Choosing Your Move
Introduit"Would you argue more, and denounce less?", 1852
- In his Fourth of July speech of 1852, Frederick Douglass voiced his critics' objection himself: "I fancy I hear some one of my audience say, it is just in this circumstance that you and your brother abolitionists fail to make a favorable impression on the public mind. Would you argue more, and denounce less... your cause would be much more likely to succeed." Then he turned it: "where all is plain there is nothing to be argued." The wrong of slavery, he said, was already admitted by the laws that punished enslaved people as responsible human beings.
- Douglass named the strongest objection and refuted it with evidence (the slave laws). Choosing your move means matching it to what your evidence can actually do.
How did Douglass answer the critics who said he should "argue more, and denounce less"?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
He named the objection and showed it did not hold.
Pick the move your evidence can pay for
| You have... | Choose | Signal phrases |
|---|---|---|
| evidence that the opposing claim is false or illogical | refute | "This does not follow, because..." |
| a strong contrasting view or other evidence | rebut | "Yet...", "However, this overlooks..." |
| neither, but the objection is partly true | concede, then turn | "Admittedly...; even so..." |
- The commonest exam mistake is claiming to refute when you only have evidence to rebut. If you cannot point to evidence that the claim is false, word it as a rebuttal.

Choisissez le mouvement qualifiant pour la situation
Concede, rebut and refute admit different amounts, and the choice is evidence-driven.
Match each situation to the best move.
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Pick the move your evidence can pay for.
Concede-then-turn: the move you can always afford
- Name the strongest objection, concede exactly what is true in it, then turn back to your claim. The turn must be narrower than the concession, or you take back what you gave.
- Acknowledging a limit of your own argument ("this works best in cities") costs no ground and builds credibility.
In concede-then-turn, the turn should take back everything you conceded.
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
The turn must be narrower than the concession.
Worked paragraph: concede-then-turn
Thesis: Schools should provide free breakfast to all students.
"Admittedly, providing breakfast to every student costs money, and some families could easily pay for their own children's food. Even so, limiting the meal to poorer students would mark those students out, and many who qualify would skip it rather than be seen. Offering it to everyone removes that stigma, so the extra cost buys the one thing a targeted scheme cannot: children who actually eat."
- Why it scores: the objection is stated fairly; the concession is specific (cost, some families can pay); the turn is a rebuttal with a reason (stigma), worded as a rebuttal, not a false refutation; the final clause links back to the thesis.
Check what you actually did
- Find your counterargument paragraph and name your move: concede, rebut or refute. If you cannot name it, the reader cannot either.
- If you named refute, point at the evidence that the other claim is false. If you cannot, change your wording to a rebuttal.
Signal the move. A counterargument with no transition ("Admittedly", "Yet") reads as the writer changing their mind.
Which pair of transitions signals concede-then-turn?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
The transitions tell the reader which move is coming.
Choose the move your evidence supports: refute with evidence that a claim is false, rebut with a contrasting view, and concede then turn when the objection is partly true. Signal each move with a transition, and keep the turn narrower than the concession.
Practice. Thesis: "Cities should plant more street trees." Objection: trees cost money to maintain and their roots damage pavements. You have no evidence that this is false. Write a concede-then-turn paragraph.
Concede what is true; turn on what is not.