Climate evidence, energy budgets and policy
Introduit| English | Sens |
|---|---|
| mitigation/ˌmɪtɪˈɡeɪʃn/ | atténuation |
| adaptation/ˌædæpˈteɪʃn/ | adaptation |
What would explain this observation?
- One cold day does not disprove a warming climate. Weather describes short-term conditions; climate describes distributions over longer times and regions.
Build the model
- The Earth energy balance includes incoming solar radiation, reflection, absorption and outgoing infrared radiation.
- Greenhouse gases absorb and emit infrared radiation.
- Feedback can alter the response to an initial forcing.
- mitigation 减缓: Actions addressing causes of environmental change.
- adaptation 适应: Actions reducing harm from environmental impacts.
Which action is adaptation to flood risk?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Adaptation reduces the impact of a risk that remains - moving equipment above flood level does exactly that. Measuring CO2 is monitoring, and ignoring the risk is neither mitigation nor adaptation.
Match each technical term to its precise meaning.
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Use the definitions to distinguish related quantities and processes.
Choose evidence that can test it
- Distinguish mitigation, which addresses drivers, from adaptation, which reduces harm from impacts.
- A policy assessment needs evidence about effectiveness, cost, equity and uncertainty; one criterion is not the entire decision.
In the lab: Compare multi-year data using consistent baselines. State the region, timescale and uncertainty. At HL, connect a management decision to law, economics and ethics rather than treating these lenses as extra definitions only.
Which two habits make the investigation or model in this case more defensible?
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Stating the conditions and assumptions lets others repeat the work exactly, and recording the supporting evidence lets them check the conclusion. Hiding disagreeing results removes the evidence that could challenge a wrong conclusion, and one measurement can never establish a wider claim.
Work from known quantities
- Known: a surface receives 200 power units and reflects 50.
- Absorbed input = incoming-reflected = 200-50 = 150.
- Reflected fraction = 50/200 = 0.25 = 25%.
- A change in reflectivity alters the absorbed budget under this model.
Your turn: Incoming energy is 240 units and reflected energy 72. Find reflected percentage.
Reflection changes the absorbed energy budget
The lesson's 200 incoming power units split into 50 reflected and 150 absorbed. An added illustrative outgoing infrared power of 150 initially balances absorption. Compare the flows as reflectivity changes; this does not predict temperature or a climate trend.
Incoming energy is 240 units and reflected energy 72. Find reflected percentage.
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
The result is 30 %. Known: incoming 240 units; reflected 72 units. Use reflected percentage = reflected / incoming x 100. Percentage = 72/240 x 100 = 30%. The absorbed share is 70% under this budget.
Check the conclusion and its limits
- The greenhouse effect is not the same process as ozone depletion.
- A carbon footprint estimate depends on its system boundary.
Not true: One local weather observation establishes a global climate trend. Weather is a short-term local state; climate is the long-term statistical pattern. One cold day in one city cannot confirm or refute a global trend built from decades of worldwide records.
- The Earth energy balance includes incoming solar radiation, reflection, absorption and outgoing infrared radiation.
- Distinguish mitigation, which addresses drivers, from adaptation, which reduces harm from impacts.
- Watch for: the greenhouse effect is not the same process as ozone depletion.
Weather is a short-term local state; climate is the long-term statistical pattern.
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
True. Weather is a short-term local state; climate is the long-term statistical pattern. One cold day in one city cannot confirm or refute a global trend built from decades of worldwide records.
Actions addressing causes of environmental change: write the technical term.
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
mitigation means Actions addressing causes of environmental change.
Write from a reflected share of 20 percent
- An opaque surface receives 180 energy units and reflects 36; none is transmitted.
- Find the reflected percentage and the absorbed amount.
An opaque surface receives 180 energy units and reflects 36; no incoming energy is transmitted. What percentage is reflected, how much incoming energy is absorbed, and how is mitigation different from adaptation?
