Environmental ethics: make the value judgement explicit
Introducido| English | Significado |
|---|---|
| intrinsic value/ɪnˈtrɪnsɪk ˈvæljuː/ | valor intrínseco |
| environmental justice/enˌvaɪrənˈmentl ˈdʒʌstɪs/ | justicia ambiental |
| instrumental value | The worth of something as a means to an end, especially for people's use. |
| consequentialism/ˌkɒnsɪˈkwenʃɪəlɪzəm/ | Judging an action by its outcomes. |
| virtue ethics/ˈvɜːtʃuː ˈeθɪks/ | Judging action by the character traits it expresses and develops. |
| indigenous/ɪnˈdɪdʒənəs/ | Belonging to a people with a long ancestral connection to a place. |
| distributive justice | Fairness in how environmental benefits and burdens are shared. |
| procedural justice | Fairness in how decisions are made, including who has a say. |
| loss and damage | Climate harms that cannot be avoided by adaptation, and the funding to address them. |
| intergenerational equity | Fairness between present and future generations. |
What would explain this observation?
- People may agree on the measured loss of a wetland but disagree on whether a development is acceptable. The disagreement can concern values as well as scientific uncertainty.
Build the model
- Environmental ethics examines reasons for responsibilities toward people, other organisms and ecological systems.
- Anthropocentric reasoning emphasizes human interests; biocentric reasoning recognizes moral standing of living organisms; ecocentric reasoning emphasizes ecological wholes.
- These positions are lenses for analysing arguments, and real individuals can combine them.
- intrinsic value 内在价值: Value considered independent of usefulness to another party.
- environmental justice 环境正义: Fair treatment in environmental burdens, benefits and decision-making.
Which statement is a value judgement rather than a measured observation?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
"Ought" expresses a value judgement; it cannot be measured. Species counts and areas are observations checkable by survey. Keeping the two kinds of statement distinct is the first step in an honest ethical argument.
Match each technical term to its precise meaning.
Dificultad 2/5 · 140 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Use the definitions to distinguish related quantities and processes.
Choose evidence that can test it
- Separate descriptive claims from normative claims.
- A species count is evidence about the sampled community; deciding that every species has intrinsic value is a value position.
- Compare consequences, rights, duties and fairness across generations.
- A defensible argument states its values, uses accurate evidence and acknowledges competing claims rather than disguising a value choice as a calculation.
In the lab: Use a fictional planning dispute or an attributed historical case. Build an argument table: stakeholder, factual claim, evidence, value principle and possible response. Include affected communities and future generations without pretending to speak for them. Use voluntary anonymous classroom positions; assess the reasoning rather than agreement with a preferred worldview.
Which two habits make the investigation or model in this case more defensible?
Dificultad 2/5 · 140 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Stating the conditions and assumptions lets others repeat the work exactly, and recording the supporting evidence lets them check the conclusion. Hiding disagreeing results removes the evidence that could challenge a wrong conclusion, and one measurement can never establish a wider claim.
Work from known quantities
- Known: a wetland proposal affects 12 hectares of a 60-hectare site, or 20%.
- This quantifies the stated area change.
- An anthropocentric argument might examine flood protection and livelihoods; a biocentric argument might consider affected organisms; an ecocentric argument might consider hydrological connections.
- The 20% figure cannot alone decide which ethical argument is strongest.
Your turn: A project affects 9 hectares within a 45-hectare site. Calculate the percentage of area affected.
A project affects 9 hectares within a 45-hectare site. Calculate the percentage of area affected.
Dificultad 2/5 · 140 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
The result is 20 %. Known: 9 hectares affected within a 45-hectare site. Use percentage = affected / total x 100. Percentage = 9/45 x 100 = 20%. The figure quantifies scale; it does not decide acceptability.
Check the conclusion and its limits
- Worldview labels are analytical aids, not fixed stereotypes of cultures or people.
- Neither a stakeholder majority nor a numerical index automatically resolves a rights-based or intergenerational objection.
