Related rates and removable quotient limits
Introducido| English | Significado |
|---|---|
| related rates/rɪˈleɪtɪd reɪts/ | tasas relacionadas |
| removable/rɪˈmuːvəbl/ | evitable |
| cross-section/krɒs ˈsekʃn/ | sección transversal |
The same fall can mean different outflows
- A spherical tank's level falls by a quarter of a metre per minute. A depth sensor alone cannot give the volume leaving: the area of the water surface matters at that instant.
- Related rates 相关变化率 connect changing quantities through a geometric equation. Later, removable 可去的 quotient limits show another distinction: filling a hole can restore continuity without giving a derivative.
State the physical model before differentiating
- Use a fixed tank with a horizontal liquid surface. Let $h(t)$ be depth above the bottom, $V(h)$ the volume below that level and $A(h)$ its horizontal cross-section 横截面 area. At an interior level, the chain rule gives $dV/dt=A(h)\,dh/dt$.
- Assume incompressible liquid and $A(h)>0$. A falling level gives a negative net volume rate. If there is no inflow, the positive outflow is $q=-dV/dt$. An instantaneous rate is not total volume divided by elapsed time.
In a fixed tank with positive horizontal area at the current interior level, $dh/dt<0$. The signed net volume rate $dV/dt$ es
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
The chain rule gives $dV/dt=A(h)\,dh/dt$. A positive area times a negative depth rate is negative; this is a net rate, not necessarily the outlet flow.
Work the original cylinder example
- For an upright cylinder with fixed radius $r$, $V(h)=\pi r^2h$ and $A(h)=\pi r^2$. Differentiate before inserting the depth; the factor multiplying $dh/dt$ is an area, not the entire cylinder's volume.
- In the original exercise, $r=2\,\mathrm m$ and $dh/dt=3\,\dfrac{\mathrm m}{\mathrm{min}}$. Thus $dV/dt=12\pi\,\dfrac{\mathrm m^3}{\mathrm{min}}$. The sign is positive because the tank fills. Area times depth rate has the required volume-rate units.
An upright cylinder of fixed radius $2\,\mathrm m$ fills with depth rate $3\,\dfrac{\mathrm m}{\mathrm{min}}$. Its volume rate is $k\pi$ cubic metres per minute. Find k.
Dificultad 2/5 · 140 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
The current area is $4\pi$ square metres. Thus $dV/dt=4\pi(3)=12\pi$ cubic metres per minute, so $k=12$.
Derive the sphere's surface radius
- Fix the sphere radius $R>0$ and measure depth from its lowest point, so $0\le h\le2R$. In a vertical section, the centre is $R$ above the bottom. If the water-surface radius is $a$, Pythagoras gives $a^2+(h-R)^2=R^2$.
- Therefore $a^2=2Rh-h^2=h(2R-h)$ and $A(h)=\pi h(2R-h)$. This is the area of the horizontal water disc; $4\pi R^2$ is the sphere's curved surface area and is the wrong factor here.
A sphere has fixed radius $3\,\mathrm m$ and water depth $1\,\mathrm m$ from its bottom. Give the square of the water-disc radius, in square metres.
Dificultad 2/5 · 140 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
$a^2=R^2-(h-R)^2=9-4=5$. The disc area is $5\pi$, while the disc radius is $\sqrt5$.
Build the spherical-cap volume from discs
- A thin layer at height $s$ has area $\pi(2Rs-s^2)$. Integrate from the bottom: $V(h)=\int_0^h A(s)\,ds$, hence $V(h)=\pi(Rh^2-h^3/3)$. Differentiation checks $V'(h)=A(h)$ and the lower endpoint gives $V(0)=0$.
- At $h=2R$, this becomes the full sphere volume $4\pi R^3/3$. At $h=R$, it is $2\pi R^3/3$, half the sphere. These checks also confirm that h is depth from the bottom, not distance from the centre.