36 divided by 180 is 0.20. 180 minus 36 is 144.
An opaque surface receives 180 energy units and reflects 36, with no transmission. Find reflected percentage and absorbed incoming energy.
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Reflected percentage = reflected/incoming × 100 = 36/180 × 100 = 20%. With no transmission, absorbed incoming energy = incoming − reflected = 180 − 36 = 144 energy units.
Compare climate records using a stated baseline
- Weather is a short-term atmospheric state; climate describes distributions over longer periods and regions. Compare consistent locations, seasons, methods and uncertainty. An invented temperature anomaly rising from +0.4 to +1.0 degrees Celsius changes by +0.6 degrees relative to the stated reference; these are not the absolute temperatures.
- A percentage calculated from a Celsius anomaly can be misleading because the reference zero is chosen. Ice-core carbon dioxide and reconstructed temperature can correlate while feedbacks and common drivers also operate. Correlation alone does not determine the whole causal direction; independent physical evidence and other observations support the greenhouse mechanism. One cold or hot local day does not settle a global trend.
An invented temperature anomaly changes from +0.4 to +1.0 degrees Celsius relative to the same reference. Find the change in degrees Celsius.
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
1.0 − 0.4 = +0.6 degrees. The anomaly is a difference from a reference, not an absolute temperature or a universal percentage warming.
Connect human emissions with active carbon stores and removal
- Fossil-fuel burning transfers carbon from geological stores to the active atmosphere–ocean–biosphere system. Deforestation can release stored carbon and reduce later uptake. Atmospheric carbon dioxide can increase even while vegetation and oceans absorb some emissions, because sinks need not remove the full added amount.
- Human-associated methane sources include fossil-fuel leaks, anaerobic decomposition in landfills or flooded rice fields, and microbial digestion in ruminants. Emission rate and atmospheric concentration are different: concentration also depends on removal. Neither gas comes from only one activity, and a continuing sink does not imply that human additions have no effect.
Separate infrared transfer from surface reflectivity
- Greenhouse gases absorb and emit infrared radiation at relevant wavelengths, changing radiative transfer and energy balance. They do not form a solid roof or reflect all outgoing radiation. The natural greenhouse effect and its enhancement are related; ozone depletion is a separate process.
- In an invented surface budget, incoming 240 power units minus reflected 72 gives absorbed input 168 and a reflected share of 30%. Another surface receiving 180 and reflecting 36 absorbs 144 and reflects 20%; the separate SL written case receives 200 and reflects 28, giving 172 absorbed and 14% reflected. State the case and consistent energy/power units; this simplified reflection budget does not determine the whole planet's temperature.
Close each reinforcing feedback through its physical mechanism
- Warming can remove bright snow/ice, expose a darker surface, increase solar absorption and promote further warming. Thaw can expose frozen organic material to decomposition: aerobic pathways release carbon dioxide, while waterlogged low-oxygen conditions can support methane production. The gas need not all have been pre-made inside ice.
- Peat drying, drought and fire can release stored carbon and reduce later uptake, reinforcing warming. Rates still depend on moisture, oxygen, substrate and organism limits. Carbon-rich deep water reaching the surface can release carbon dioxide, while warming affects solubility; circulation and biology also matter. Local release does not establish that the entire ocean is a net source.

Distinguish a boreal carbon stock from its current net balance
- In an invented hectare, annual carbon uptake 10 tonnes C and respiration 8 give net retention +2 tonnes C with no fire. A dry fire year with uptake 7, respiration 8 and combustion 3 gives −4 tonnes C: a net source for that boundary and year. Even without fire, uptake 7 minus respiration 8 would be a loss of one tonne C.
- A large existing stock does not make a forest a current sink, and tonnes C are not tonnes carbon dioxide. Walker and colleagues' research summary describes radiocarbon evidence for legacy-soil-carbon combustion in vulnerable Canadian forest conditions. It supports a loss mechanism, not one universal tipping age for every boreal forest. Repeated measurements are needed before calling a one-year loss permanent collapse.

