Skip to content

IGCSE Physics · June 2021 · Paper 53 · Difficulty 3 · Standard

Question 3

3

In this experiment, you will investigate the refraction of light by a transparent block. You will determine a quantity known as the refractive index of the material of the block.

Carry out the following instructions, using the separate ray-trace sheet provided. You may refer to Fig. 3.1 for guidance.

(a)

• Place the block approximately in the centre of the ray-trace sheet. Carefully draw round the block and label the corners ABCD as indicated by Fig. 3.1.

  • Remove the block from the ray-trace sheet.
  • Draw a normal to line AB at a point N, $2\text{ cm}$ from A. Extend the normal downwards until it crosses the line CD. Label the point at which it crosses CD with the letter F.
  • Draw a line NE, as indicated by Fig. 3.1, $8\text{ cm}$ long and at an angle $\theta_1 = 20^\circ$.

[1]

(b)

• Replace the block in exactly the same position as in (a).

  • Place two pins, $\text{P}_1$ and $\text{P}_2$, on line NE, a suitable distance apart for accurate ray tracing.
  • Label the positions of $\text{P}_1$ and $\text{P}_2$.
  • View the images of $\text{P}_1$ and $\text{P}_2$ through the block from the direction indicated by the eye in Fig. 3.1. Place two pins, $\text{P}_3$ and $\text{P}_4$, a suitable distance apart, so that pins $\text{P}_3$ and $\text{P}_4$, and the images of $\text{P}_1$ and $\text{P}_2$, all appear exactly one behind the other.
  • Label the positions of $\text{P}_3$ and $\text{P}_4$.
  • Remove the block and pins from the ray-trace sheet.
  • Draw a line joining $\text{P}_3$ and $\text{P}_4$. Extend this line until it meets NF.
  • Label the point at which this line meets NF with the letter G. Label the point at which this line crosses CD with the letter H.
  • Draw a line joining points N and H.

[3]

(c)

Measure the length $a$ of line NH.

$a =$ cm

Measure the length $b$ of line GH.

$b =$ cm

Calculate a value $n_1$ for the refractive index, using the equation $n_1 = \frac{a}{b}$.

$n_1 =$ [2]

(d)

Draw a new line NE, as indicated by Fig. 3.1, $8\text{ cm}$ long and at an angle $\theta_2 = 40^\circ$.

Repeat the steps in (b).

(i)

Measure the length $c$ of the new line NH.

$c =$ cm

Measure the length $d$ of the new line GH.

$d =$ cm

Calculate a second value $n_2$ for the refractive index, using the equation $n_2 = \frac{c}{d}$.

$n_2 =$ [1]

(ii)

State whether $n_1$ or $n_2$ is likely to be the more accurate value. Explain your answer.

statement

explanation [1]

(e)
(i)

Measure the angle $\alpha$, where $\alpha$ is the smaller angle between the line GH from (b) and the line GH from (d).

$\alpha =$ [1]

(ii)

A student suggests that the angle $\alpha$ should be equal to the difference between the angle $\theta_2$ from (d) and the angle $\theta_1$ from (a).

State whether your results support this suggestion. Justify your answer by reference to your results.

statement

justification [1]

(f)

Suggest why different students, all carrying out this experiment carefully, may not obtain identical results.[1]

Tie your ray-trace sheet into this booklet between pages 10 and 11.

[Total: 11]

Show the mark scheme

These are the official mark-scheme rows. Each point that matches your answer earns a mark.

Tap the mark scheme to open it full size.

Show a worked answer

How to reach each mark, step by step. Try the question yourself first.

3(a)

  • Draw the normal through N at $90^\circ$ to AB, then extend it to meet CD at F.

3(b)

  • Draw $NE$ at $20^\circ$ to the normal. Place each pair of pins well apart and label all four pin positions.
  • Line up $P_3$ and $P_4$ with the images of $P_1$ and $P_2$. Join $P_3$ to $P_4$ and extend the line to $NF$.
  • Label its crossing with $CD$ as $H$ and its meeting with $NF$ as $G$. Join $N$ to $H$ with a neat straight line.

3(c)

  • Measure $NH$ and $GH$ to the nearest $0.1\,\mathrm{cm}$; call them $a$ and $b$.
  • Use $n_1 = a/b$. With both lengths in $\mathrm{cm}$, $n_1 = \mathbf{a/b}$; the result has no unit and should be about $1.3$ to $1.7$.

3(d)(i)

  • Measure the new $NH$ and $GH$ in $\mathrm{cm}$ and call them $c$ and $d$.
  • Use $n_2 = c/d$. With both lengths in $\mathrm{cm}$, $n_2 = \mathbf{c/d}$, with no unit. It should be within $10\%$ of $n_1$.

3(d)(ii)

  • $\mathbf{n_2}$ is likely to be more accurate. The lengths measured at the larger angle are larger, so the same reading uncertainty gives a smaller percentage uncertainty.

3(e)(i)

  • Measure the smaller angle between the two $GH$ lines with a protractor. It should be about $\mathbf{20}^\circ$.

3(e)(ii)

  • The difference is $\theta_2-\theta_1 = 40^\circ-20^\circ = 20^\circ$.
  • If your measured $\alpha$ is close to $20^\circ$, the results support the suggestion within experimental accuracy. If it is not close, they do not support it.

3(f)

  • It is difficult to align the pins exactly, so different students may draw slightly different ray paths.
Original question

Log in or create account

IGCSE, A-Level & AP