Not true: A percentage of habitat lost alone settles the ethical acceptability of a development. The 20% is a measurement; acceptability is a judgement that also weighs what the habitat means, who is affected and what alternatives exist. Different ethical frameworks can weigh the same 20% differently.
- Environmental ethics examines reasons for responsibilities toward people, other organisms and ecological systems.
- Separate descriptive claims from normative claims.
- Watch for: worldview labels are analytical aids, not fixed stereotypes of cultures or people.
The 20% is a measurement; acceptability is a judgement that also weighs what the habitat means, who is affected and what alternatives exist.
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
True. The 20% is a measurement; acceptability is a judgement that also weighs what the habitat means, who is affected and what alternatives exist. Different ethical frameworks can weigh the same 20% differently.
Value considered independent of usefulness to another party: write the technical term.
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
intrinsic value means Value considered independent of usefulness to another party.
Write from 30 percent of the site
- A proposal affects 15 hectares of a 50-hectare site.
- Find the percentage of area affected. That percentage does not settle whether the proposal is ethically acceptable.
A proposal affects 15 hectares of a 50-hectare site. What percentage of the site is affected, and why does that percentage not settle the ethical question?
The affected share is the affected area divided by the site area. A measurement is not by itself an ethical verdict.
A proposal affects 15 hectares within a 50-hectare wetland site. What percentage of the site is affected?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Affected percentage = affected area/total site area × 100 = 15/50 × 100 = 30%. The hectare counts are inputs, not percentages. This area share alone does not settle ethical acceptability.
Separate an observation from a recommendation
- A measured habitat area is descriptive evidence. Saying the habitat ought to be protected is a normative conclusion requiring a value premise.
- Forecasts also need evidence and uncertainty: a promised benefit is not already an observation. State what is known, assumed and valued.
What is missing from a purely factual description if an ethical conclusion follows?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Facts inform reasoning, but a recommendation also depends on normative premises.
Place the field in historical context
- Modern academic environmental ethics expanded in the 1960s and 1970s as environmental crises prompted questions about moral concern beyond interpersonal relations. Earlier cultures also developed environmental ethical ideas.
- Environmental and social-justice movements have distinct histories but can share concerns about exploitation, participation and burdens. Shared aims and conflicts both need explanation.
Did environmental ethical thinking begin in every culture only in the 1960s?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Distinguish a modern academic field from the long and varied histories of ethical reflection.
Use the turtle example with a date
- WCS reported the death of a female Yangtze giant softshell turtle at Suzhou in April 2019 after a breeding procedure. Last known describes knowledge at that time.
- An old survival count is not a current census or proof of inevitable extinction. Conservation triage needs evidence of prospects, costs, alternatives and the interests at stake.
Can a 2019 count establish the exact surviving population today?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Known individuals and an entire species’ true population are different evidential claims.
Distinguish intrinsic and instrumental value 工具价值
- Instrumental value is value as a means to another end, such as a wetland reducing flood damage. Intrinsic value concerns worth for its own sake.
- One argument can recognise both. A willingness-to-pay estimate does not directly measure intrinsic moral worth or settle whether substitution is acceptable.
Which is an intrinsic-value claim?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
The reason given, rather than the policy conclusion, identifies the kind of value.
Identify moral standing
- Moral standing means an entity’s interests count directly rather than only through effects on somebody else. Different frameworks debate the scope and grounds.
- Labels are analytical aids, not a ladder of moral development or fixed identities for cultures and individuals. A person can combine several reasons.

Does a worldview label establish one person’s position on every issue?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Examine the actual reason and context rather than stereotyping people.
Compare human-centred and sentience-based reasons
- An anthropocentric reason gives direct moral weight to human interests, including future people. It can support strict protection because humans depend on ecosystems.
- A sentientist reason gives direct weight to beings capable of experience or suffering. Evidence and uncertainty about experience matter; a policy label alone does not settle the scope.
Can an anthropocentric argument support conserving a wetland?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
The scope of concern does not mechanically determine one policy verdict.
Compare organisms and ecological wholes
- Biocentric reasons recognise living organisms’ worth; ecocentric reasons also focus on species, communities and ecological systems.
