Models, ceteris paribus and value judgements
Introduced| English | Meaning |
|---|---|
| model/ˈmɒdl/ | A simplified representation of a system used to explain, analyse or predict its behaviour. |
| ceteris paribus/ˈsetərɪs ˈpærɪbəs/ | Holding every other factor unchanged while one factor is studied. |
| normative statement/ˈnɔːmətɪv ˈsteɪtmənt/ | A statement of opinion about what should happen, which cannot be tested with evidence. |
| positive statement/ˈpɒzɪtɪv ˈsteɪtmənt/ | A statement of fact that can be tested with evidence. |
| value judgement/ˈvæljuː ˈdʒʌdʒmənt/ | An assessment based on beliefs about what is desirable, fair or important. |
Did the fare rise cut the journeys?
- At the end of 2014 Beijing replaced its flat ¥2 subway fare with distance-based fares of ¥3 and more.
- In the following weeks fewer journeys were made. But it was also winter, and Spring Festival travel was starting.
- How much of the fall was caused by the fare? Answering that is what an economic model 模型 is for.
Economics is a social science
- Economists study people, firms and governments. They cannot put a whole city in a laboratory.
- So they build models: simplified versions of reality that keep only the relationship being studied.
- A model is judged by how well it explains and predicts, not by how realistic every detail is.
Why do economists use models?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Whole economies cannot be put in a laboratory, so a model keeps only the relationship being studied.
Ceteris paribus: hold everything else still
- Ceteris paribus 其他条件不变 means "other things being equal".
- To study the fare, the model keeps income, weather, petrol prices and population unchanged.
- Then any change in journeys in the model is caused by the fare alone.
"Other things being equal" is written in Latin as ceteris ____.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Ceteris paribus holds every other factor constant so that one cause can be studied.
Worked example: isolate the fare effect
A model of journeys per day (thousands) is $Q = 200 - 5P$, where $P$ is the fare.
- At $P = 10$: $Q = 200 - 5(10) = 150$.
- At $P = 12$: $Q = 200 - 5(12) = 140$.
- Model effect of the fare rise: $140 - 150 = -10$ thousand journeys.
- Real journeys fell from $150$ to $125$, a fall of $25$. Only about $10$ of that is the fare; the other $15$ came from factors that were not held constant.

The isolated effect of a fare rise
The model Q = 200 − 5P predicts 150 journeys at a fare of 10 and 140 at 12: the isolated model effect of the fare rise is −10 journeys, other factors unchanged.
With $Q = 200 - 5P$, by how many thousand journeys does $Q$ fall when the fare rises from 12 to 14?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
$Q$ falls from $140$ to $130$: each extra unit of fare loses $5$ thousand journeys.
Positive and normative statements
- A positive statement 实证性陈述 is about what is, was or will be. It can be tested with evidence: "The fare rise reduced journeys by 10,000 a day."
- A normative statement 规范性陈述 is about what ought to be. It contains a value judgement 价值判断: "Fares should be kept low so that poorer workers can travel."
- Clue words for normative: should, ought, fair, too high, better.
Which statements are NORMATIVE?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
"Should" and "unfair" carry value judgements. The other two can be checked against data.
Positive does not mean true. "The fare rise doubled journeys" is a positive statement — it can be tested, and the test shows it is false. A statement is positive because it can be checked against evidence, not because it is correct.
"Raising the minimum wage always increases unemployment" is a positive statement.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
It is a claim about what happens, so it can be tested with evidence. Evidence suggests it is not always true, but it is still positive.
Why value judgements matter in policy
- Evidence can tell a city how many journeys a fare rise loses and how much revenue it raises.
- It cannot tell the city whether lower fares for workers are worth the cost to taxpayers. That choice needs value judgements.
- So good policy analysis keeps the two apart: first the positive effects, then the normative weighing.
A city must decide whether to cut fares. Which question can evidence alone answer?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
The number of extra journeys is a positive question. The other three need value judgements.
Economists use models with ceteris paribus to isolate one cause at a time. Positive statements can be tested with evidence, even if they turn out false; normative statements contain value judgements about what should happen. Policy needs both.
Write one positive and one normative statement about the price of housing in a large city.
Test each one by asking whether evidence could settle it.