Free market, command and mixed economies
Introduced| English | Meaning |
|---|---|
| ration coupon | A paper ticket the state gave families, needed as well as money to buy food. |
| free market economy | An economy where private people and firms own resources and prices decide what is made. |
| invisible hand/ɪnˈvɪzɪbl hænd/ | The idea that individuals pursuing their own interests can coordinate economic activity through market prices under suitable conditions. |
| command economy/kəˈmænd ɪˈkɒnəmi/ | An economic system in which central authorities direct major production and resource-allocation decisions. |
| mixed economy/mɪkst ɪˈkɒnəmi/ | An economy combining market allocation and private ownership with government intervention and public provision. |
| redistribute/ˌriːˈdɪstrɪbjuːt/ | To move income or wealth from some people to others, for example through taxes and benefits. |
| regulate | To control a market with rules set by the government. |
Rice that needed a coupon
- Until the early 1990s, many Chinese families needed ration coupons 粮票 as well as money to buy rice and cooking oil.
- The state decided how much was produced and who got it. Today shops sell rice to anyone who pays.
- Who should decide what is produced, how, and for whom? Every economy must answer.
Which are the basic questions every economy must answer?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Scarcity cannot be avoided; it is why the three questions must be answered.
The free market economy
- In a free market economy 自由市场经济, private individuals and firms own resources and decide.
- Prices carry information: when a good is scarce its price rises, so firms make more and buyers use less.
- Adam Smith called this coordination without a planner an invisible hand 看不见的手.
In a free market, the price of avocados doubles. What message does this send?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
A rising price signals scarcity and gives an incentive to supply more and consume less.
Free markets: strengths and weaknesses
- Strengths: firms compete, so they keep costs down and innovate; consumers get choice.
- Weaknesses: public goods such as street lighting are not provided; pollution is ignored; income can be very unequal.
- Those who cannot pay — the poor, the sick — may get very little.
Which are weaknesses of a free market economy?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Competition gives firms a strong incentive to cut costs; that is a strength.
The command economy
- In a command economy 计划经济, the state owns most resources and a central plan sets output, prices and wages.
- It can direct resources to national goals fast, such as heavy industry or full employment.
- But planners cannot know millions of people's needs, and without profit there is little reward for working harder or innovating. Queues and shortages follow.
What is the main information problem of a command economy?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Without prices, planners lack the information that markets collect automatically.
Hayek and Marx
- Friedrich Hayek argued that knowledge is spread across millions of people. Only prices can gather it, so central planning must fail.
- Karl Marx argued that free markets let owners of capital exploit workers, and that resources should be owned collectively.
- Exam answers use both views to evaluate how far the state should allocate resources.
Match each economist to the view.
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
All three appear in evaluation answers on allocation systems.
The mixed economy
- Almost every real economy is a mixed economy 混合经济: markets allocate most goods, and the state also acts.
- The state provides public goods (defence, roads), redistributes 再分配 income through taxes and benefits, and regulates 监管 markets.
- Countries differ in the mix. In Singapore about 80% of residents live in public (HDB) flats, yet most other goods are sold in markets.

Classify the case. Private clinics set their own fees, but the city pays for all children's vaccines.
- Market part: clinic care goes to those who pay the fee.
- State part: vaccines are funded by taxes and given to every child.
- Verdict: a mixed economy. Public spending on one service does not make the whole system a command economy.
Because the state pays for vaccines, the economy in the clinic case is a command economy.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Clinics still set fees in a market. Market allocation plus state activity is a mixed economy.
Ownership is not the same as competition. A state-owned firm can face strong competitors, and a private firm can be a monopoly. Judge an allocation system by who decides and how, not by political labels.
A free market allocates through prices and profit, which gives incentives and choice but ignores public goods, pollution and inequality. A command economy allocates by plan, which can pursue national goals but suffers from poor information and weak incentives. Most economies mix the two.
Give one advantage and one disadvantage of a command economy, each with a reason.
Each point needs a reason, as in a WEC11 explain question.