At depth $h=R$ in a sphere, write the water volume as $k\pi R^3$. Give k.
Dificultad 2/5 · 140 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
$V(R)=\pi(R^3-R^3/3)=2\pi R^3/3$, so $k=2/3$. This is half of the full sphere volume.
Work the original spherical-tank rate
- Use metres and minutes, with $R=3$, $h=1$ and $dh/dt=-1/4$. The current area is $A=\pi(6-1)=5\pi$ square metres, so the signed volume rate is $dV/dt=-5\pi/4$ cubic metres per minute.
- With no inflow, the positive outflow is $5\pi/4$ cubic metres per minute. The original figure shows this level on the left and a separate quotient corner example on the right; the two panels illustrate different ideas.
Check a second level and the widest section
- For the original exercise with $R=5$, $h=2$ and $dh/dt=-1/2$, the area is $\pi(20-4)=16\pi$. The signed volume rate is $-8\pi$ cubic metres per minute; without inflow, the outflow is $8\pi$ cubic metres per minute.
- Since $A(h)=\pi[R^2-(h-R)^2]$, the largest area is $\pi R^2$ at $h=R$. Mirror depths h and $2R-h$ have equal areas. For $R=3$, depths $1$ and $5$ both give $5\pi$, while the equator gives $9\pi$.
A fixed sphere of radius $5\,\mathrm m$ contains water of depth $2\,\mathrm m$ measured from the bottom. There is no inflow, and depth falls at $0.5\,\dfrac{\mathrm m}{\mathrm{min}}$. The outflow is $k\pi$ cubic metres per minute. Find k.
Dificultad 2/5 · 140 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Área $A=\pi(2Rh-h^2)=16\pi$. The signed volume rate is $16\pi(-0.5)=-8\pi$; no inflow means positive outflow $8\pi$, so $k=8$.
Constant volume outflow does not mean constant depth speed
- With no inflow and constant outflow $q>0$, use $dh/dt=-q/A(h)$ for $0<h<2R$. A smaller area gives a larger fall speed. For $R=3$, $q=5\pi/4$, the fall speed is $1/4$ at depth $1$ but $5/36$ at depth $3$, in metres per minute.
- The sphere's area is zero at depths $0$ and $2R$, so this division is only valid at interior levels. The ideal constant-q model gives an unbounded depth speed as an endpoint is approached; it does not supply a finite endpoint derivative.
For a fixed spherical tank with no inlet and constant positive volume outflow, the water depth falls at a constant speed throughout the interior.
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
False. The depth rate is $-q/A(h)$, and the area changes with depth. Its fall speed is smallest at the equator and grows toward either endpoint in this ideal model.
For a radius-4 m sphere at water depth 2 m, the level falls at one quarter of a metre per minute and there is no inlet. Find the signed volume rate and positive outflow. If that outflow stays constant, find the signed depth rate at the equator.
Compare the geometry, signs, hypotheses and one-sided calculations with the model and checklist.
Net change is different from the outlet's flow
- If water also enters, write $dV/dt=q_{\rm in}-q_{\rm out}$, with both flow magnitudes nonnegative. A falling level measures their difference. It does not determine the outlet's flow unless the inlet flow is known.
- For $R=3$, $h=1$, inlet $2\pi$ and outlet $3\pi$ cubic metres per minute, the net rate is $-\pi$. Dividing by area $5\pi$ gives $dh/dt=-1/5$ metre per minute. The outlet still carries $3\pi$, rather than the net loss magnitude $\pi$.
At depth 1 m in a radius-3 m sphere, inlet and outlet rates are $2\pi$ y $3\pi$ cubic metres per minute. Give the signed depth rate in metres per minute.
Dificultad 2/5 · 140 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
The net volume rate is $2\pi-3\pi=-\pi$. Divide by current area $5\pi$ to obtain $dh/dt=-1/5=-0.2$.