- Protecting a whole ecosystem can conflict with protecting some individuals. Assess the specific conflict and constraints rather than assuming everyone with a label gives one answer.
What distinguishes a reason centred on ecological wholes?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
A focus on wholes differs from treating every relevant entity as only an individual.
Apply the land ethic carefully
- Leopold’s land ethic places people within a biotic community and emphasizes integrity, stability and beauty. It broadens the objects of ethical attention.
- Invoking the land ethic does not establish that a proposed cull will work, that all methods are acceptable or that every ecocentric agrees. Ecological predictions still need evidence.
Does an ecocentric value premise establish an intervention’s effectiveness?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Values and empirical predictions play different roles in an argument.
Distinguish frameworks from outcomes
- Consequentialism 后果主义 assesses consequences under a stated account of good; utilitarian approaches consider aggregate welfare. Neither is simply counting supporters.
- Deontological approaches emphasize duties and rights; theories differ over conflicts and exceptions. A policy conclusion alone cannot identify which reason produced it.
Which reason is primarily duty-based?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Identify the justificatory reason, not merely approval or rejection of the project.
Evaluate consequences beyond a head count
- Compare severity, duration, probability, distribution and alternatives. Two million small benefits do not automatically outweigh severe harm to 400 people.
- A monetary cost-benefit result is one limited comparison, not a complete measure of welfare or a proof that rights may be ignored. State whose outcomes and what baseline count.
What is wrong with using only beneficiary numbers?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Aggregate reasoning needs more than a count of people on each side.
Handle conflicting duties
- A project may implicate water access, homes, livelihoods and species protection at once. A rights-based argument must identify the duties and justify how conflicts are addressed.
- Different deontological theories allow different priorities or exceptions. Do not reduce them to ignoring every consequence or declaring every duty automatically absolute.
What strengthens a duty-based argument with conflicting claims?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
A clear principle still needs an explanation of how it applies under conflict.
Apply virtue and care without prescribing identities
- Virtue ethics 美德伦理 emphasizes character and practices such as humility, moderation and care; care ethics emphasizes relationships and responsibilities to vulnerable others.
- Needs, access and infrastructure constrain choices. Explain why a practice expresses a virtue or relationship rather than grading a person’s whole character from one purchase.
Which fits virtue reasoning?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
The focus is character and practice, with context and constraints acknowledged.
Explain stewardship as a reason
- Stewardship treats people as responsible caretakers with obligations towards the world and those who depend on it. Religious or secular premises can support it.
- Specify the responsibility being argued. Belief that a technology can work is an empirical claim, distinct from whose interests deserve moral consideration.
Does a stewardship label settle every environmental decision?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Explain the actual argument rather than assigning a fixed verdict to a group.
Use traditions without flattening them
- Daoist, Confucian and Indigenous 原住民 traditions contain varied resources for thinking about relationships, responsibility and the world. Interpretations differ within traditions.
- An ancient word translated as nature is not automatically a modern conservation policy. Respect knowledge and participation without claiming one person speaks for every community.
What is a defensible use of a cultural example?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Specific evidence and respectful interpretation avoid stereotypes.
State the invented reservoir assumptions
- A hypothetical reservoir is projected to benefit 2 million people, remove 12 of 60 wetland hectares and displace 400 villagers. The site is a last known frog breeding area.
- Separate projections and scenario assumptions from observations. Ask about need, reliability, habitat function, alternatives and whether a population is viable elsewhere.
Does the phrase last breeding site describe a risk that may exceed a small area percentage?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Area does not by itself measure ecological function or extinction risk.
Calculate area without deciding acceptability
- In the invented case,12/60×100=20%of the wetland area is affected. Another project affecting 15 of 50 hectares affects 30%.
- Neither percentage alone is an ethical verdict. Include habitat quality, cumulative effects, people, uncertainty, alternatives and the stated principles.
Does 20%loss alone establish whether development is right?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Measurement supports but does not replace ethical argument.
Find percentage area affected when 12 of 60 hectares is affected.
Dificultad 2/5 · 140 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
12/60×100=20%; this does not by itself decide acceptability.
