything at the Heights.
The reader stands between them
- The reader cannot fully trust either voice. Lockwood is a stranger who sees only the surface; Nelly is inside the story and takes sides.
- Meaning comes from comparing the accounts: where they agree, where they clash, and what each one cannot see.

Cannot, does not, or a contradiction?
Sort each gap between two accounts.
Match each narrator to their limit.
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Neither is fully reliable.
Worked example: why two narrators?
- Contradiction: Lockwood sees a reserved gentleman; Nelly describes a man who hangs a dog and plans revenge for years.
- Limits: Lockwood is vain and quick to judge; Nelly has her own loyalties and sometimes acts against characters she dislikes.
- Effect: Heathcliff never speaks to us directly. Brontë makes us build him from two partial views, so he stays mysterious, and the reader is drawn into judging him.
What is one effect of telling Heathcliff's story through two narrators?
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
He never speaks to us directly.
Questions to ask each narrator
- What can this narrator know? What do they want the listener to believe? Where might they be wrong?
- A narrator does not have to lie to be unreliable; ignorance and loyalty are enough.
A narrator must lie to be unreliable.
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Ignorance and loyalty are enough.
Writing about contradiction
- Do not choose one narrator as "right". Explain what the contradiction shows: a mystery, a judgement on the narrator, or a truth no single person can see.
- Quote both accounts side by side.
Do not treat a narrator as the author. Nelly's opinions are a character's opinions, not Brontë's. Ask why the author gives the story to this voice.
Nelly's opinions are Brontë's opinions.
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Ask why the author gives the story to this voice.
When narrators contradict each other, ask what each can know and wants, compare their accounts, and explain what the contradiction does: keep a character mysterious, expose a narrator, or show a truth no single voice can hold.
Choose a text with two narrators or two accounts of the same event. Say where they clash and what the clash shows.
Compare, then interpret.