Design sustainability and production choices
Introduced| English | Meaning |
|---|---|
| sustainable design | design that reduces environmental and social harm over a product's whole life |
| life cycle | The stages of a product's existence, from obtaining raw materials to its end-of-life treatment. |
| scale of production | the number of products made, from one-off and batch to mass and continuous |
| life cycle assessment/laɪf ˈsaɪkl əˈsesmənt/ | Measuring a product's environmental impact at every stage from raw materials to disposal. |
A phone designed to be repaired, 2013
- In 2013 the Dutch company Fairphone launched a smartphone designed to last. Later models were modular: a user with a small screwdriver could replace the battery, screen or camera instead of buying a new phone. The company also traced where some of its minerals came from.
- Most of a phone's carbon footprint comes from making it, so keeping it longer cuts its impact. Sustainable design 可持续设计 considers the whole life cycle 生命周期, and production choices depend on scale of production 生产规模.
What design strategy did Fairphone's modular phones use?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Repair extends its life.
The life cycle
- Raw materials → manufacture → distribution → use → end of life (reuse, repair, recycle, landfill).
- Life cycle assessment 生命周期评估 measures energy, emissions and waste at each stage.
Which are life-cycle stages?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
And distribution and end of life.
Design strategies
- Design for repair and disassembly (screws, not glue), for fewer materials, for recycled materials, and for longer life.
- Each strategy is a trade-off with cost, size or appearance.
Using screws instead of glue helps repair and disassembly.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
It is still a trade-off.
Scale of production
- One-off, batch, mass and continuous production. Higher volume favours processes with high set-up cost and low cost per item.
- Injection moulding needs an expensive mould but makes each part cheaply; 3D printing needs no mould but each part costs more.
Which process suits a run of 10,000 identical parts?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
High set-up cost, low cost per item.
Worked example: mould or print?
Moulding: fixed cost 600, then 4 per item. Printing: fixed cost 100, then 9 per item.
- Break-even: 600 + 4n = 100 + 9n → 500 = 5n → n = 100 items.
- Below 100 items printing is cheaper; above 100, moulding is cheaper. At 300 items: moulding 1,800, printing 2,800.
- Beyond cost: a mould locks in the design; printing allows changes between batches. For a first run of 50 cases, print; for 5,000, mould.
Two cost models differ by 540 in fixed cost and by 6 per item. What is the break-even item count?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
540 ÷ 6 = 90.
Using printing at 100 + 9 per item, what do 300 items cost?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
100 + 9 × 300 = 2,800.
Weighing impacts
- Compare options across the life cycle, not one stage: a lighter material may need more energy to make.
- State the evidence and its limits: estimates depend on assumptions.
"Recyclable" does not mean recycled. A product made of mixed, glued materials may be recyclable in theory but sent to landfill in practice. Design so separation is easy.
A recyclable product is always recycled.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Design so separation is easy.
Sustainable design considers the whole life cycle, using strategies such as repair, disassembly and fewer materials. Production choices depend on scale: find the break-even point between fixed and per-item costs, and weigh flexibility and impact as well as cost.
A school club will sell 60 phone cases this year and maybe 2,000 next year. Recommend a production method for each year, using cost and flexibility.
Cost and flexibility.