Construisez un argument logique sur une procédure inventée
IntroduitCounting complaints is not the same as judging a procedure
- A fictional makerspace receives complaints about equipment reservations. An essay must decide whether the proposed procedure is justified. It needs a conclusion, relevant evidence and an explanation connecting them—not a claim that rules are automatically good or bad.
- This GAC015-aligned lesson uses a made-up institutional procedure to practise logical argument. It states no actual law or legal right. The source log and criteria are classroom evidence, not a legal authority.
Define the decision and the evidence boundary
- The proposal is to require users to confirm bookings the day before use. A fictional four-week log lists forty bookings: six unused slots and four cases where someone arrived but another user had the equipment. Reasons for unused slots are incomplete.
- A staff note proposes confirmations; a student note warns that not everyone checks email daily. The log describes problems but does not test the proposal. The notes add perspectives, not measured predictions about how many problems will disappear.

Combien de créneaux inutilisés y avait-il dans le journal fictif ?
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Six des quarante réservations étaient inutilisées ; quatre est le décompte distinct des conflits.
State the warrant linking evidence to a proposal
- A warrant explains why evidence supports a conclusion. Unused slots support checking whether users still need their bookings; they do not establish that email-only confirmation is accessible. A sound argument makes the missing link visible.
- Choose criteria such as reducing conflicts, preserving access and keeping effort manageable. These are proposed decision criteria, not measured achievements. Explain which evidence relates to each and which information still needs collecting.
| Evidence | Supported point | Unanswered question |
|---|---|---|
| 6 unused slots | Some booked time was not used | Why users did not attend |
| 4 equipment conflicts | Some arrivals could not use booked equipment | How confirmation would change conflicts |
| Student access concern | Email-only access should be checked | How many users need another channel |
Qu'est-ce qu'un fondement (warrant) ?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Le fondement explique pourquoi les preuves étayent la conclusion proposée.
Address a strong objection rather than a weak substitute
- A fair objection is that mandatory email confirmation may exclude people who miss the message. Do not answer by saying “students hate all rules,” which changes the objection. Consider an alternative channel or a small trial, while keeping its effectiveness unmeasured.
- Acknowledge that keeping the existing system also has costs: unused slots and conflicts. An argument can compare imperfect options. It should state what a limited trial would test and how users could report access problems.
« Les étudiants détestent chaque règle » représente équitablement l'objection relative à l'accès par courriel.
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
L'objection porte sur le fait de manquer un message et l'accès, pas sur l'hostilité envers toutes les règles.
Write a conclusion proportionate to the support
- Draft 160–190 words recommending either a limited trial or more investigation before one. Include the bounded log evidence, a warrant, the access objection and a response. State a review criterion; do not invent a successful trial to close the argument.
- Use “supports testing” rather than “proves the policy will work.” If your recommendation depends on an accessible confirmation route, write that condition explicitly. Conditional reasoning is clearer than burying an important assumption.
Quelles DEUX caractéristiques renforcent une recommandation ?
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Des conditions explicites et des critères d'évaluation rendent la proposition vérifiable sans résultats inventés.
Check logical consistency and source use
- Label conclusion, evidence, warrant and counterargument in your draft. Every borrowed fact needs acknowledgment to its fictional source; real essays need real retrievable sources. Check that your ending does not claim a stronger result than your body established.
- Ask a partner to identify the most important uncertainty. If they cannot, revise it into the argument. Acknowledging a genuine weakness can improve a recommendation by showing what must be checked before a wider decision.
The log supports testing a way to release unneeded slots, but it does not establish that email-only confirmation is suitable. A limited trial with another response route could examine both slot use and access before a wider decision.
A source describing a problem is not automatically evidence that your preferred solution will solve it.
A logical argument connects relevant evidence to a bounded conclusion through an explicit warrant and a fair response to objections.
Quelle conclusion reste dans le cadre des preuves ?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Le journal identifie des problèmes bornés et soutient une investigation, pas une solution garantie.