History: what can the surviving records establish?
Introduced| English | Meaning |
|---|---|
| source/sɔːs/ | The document or testimony a knowledge claim depends on. |
| corroboration/kəˌrɒbəˈreɪʃn/ | Support for a claim obtained by comparing it with independent evidence. |
| inference/ˈɪnfərəns/ | A conclusion drawn from evidence or reasoning rather than directly observed. |
Two records tell different stories
- A school library closed early one afternoon. A later student account blames a staff meeting; a dated maintenance notice mentions a power repair. Which claim does each record actually support?
- A source 史料 preserves information from a particular setting. Separate a record of what happened from an explanation of why it happened.
Place each record in its setting
- Check who made the record, its date, intended readers and purpose. A notice may describe a planned repair without proving that the repair occurred.
- A remembered account can reveal what a student believed. Its value depends on the question; being a memory does not make every statement false.

What does an advance maintenance notice directly establish?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
A plan needs evidence of completion before it establishes what actually happened.
Compare independent records
- Seek a repair log, opening-time record and meeting schedule. Corroboration 相互印证 compares relevant evidence from different sources. Two reports copied from one notice are not two independent checks.
- Explain agreement and disagreement. If the repair log records a power cut at the closing time, the repair explanation gains support; a meeting elsewhere does not establish its role.
Two stories copied from one notice do not independently confirm its claim.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
True. Both depend on the same source, so they repeat rather than check it.
Which evidence most directly checks whether the repair took place?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
The completed record addresses the event rather than merely the plan.
Match certainty to the evidence
- An inference 推断 moves from evidence to a claim. A record that the library closed does not by itself establish the staff’s intention. State which step requires another source.
- Missing records limit what you can know. An archive may omit student complaints because nobody collected them, rather than because no complaints existed.
Why is an absent complaint file insufficient to show nobody complained?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
What survives depends partly on what was recorded and retained.
Ask a question about knowing the past
- Ask how source selection affects explanations of the past. Use the library case to explain which records survive, what each can establish and why a conclusion may change.
- Compare a supported alternative fairly. Do not claim that history has no standards because accounts differ; source context and independent checks provide reasons for a judgement.
Match each historical check to its purpose.
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Each check supports a different part of the reasoning.
Which conclusions fit this case?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
The records support an event connection without proving all intentions.
The dated notice announces a planned repair. A completed repair log records a power cut from 14:00, and the library log records closing at 14:05. Together they support a connection between the power cut and closing. The later memory suggests a staff meeting, but its date and place still need checking. The conclusion remains limited: the surviving records support the repair explanation more strongly for this closure; they do not reveal every staff member’s intention.
An official record is useful evidence, not an automatic guarantee of accuracy. Explain its purpose and the claim you infer from it.
Judge a historical explanation by relevant records, their context, independent checks and the limits of the inference.
Write from two records
- A student account blames a staff meeting. A dated notice mentions a power repair. Both say the library closed.
- Separate the closure from the cause. A missing complaint file is not proof that nobody complained.
A student account blames a staff meeting for an early closing. A dated notice mentions a power repair. What does each record support, and what does a missing complaint file not prove?
A source preserves a record from its setting. An inference about intention needs another step, and an archive can omit records.
What can both records support?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
The shared fact is the closing. The causes disagree, and a missing file is not proof of silence.