An invented hectare takes up 1,200 kg C annually, loses 900 kg C through respiration and 450 kg C through fire. Calculate net ecosystem carbon retention in kg C for that year.
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
1,200 − 900 − 450 = −150 kg C. Negative retention means a net source for the defined year/boundary, not proof of permanent collapse or a quantity in kg CO2.
Explain polar habitat loss through season, location and life stage
- Landfast sea ice is attached to a coast or fixed feature; drifting sea ice moves, and both differ from a land-based glacier. Emperor penguins commonly breed on stable Antarctic sea ice. Early breakup can remove the platform before chicks have waterproof plumage. Fretwell and colleagues' 2023 satellite study reported evidence of breeding failure at four of five studied Bellingshausen Sea colonies in 2022, not every colony in Antarctica.
- Arctic walruses use ice as resting platforms near shallow feeding grounds. Retreat beyond suitable shelf habitat can increase travel or crowd coastal haulouts, where young animals can be vulnerable during disturbance. Walruses feed on benthic organisms rather than eating ice. Habitat function depends on position, season and persistence, not just one annual ice-area total.
Connect ocean mixing with nutrient-limited primary production
- Photosynthesis needs light and nutrients. Sunlit surface water can become nutrient-depleted, while mixing and upwelling supply nutrient-rich deeper water. Warmer surface layers can strengthen stratification and reduce vertical exchange. Winds, salinity and currents also affect delivery; warmth does not create nitrate by itself.
- If nutrient supply limits producers, reduced delivery can lower production and food-web energy input. In an invented comparison, production falls from 500 to 400 units per square metre per year, a 20% reduction. An assumed transfer fraction of 0.10 gives 50 then 40 corresponding units at the next level. This is a conditional model, not a universal efficiency or a direct forecast of fish catch at every coast.
An invented primary-production comparison changes from 500 to 400 units per square metre per year. Calculate percentage decrease relative to 500.
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
(500 − 400)/500 × 100 = 20%. An assumed 10% trophic transfer would give 50 then 40 corresponding units, not an unconditional fish-catch forecast.
Distinguish range movement from unlimited habitat escape
- Establishment at a cooler leading edge and loss at a warmer trailing edge can shift a range poleward or upslope. Dispersal, soil, partners, competition and barriers constrain movement; individuals do not need to walk uphill for a population's boundary to change. Survey effort, season and detection must be comparable in resurveys.
- In the invented mountain model, limits move from 900–1,600 m to 1,200–1,800 m. The lower edge rises 300 m and upper edge 200 m, shrinking vertical extent from 700 to 600 m, about 14.3%. Vertical extent is not habitat area, especially near a summit. Real species, including different tree life stages, can show varied responses; a distributional shift alone is not proof of allele-frequency evolution.

An invented mountain range changes from limits 900–1,600 m to 1,200–1,800 m. Find the percentage decrease in vertical extent relative to its initial extent.
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Initial extent 700 m; later 600 m. The decrease is 100/700 × 100 ≈ 14.3%. Vertical extent is not habitat area.
Separate coral bleaching from reduced calcification
- Reef-building corals are animals associated with photosynthetic symbionts supplying much of their nutrition. Heat stress can disrupt the association, reducing symbionts or pigments and revealing the pale skeleton: bleaching. A bleached coral is stressed but not necessarily dead; prolonged or repeated stress can impair recovery and cause mortality.
- Carbon dioxide uptake also increases seawater hydrogen ions and can reduce carbonate availability, making calcium-carbonate construction harder. As NOAA explains, acidification concerns falling pH, not necessarily pH below seven. This chemistry differs from heat-induced bleaching. Lost coral structure can affect shelter, food and reproduction throughout the reef; local pollution or disease can compound stress.
