Higher Tier: evidence about brain function
Introduced| English | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Electrical stimulation/ɪˈlektrɪkl ˌstɪmjʊˈleɪʃn/ | During brain surgery, a small current is applied to one area while the patient is awake. |
| MRI scanning/ˌem ɑː ˈaɪ ˈskænɪŋ/ | A scan that uses magnets and radio waves to image soft tissue like the brain. |
Phineas Gage, 1848 (Higher)
- In 1848 an iron rod shot through the front of railway worker Phineas Gage's head. He survived — but friends said he was "no longer Gage": rude, impatient, unreliable.
- Cases like his gave the first evidence that brain regions have specific jobs.
Evidence from damage
- Doctors study patients with brain damage from injury, stroke or tumours, and note which abilities are lost.
- This links a region to a function, but each case is unique.
Evidence from stimulation
- Electrical stimulation 电刺激: during brain surgery, a small current is applied to one area while the patient is awake.
- If a hand twitches or a memory returns, that area is linked to that function.
Worked example: how strong is the evidence?
Stimulating one area produced finger movement in 18 of 24 patients.
- Response rate $= \dfrac{18}{24} \times 100 = 75\%$.
- 6 patients responded differently, perhaps because brains vary slightly.
- Conclusion: strong evidence linking the area to finger movement, but not true for everyone.
A response in most stimulation cases
18 of 24 stimulation cases show the response: 75%. Six cases differ, so the evidence is strong but not universal.
21 of 30 patients show the same response to stimulation. What percentage is that?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
21 ÷ 30 × 100 = 70%.
Evidence from MRI
- MRI scanning 磁共振成像 shows which areas are most active during a task, such as listening to music, without surgery.
- It is safe, but shows activity, not cause.
Match each method to what it does.
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Three kinds of evidence.
What is an advantage of MRI over electrical stimulation?
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
It is non-invasive.
Why treatment is difficult
- The brain is delicate and hard to reach; surgery can damage healthy tissue.
- It is often unclear exactly which region causes a problem, and drugs struggle to cross into the brain from blood.
Why is it hard to treat brain disorders?
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
The brain is complex and protected.
An active area on a scan is not proof that it controls the task. MRI shows where blood flow rises. Another region could be doing the work while the active one supports it.
An area that lights up on an MRI scan must cause the behaviour.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Activity is not proof of cause.
Evidence about brain function comes from damage, electrical stimulation and MRI scans. Each has limits. The brain is complex, delicate and hard to reach, so investigating and treating it carries risks.
Evaluate the use of patient brain damage as evidence of brain function.
Evaluate both sides.