难道 (rhetorical: don't tell me …?) · ¿Acaso (retórica: ¡no me digas...?)
Read the implied answer from the question
- Someone doubts a claim and asks whether it is possible.
- 难道这是真的吗？ — The speaker challenges the claim's plausibility.
Read the implied answer from the question
- Someone doubts a claim and asks whether it is possible.
- don't tell me ...难道这是really真的(yes/no ?)吗？ — The speaker challenges the claim's plausibility.
Someone doubts a claim and asks whether it is possible. What does 难道这是真的吗？ communicate?
The speaker challenges the claim's plausibility. The implied answer depends on the proposition and context. 难道你不想去吗 often suggests that you do want to go, so the expected response is not always no.
Build the form
- The pattern in this lesson is 难道 (rhetorical: don't tell me …?). Locate it in the original interlinear examples below.
- Keep the words in their demonstrated positions; the pattern must fit the intended situation as well as the sentence form.
don't tell me难道you你forget忘了吗？
Build the form
- The pattern in this lesson is don't tell me ...难道 (rhetorical: don't tell me …?). Locate it in the original interlinear examples below.
- Keep the words in their demonstrated positions; the pattern must fit the intended situation as well as the sentence form.
don't tell me难道you你forget忘了吗？
Using the lesson pattern in this demonstrated example: Don't tell me you forgot?! ____ 你忘了吗?
难道 … 吗? is a rhetorical question: 难道你忘了吗? · **¿Acaso ... ?** es una pregunta retórica: ¿Acaso te has olvidado?
Read examples in context
- In the opening example, 难道这是真的吗？: The speaker challenges the claim's plausibility.
- Explain who acts, what is described and which time or group is relevant before choosing an English paraphrase.
Read examples in context
- In the opening example, don't tell me ...难道这是really真的(yes/no ?)吗？: The speaker challenges the claim's plausibility.
- Explain who acts, what is described and which time or group is relevant before choosing an English paraphrase.
What attitude does 难道 add to the question 难道这是真的吗？?
The implied answer follows the actual proposition and context. A negative 难道 question can expect confirmation of the positive meaning.
Know the boundary
- The implied answer depends on the proposition and context.
- 难道你不想去吗 often suggests that you do want to go, so the expected response is not always no.
Know the boundary
- The implied answer depends on the proposition and context.
- don't tell me ...难道you你unexpectedly不想to go去(yes/no ?)吗 often suggests that you do want to go, so the expected response is not always no.
Every 难道 question expects the answer no.
难道你不想去吗 can suggest that you do want to go. It is rhetorical or challenging, but the answer polarity is not fixed.
In the opening situation: The speaker challenges the claim's plausibility.
The implied answer depends on the proposition and context. 难道你不想去吗 often suggests that you do want to go, so the expected response is not always no. The speaker challenges the claim's plausibility.
Use the distinction
- The speaker challenges the claim's plausibility.
- The implied answer depends on the proposition and context. 难道你不想去吗 often suggests that you do want to go, so the expected response is not always no.
Read the full reference: HSK 4 grammar — Adverbs.
Use the distinction
- The speaker challenges the claim's plausibility.
- The implied answer depends on the proposition and context. don't tell me ...难道you你unexpectedly不想to go去(yes/no ?)吗 often suggests that you do want to go, so the expected response is not always no.
Read the full reference: HSK 4 grammar — Adverbs.