Test mitigation rather than assuming success
- Relocating organisms or promising captive breeding does not guarantee survival, viable reproduction or replacement of habitat functions.
- Ask about feasibility, evidence, long-term monitoring, resources, consent and alternatives. An irreversible loss may remain even if a proposal promises compensation.
What does a proposed frog relocation establish by itself?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Evaluate implementation and ecological outcomes separately from a promise.
Test an appeal to nature
- An appeal to nature infers that something is good or right merely because it is natural. A natural toxin can harm organisms; origin alone does not establish ethical acceptability.
- Human-made does not itself mean safe or harmful either. Valuing wildness is a stated value position, while claiming every natural process is beneficial requires a different justification.
What is wrong with natural, therefore morally right as a complete argument?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Use evidence and stated ethical premises rather than treating origin as a complete moral proof.
Build a conditional judgement
- A reasoned answer can support, reject or redesign a proposal. State the principle given priority, the supporting evidence, the strongest objection and the conditions that could change the conclusion.
- Do not conceal a value choice in a calculation or imply only one conclusion receives marks. Assess coherence, evidence and engagement with competing claims.
What makes a judgement defensible?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Ethical assessment concerns the quality of the argument rather than conformity to one verdict.
Distinguish three forms of justice
- Distributive justice 分配正义 concerns benefits and burdens; procedural justice 程序正义 concerns meaningful involvement; recognition concerns respect for identities, knowledge and ways of life.
- The three interact. A meeting can exist without meaningful influence, and equal totals can conceal severe losses to a particular group.
Which question concerns procedural justice?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Participation requires practical access and influence rather than a symbolic meeting alone.
Test recognition and representation
- Ask whose evidence and values are treated as credible and whose relationships with a place are recognised. Avoid assuming that money replaces every cultural or relational loss.
- Communities can contain disagreement. Include different affected voices and protect privacy; do not infer a unanimous position from one spokesperson.
Does one representative necessarily establish every community member’s view?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Respectful participation and empirical evidence can complement one another.
Use a fairness thought experiment
- A veil-of-ignorance approach asks how rules might be chosen without knowing one’s position, wealth or exposure. An environmental application can test whether a rule protects those who could be worst affected.
- This is a normative reasoning tool, not an observed survey result or a proof of one policy. Explain assumptions and compare it with other principles.
What does the thought experiment test?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
A philosophical tool differs from an empirical measurement.
Read the emissions chart’s dates and units
- The GCB 2023 snapshot reports selected cumulative fossil CO₂ shares for 1850–2022 and per-person fossil emissions for 2022. These are different denominators and periods.
- The per-person figures in that report are tonnes of carbon, not tonnes of CO₂. They are not all greenhouse gases, consumption footprints or current 2026 values.

What must be checked before comparing the chart’s numbers?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Metadata determines which factual comparison the values support.
Convert carbon mass explicitly
- CO₂ mass is carbon mass multiplied by 44/12. The source’s reported rounded 2.2 tonnes C per person corresponds to 2.2×44/12≈8.1 tonnes CO₂.
- Do not silently relabel tonnes C as tonnes CO₂, or report precision not supported by the source. The conversion does not change the chosen ethical principle.
Can 2.2 tonnes C be labelled 2.2 tonnes CO₂without conversion?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Use the 44/12 mass ratio and preserve the source’s precision and boundary.
Convert the reported rounded 2.2 tonnes of carbon to tonnes CO₂ using 44/12; an unrounded answer or one decimal is accepted.
Dificultad 2/5 · 140 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
2.2×44/12=8.066666..., approximately 8.1 tonnes CO₂; preserve the source’s reported precision.
Connect a metric with a principle
- Historical totals can inform a polluter-pays argument; current per-person rates can inform an equal-share argument; resources can inform ability to pay.
- No emission ranking alone proves a complete moral or legal duty. State the link between the selected fact and the proposed rule, including its limitations.
Does a numerical ranking alone determine who ought to pay?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Facts about emissions and a justified allocation of responsibility are different steps.
Compare responsibility principles fairly
- Polluter pays links contributions to harm; beneficiary pays links them to benefits obtained; ability to pay emphasizes capacity; equal-per-person approaches concern a specified allocation.
