Taxes, subsidies and price controls
Introduced| English | Meaning |
|---|---|
| minimum price/ˈmɪnɪməm praɪs/ | A legal lowest price, set above the market price. |
| maximum price/ˈmæksɪməm praɪs/ | A legal highest price, set below the market price. |
| binding price ceiling/ˈbaɪndɪŋ praɪs ˈsiːlɪŋ/ | A maximum price below equilibrium, so it actually changes the market and causes a shortage. |
| black markets | Illegal markets where goods are sold above a legal maximum price. |
| guaranteed minimum price/ˌɡærənˈtiːd ˈmɪnɪməm praɪs/ | A price the government promises to pay producers, so their income cannot fall below it. |
A tax that changed the recipe
- In 2018 the UK put a tax on sugary soft drinks: about 24 pence per litre for the sweetest ones.
- Before it even started, many makers cut the sugar in their drinks to stay below the tax line.
- Governments can correct markets by changing prices: taxes, subsidies, and maximum and minimum prices.
Indirect taxes against external costs
- A tax equal to the marginal external cost shifts MPC up to MSC, so the market moves to the social optimum. The polluter pays for the damage it causes.
- Problems: the external cost is hard to measure; inelastic demand means the quantity falls only a little; and the tax can hit poorer households hardest.
Who pays a specific tax?
$P_b-P_s=t$
With Qd = 120 − 2P and Qs = 2P the market clears at P 30, Q 60. A specific tax of 3 opens a wedge of 3 between the buyer's and the seller's price; with equally steep curves each side bears half.
To reach the social optimum, a tax on a polluting good should equal —
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
A tax equal to the MEC makes the firm's cost equal to the social cost.
Worked example: a maximum price
Demand is $Q_d = 120 - 2P$ and supply is $Q_s = 2P$, so the market clears at $P = 30$, $Q = 60$. The government sets a maximum price 最高限价 of ¥20.
- Quantity demanded at ¥20: $120 - 40 = 80$. Quantity supplied: $2 \times 20 = 40$.
- Shortage $= 80 - 40 = 40$ units.
- ¥20 is below equilibrium, so this is a binding price ceiling 有约束力的最高限价. The price can no longer ration, so queues, waiting lists or black markets 黑市 appear.

Shortage under a maximum and surplus under a minimum
With Qd = 120 − 2P and Qs = 2P the market clears at P 30, Q 60. A maximum of 20 leaves a shortage of 80 − 40 = 40. Switch to a guaranteed minimum of 40 and the surplus of 40 costs the government 40 × 40 = 1600 to buy.
With $Q_d = 120 - 2P$ and $Q_s = 2P$, a maximum price of ¥25 is set. What is the shortage?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
$Q_d = 70$ and $Q_s = 50$, so the shortage is $20$.
Minimum prices
- A minimum price 最低限价 is set above equilibrium to raise producers' income. China sets minimum purchase prices for wheat and rice.
- At a guaranteed minimum price 保证最低价格 of ¥40 in the same market: demand is 40, supply 80, so the state must buy the surplus of 40 at ¥40 — a cost of $40 \times 40 = ¥1600$.

In the same market, the state guarantees a minimum price of ¥35 and buys any surplus. How much does it spend?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
$Q_d = 50$, $Q_s = 70$: a surplus of 20 bought at ¥35 costs $20 \times 35 = ¥700$.
Subsidies against under-consumption
- A subsidy equal to the marginal external benefit shifts supply down, lowers the price, and raises consumption towards the optimum — for example, free vaccines or cheap public transport.
- Problems: it has an opportunity cost, firms may become inefficient if they rely on it, and it is hard to remove later.
Which are problems with subsidies?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Subsidies lower prices, not raise them.
A maximum price only matters if it is below equilibrium; a minimum price only matters if it is above. A maximum of ¥40 in a market that clears at ¥30 changes nothing. Always check where the control is set before drawing its shortage or surplus.
A maximum price of ¥40 in a market whose equilibrium price is ¥30 causes a shortage.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
The ceiling is above equilibrium, so the market still clears at ¥30.
Match each policy to a likely side effect.
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Each tool has its own typical unintended consequence.
Evaluating the tools
- Information: each tool needs the government to know the size of the external cost or benefit.
- Elasticity: taxes change behaviour most when demand is elastic; subsidies work best when demand responds to price.
- Side effects: controls create shortages, surpluses and black markets; taxes can be regressive.
Taxes raise the price of goods with external costs; subsidies lower the price of goods with external benefits. A maximum price below equilibrium causes a shortage, and a minimum price above it causes a surplus that the state may have to buy. Each tool's success depends on information, elasticity and side effects.
Evaluate the use of an indirect tax to reduce the consumption of sugary drinks.
Judge the tool against its aim, with a condition.