D'une affirmation de source à une conclusion justifiée
Introduit| English | Sens |
|---|---|
| source claim/sɔːs kleɪm/ | affirmation de la source |
| scope/skəʊp/ | portée |
| measure/ˈmeʒə/ | indicateur |
| warrant/ˈwɒrənt/ | justification |
| limitation/ˌlɪmɪˈteɪʃn/ | limitation |
An announcement is not an outcome
- A museum announces: “Our new audio guide makes every visit easier.” A later report says that 18 of 20 visitors who tried it found the instructions clearer. Does this establish an improvement for every visitor?
- A source claim 来源主张 records what its maker says. The announcement shows the museum made a promise; testing its effect needs evidence about actual visits. These statements are invented for this lesson.
Ce que l'annonce établit directement ?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Une annonce enregistre la promesse, pas son effet vérifié.
Identify who supplied the evidence
- The report concerns 20 users of the audio guide. It says nothing about visitors who did not use it, or why they did not. Keep the studied group visible when explaining the result.
- Scope 范围 is the range covered by a claim. “18 of these 20 users” fits the reported count. “Every visitor benefits” goes beyond it, even if the users gave honest answers.

Les rapports 18 positifs établissent que tous les visiteurs du musée ont bénéficié de l'amélioration.
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Le rapport porte sur les utilisateurs 20 du guide, pas sur chaque visiteur.
Read the measure before the conclusion
- “Instructions clearer” describes reported understanding of instructions. It does not measure waiting time, access to every exhibit or enjoyment of the whole visit. Decide what the question actually asks.
- A measure 衡量指标 must address the proposed outcome. More responses to the same narrow question would not automatically establish an improvement in all parts of a visit.
Quelle conclusion correspond à la mesure déclarée ?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
La question porte sur la clarté déclarée des instructions.
Explain the evidence-to-claim connection
- A warrant 论证依据 explains why evidence supports a conclusion. Here, users' reports can support a limited claim about their experience of the instructions. Explain that connection rather than writing “the report proves success”.
- Consider what could change the interpretation. If staff invited only satisfied users to respond, selection may affect the finding. Investigate how the users were chosen; do not invent a selection problem as an established fact.
Associez la partie de l'argument à son rôle.
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Conserver la distinction entre l'affirmation, la preuve et sa portée.
State what remains unanswered
- A limitation 局限 matters when it changes what you can conclude. The missing non-user evidence prevents a conclusion about all museum visitors. It does not erase what the 20 users reported.
- An actual research plan needs traceable sources, a permitted subject method and supervisor review. This fictional practice case supplies no collected data, approved research question or completed essay paragraph.
Quelles actions suivantes peuvent améliorer la décision de recherche ?
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Évaluer la méthode de collecte et le résultat avant d'élargir la réponse.
Comment décrire un biais de sélection éventuel ?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Une préoccupation éventuelle nécessite une investigation et un compte rendu raisonné de son effet.
The report states that 18 of 20 audio-guide users found the instructions clearer. This supports a claim about those users' reported understanding, provided the wording and collection process are checked. It does not establish that the guide improved every visit: non-users are absent, and other aspects of a visit were not measured. A next research decision is to define the intended outcome and check what evidence is accessible before widening the claim.
A source can be quoted accurately while the conclusion drawn from it is too broad. Check the group, measure and inference as well as the quotation.
Separate what a source says, what its evidence measures and what your argument can reasonably conclude.
Write from 18 of 20
- A museum says its audio guide makes every visit easier. 18 of 20 users found the instructions clearer.
- 18 of 20 is not every visitor, and clearer instructions are not the whole visit.
18 des 20 utilisateurs ont trouvé les instructions du guide audio plus claires. Le musée affirme que chaque visite est plus facile. Que peut soutenir le 18 ?
Une mesure doit correspondre au résultat. La portée désigne le groupe et la question effectivement traités.
Quelle affirmation correspond à 18 de 20 ?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Le décompte concerne les instructions parmi les 20 utilisateurs. Il ne s'agit pas de tous les visiteurs, et l'annonce ne reflète pas ce décompte.