Which explanation correctly separates coral bleaching from ocean acidification?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Bleached corals can survive and recover under suitable conditions. Acidification is a pH decline, with reduced carbonate availability potentially affecting calcium-carbonate structures.
Keep climate adaptation distinct from mitigation and genetic adaptation
- Mitigation addresses drivers, such as fossil-fuel emissions or durable carbon uptake. Climate adaptation reduces harm, for example reconnecting suitable habitats or adjusting water management. One intervention can contribute to both, but reducing flood damage does not automatically lower greenhouse-gas concentration.
- In evolution, adaptation refers to inherited features associated with success; in climate policy, adaptation can be a practical response that requires no genetic change. Likewise, acclimatization within one organism and range movement are not automatically evolution. Name the meaning in context rather than treating every useful response as newly inherited adaptation.
Which action most directly illustrates climate adaptation rather than a demonstrated reduction in the causes of warming?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Climate adaptation reduces impacts; mitigation addresses drivers. A project can do both, but impact reduction alone does not establish reduced greenhouse-gas concentration or genetic evolution.
Assess sequestration through net storage, baseline and permanence
- Afforestation establishes forest on land not recently forested; regeneration restores tree cover through recovery. Net carbon retention depends on growth, soil disturbance, respiration, harvest, later fire and what would otherwise happen. Planting one seedling does not make its carbon permanent. Compare native regeneration and non-native plantations over equivalent boundaries and timescales, including water use, habitat and reflectivity.
- Rewetting peat-forming wetlands can slow aerobic decomposition and support organic accumulation when production exceeds loss. Methane emissions can also change, so stored carbon and total climate effects need separate accounting. Tropical, temperate and boreal peat systems need not have identical rates. A stock estimate alone does not establish annual additional removal or a zero-emission outcome.
Compare policy claims using several explicit criteria
- Effectiveness, cost, equity and uncertainty address different questions. Include construction, maintenance, land-use change, displaced emissions and later releases where relevant to the chosen boundary. A cheap project can have little net benefit if it merely shifts emissions elsewhere; a large gross uptake can conceal a small additional net gain.
- Compare measured or modelled outcomes against an explicit baseline, giving the timescale and uncertainty. Legal requirements, economics and ethical priorities can influence choices, but a decision needs evidence linking the intervention to its intended outcome. A single cost or photograph cannot establish the full comparison.
Link a climate driver to an ecological consequence and its limits
- Trace the relevant physical change through habitat, nutrients, physiology or interactions to a biological outcome. Distinguish mechanisms such as sea-ice platform loss, stratification, coral heat stress and seawater chemistry rather than writing one generic warming arrow. Name the region, life stage and evidence used.
- In numerical work, use consistent carbon mass, proper starting denominators and the actual system boundary. Separate stocks, net fluxes, percentage points and differences from an anomaly baseline. Explain one alternative influence, one measurement limitation and what further evidence would strengthen a claim about persistence, recovery or causation.
Explain two different routes from climate-related change to a biological outcome, then evaluate a carbon-sequestration or adaptation claim. Include a calculation or measurement limit.
A causal pathway and a defined comparison support a claim more strongly than one generic warming arrow or gross uptake figure.
AHL: Explain phenology using cues and biological timing
- Phenology concerns timing of budburst, flowering, bud set, migration, nesting and seasonal growth. Temperature, accumulated warmth, snowmelt and photoperiod can be cues. Day length at the same latitude and calendar date does not increase merely because climate warms. Different organisms can respond to different cue windows.
- Earlier warmth or snowmelt can advance young growth in Arctic mouse-ear chickweed, while migrating reindeer may not shift arrival equally because of different cues and route constraints. Reduced overlap with nutritious growth can affect reproduction without assuming one exclusive food or that all migration is controlled only by day length. A timing response can be plasticity rather than demonstrated genetic evolution.
AHL: What does warming itself imply about photoperiod at a fixed latitude on a fixed calendar date?
