Dialysis and transplant: compare evidence and burdens
Introduced| English | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Transplant/trænˈsplænt/ | A long-term cure and cheaper overall, but there are not enough donors, and rejection is a risk. |
| Dialysis/daɪˈæləsɪs/ | Available, but time-consuming, restricts diet and travel, and is costly over years. |
Twelve hours a week
- In 1954 surgeons in Boston gave Ronald Herrick's kidney to his identical twin, Richard: the first successful organ transplant.
- Today, a patient with kidney failure either has dialysis — about 12 hours a week on a machine — or waits for a donor kidney.
Dialysis
- Blood flows through a machine on one side of a partially permeable membrane. Dialysis 透析 fluid flows on the other side.
- The fluid has the same glucose and useful ion concentrations as normal blood, but no urea. Urea and excess ions diffuse out; nothing useful is lost.
Why does dialysis fluid contain glucose at the normal blood concentration?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
No concentration gradient for glucose.
Worked example: one dialysis session
Waste in a patient's blood falls from 24 to 9 units during a session.
- Removed $= 24 - 9 = 15$ units.
- Percentage removed $= \dfrac{15}{24} \times 100 = 62.5\%$.
- Why not all of it: as urea leaves, the concentration difference shrinks and diffusion slows. Fresh fluid keeps the gradient as steep as possible.
Waste removed by dialysis
Waste falls from 24 to 9 units: 15 removed, 15 ÷ 24 × 100 = 62.5% of the starting amount.
Urea falls from 30 to 12 units. What percentage is removed?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
18 ÷ 30 × 100 = 60%.
Kidney transplant
- A healthy kidney from a donor is put into the patient. It works all the time, so the patient is free of the machine.
- But the immune system may attack it: the donor must be closely matched, and the patient takes immunosuppressant drugs for life.
Why does a transplant patient take immunosuppressant drugs?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
The donor kidney has foreign antigens.
Comparing the two
- Dialysis: available, but time-consuming, restricts diet and travel, and is costly over years.
- Transplant 移植: a long-term cure and cheaper overall, but there are not enough donors, and rejection is a risk.
Dialysis or transplant?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Each has its burdens.
Dialysis fluid is not pure water. If it were, glucose and useful ions would diffuse out of the blood too. It contains them at normal blood concentrations so only waste is removed.
Dialysis fluid is pure water.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
It contains glucose and ions.
Dialysis removes urea and excess ions by diffusion across a partially permeable membrane into fluid matched to healthy blood. A transplant restores full kidney function but needs a matched donor and lifelong anti-rejection drugs.
Evaluate kidney transplant as a treatment compared with dialysis.
Evaluate both sides.