- Start dates, present inequalities, development needs and uncertainty affect application. A proposal can combine principles rather than select only one.
Can responsibility and ability-to-pay principles be combined?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Explain the combination and trade-offs rather than assuming a universal formula.
Avoid hiding inequality in averages
- UNEP’s 2020 chapter reviewed studies giving different global consumption-emission shares for income groups. These are dated estimates across methods, not one current exact value for every country.
- A national average can hide high- and low-emitting households, constrained choices and unequal access to low-carbon infrastructure. Include distribution and feasible alternatives.
Can a national mean describe every household’s footprint?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Averages support some comparisons but cannot substitute for distributional evidence.
Separate loss and damage 损失与损害 from a promise to restore everything
- The 2022 climate decision to establish a loss-and-damage fund concerns support for vulnerable places facing climate harms; governance and delivery require separate evaluation.
- Some losses are irreversible or non-monetary. Finance, adaptation and mitigation address different needs and cannot automatically compensate every harm.
Does establishing a fund prove every loss has been compensated?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
A legal or institutional decision is distinct from its measured effects.
Reason across generations
- Future people cannot participate directly in today’s decisions but may bear long-lived climate, biodiversity or waste consequences. Explain the duties and uncertainties being argued.
- Intergenerational equity 代际公平 concerns fair treatment, not one uncontested measure requiring every environmental feature to stay identical forever. Consider resilience, options and irreversible loss.
Why include future generations?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
The ethical scope and uncertain long-term effects must both be stated.
Interpret discounting without erasing harm
- A higher discount rate reduces the present monetary weighting of distant costs under a model. It does not reduce the physical future damage.
- Economic growth, risk and time-preference assumptions interact with ethical choices. Compare sensitivity and non-monetary constraints rather than calling one rate a neutral fact.
What does a low present value of distant damage show directly?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Money weighting is distinct from future ecological or human consequences.
Assess a cull through several reasons
- Invasive-rat removal may protect seabirds and ecological systems while causing animal suffering. Evidence about effectiveness, methods and alternatives is essential.
- Welfare arguments can consider rats and birds; ecosystem arguments can impose humane constraints. Neither label guarantees support or opposition in every case.
What should be assessed before assigning a verdict to a framework?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Compare specific arguments rather than using labels as automatic answers.
Evaluate zoos with the right evidence
- A conservation claim should show a specified programme’s contribution, welfare conditions, habitat links, costs and alternatives. Education or breeding promises are not outcomes by themselves.
- The panda’s 2016 IUCN status change concerned wild-population evidence; it does not isolate a captive-breeding effect. A zoo’s species list alone is not an evaluation.
Does a wild-species status improvement prove one zoo programme caused it?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Conservation outcomes and welfare need evidence rather than a single label.
Compare conservation triage and new technologies
- With limited resources, compare viability, ecological role, welfare, rights, costs and uncertainty. Rarity or popularity alone need not settle priority.
- Assess a specific GM trait, crop and context rather than assuming every modification raises yield or reduces pesticide use. Ownership, choice and ecological effects may differ.
What improves a technology argument?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
A technology category is too broad to establish every empirical outcome or moral conclusion.
Distinguish solar modification from removing carbon
- Stratospheric-particle proposals aim to alter radiation; they do not themselves remove CO₂ or solve ocean acidification. Regional effects, termination risk and governance need assessment.
- Research, field trials and deployment are different decisions. Compare benefits, uncertainty, duties, participation and who bears risks without assuming one automatic verdict.
Does solar radiation modification itself remove the emitted CO₂?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Mechanisms and proposed outcomes must be distinguished before ethical evaluation.
Write and assess a full argument
- State the decision, descriptive evidence and uncertainty, then identify affected people, organisms and systems. Apply at least two frameworks accurately.
- Explain the strongest counterargument, alternative, distributional issue and conditions behind a clear judgement. Credit rigorous reasoning rather than agreement with a preferred conclusion.
Which response deserves stronger assessment?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Judge the reasoning, evidence and engagement with alternatives.