Difficulté 1/5 · 100 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Temperature, snowmelt and cue windows can change while the date/latitude photoperiod remains the same. Plasticity, constraints and inheritance require separate evidence.
AHL: Distinguish advancing events from maintaining synchrony
- Visser and colleagues' Hoge Veluwe study compared 1973–1995 great-tit reproduction with the estimated caterpillar food peak. Food timing advanced without equivalent mean laying-date advancement. Birds can use temperature as well as photoperiod; the timing of cues, egg resources and delay to offspring demand matter, rather than birds being unable to change timing.
- In an invented model, food and demand both peak on day 115 initially. Later, food peaks on day 100 and demand on day 110: they advance 15 and five days, leaving a ten-day difference. Both moved earlier, yet mismatch increased. Separate relative curve scales do not imply equal masses, and peak dates alone do not determine total usable food or overlap.

AHL: In the invented later model, food peaks on day 100 and offspring demand on day 110. Find the difference between peak dates in days.
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
110 − 100 = 10 days. Both events advanced from day 115, by fifteen and five days respectively; advancing both does not guarantee synchrony.
AHL: Distinguish an extra brood from a completed insect generation
- Spruce bark beetle development, including Ips typographus, depends on suitable temperatures and season length. A longer warm season can permit another generation where previously one was possible, potentially increasing pressure on drought-stressed spruce. Photoperiod and temperature also affect seasonal activity and diapause; excessive heat or limited hosts can still reduce success.
- A sister brood from the same parents is not a completed new generation. Forest Research's account describes geographical variation. In an invented unlimited-resource model, 100 adults each leave four reproductive offspring: one generation gives 400, and a second gives 1,600. These potential counts require survival and reproduction, not merely another flight or egg-laying event.
AHL: An invented unlimited-resource model begins with 100 adults. Each completed generation yields four reproductive offspring per adult. How many reproductive adults are predicted after two completed generations?
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
100 × 4 × 4 = 1,600. A second brood from the same parents is not automatically a completed second generation; survival and host constraints can change real outcomes.
AHL: Connect changed survival selection with inherited variants
- Karell and colleagues' Finnish tawny-owl study found stronger survival selection against the heritable brown morph in snow-rich winters. The disadvantage diminished as winters became milder, alongside increasing brown-morph frequency. This does not mean grey individuals turned brown or that camouflage alone was established as the cause.
- In an invented population of 40 brown and 60 grey adults, survival fractions 0.50 and 0.80 give 20 and 48 survivors: brown fraction about 29.4%, down from 40%. At 0.80 survival for both, counts 32 and 48 retain 40% brown. These are phenotype proportions among survivors, not direct allele frequencies or a complete multigeneration breeding model.
AHL: Invented initial counts are forty brown and sixty grey owls. Their survival fractions are 0.50 and 0.80. Find brown morph percentage among survivors.
Difficulté 2/5 · 140 pièces + un petit bonus lors de la première réussite aujourd'hui
Brown survivors 20; grey 48. 20/68 × 100 ≈ 29.4%. This is a phenotype proportion among survivors, not direct allele frequency or a complete breeding model.
AHL: Match the type of response to the evidence collected
- An individual adjusting physiology, a population moving its range, events shifting timing and inherited frequencies changing are different responses. Ask whether measurements concern physiology, occurrence, event dates, survival, breeding or genotypes. A shared association with temperature does not make them one mechanism.
- For an evolutionary claim, establish inheritance and differential contribution as well as environmental change. For mismatch, compare both interacting schedules and the time window of resource use. For a pest projection, distinguish potential generations from observed survival and host damage. Name uncertainty and regional scope before extrapolating a result to other systems.
AHL: Distinguish phenological mismatch, additional insect generations and a climate-associated evolutionary response using the taught examples. What extra evidence keeps each claim defensible?
Identify what was measured: physiology, event time, occurrence, survival, reproduction or alleles.