A cone needs similar triangles first
- For a fixed upright cone with its vertex down, let its height be $H$ and top radius $r_0$. Similar triangles give $r/h=r_0/H$. Hence $V(h)=\pi(r_0/H)^2h^3/3$ and $A(h)=\pi(r_0/H)^2h^2$ for $0<h<H$.
- With $H=6$, $r_0=3$, $h=2$ in metres, the current area is $\pi$ square metres. An outflow $\pi/2$ cubic metres per minute and no inlet gives $dh/dt=-1/2$ metre per minute. The water-surface radius changes; it must not be treated as fixed.
¿Cómo cambia el área horizontal actual con la profundidad?
Use tanques verticales fijos, profundidad desde el fondo y el interior de cada tanque; los conos y hemisferios tienen la orientación especificada.
A fixed vertex-down cone has height 6 m and top radius 3 m. At water depth 2 m, outflow is $\pi/2$ cubic metres per minute and there is no inlet. Give the signed depth rate in metres per minute.
Dificultad 2/5 · 140 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Similar triangles give $r=h/2=1$, so $A=\pi$. Thus $dh/dt=-(\pi/2)/\pi=-1/2$.
A fixed vertex-down cone has height 8 m and top radius 2 m. At water depth 4 m, it drains with no inlet at $2\pi$ cubic metres per minute. Derive the depth rate using similar triangles before substituting the depth.
Compare the geometry, signs, hypotheses and one-sided calculations with the model and checklist.
Set up a quotient limit from derivatives
- Let f and g be defined near $0$, differentiable at $0$, and satisfy $f(0)=g(0)=0$. Suppose $g'(0)\ne0$. Differentiability gives $f(x)/x\to f'(0)$ and $g(x)/x\to g'(0)$ as $x\to0$.
- For $x\ne0$ where the quotient is defined, write $f(x)/g(x)=[f(x)/x]/[g(x)/x]$. This uses derivative definitions at the point. Continuous derivatives on a whole neighbourhood are sufficient but are not needed for this argument.
A nonzero derivative protects the denominator
- Put $c=g'(0)\ne0$. For sufficiently small nonzero x, convergence gives $|g(x)/x-c|<|c|/2$. Hence $|g(x)/x|>|c|/2>0$, so $g(x)\ne0$ throughout a punctured neighbourhood of zero.
- The ordinary quotient limit law now applies: the finite limit of $f(x)/g(x)$ is $L=f'(0)/g'(0)$. The nonzero derivative does two jobs: it gives a nonzero limiting denominator after division by x, and ensures the original quotient is defined nearby.
Work the original quotient limits
- In radians, take $f(x)=\sin(2x)$ and $g(x)=3x$. Both vanish at zero, with derivatives $2$ and $3$, so the quotient tends to $2/3$. The factor multiplying x inside the sine matters.
- In the original exercise, $f(x)=e^x-1$ and $g(x)=\sin(5x)$. Their derivatives at zero are $1$ and $5$, so the limit is $1/5=0.2$. The derivative-definition argument establishes the result directly.
Evaluate $\lim_{x\to0} \dfrac{e^x - 1}{\sin 5x}$.
Dificultad 2/5 · 140 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
Both functions vanish at zero and are differentiable there. Their derivatives are $1$ y $5$, respectively. The nonzero denominator derivative permits the local quotient limit $1/5=0.2$.
Fill only the value that the limit permits
- If the quotient has finite limit L, keep its values for $x\ne0$ and set its value at zero to L. The resulting extension is continuous at zero. A different value there cannot be continuous, because changing a single value does not change the limit.
- For $(x+x^2)/x$, the nearby values are $1+x$ and the only continuous fill is $1$. Assigning the value $2$ at zero leaves a discontinuity. Replacing it by $1$ fixes continuity, but a separate derivative check is still required.
A favor $x\ne0$, let $H(x)=(x+x^2)/x$. Which value must H(0) have for continuity at zero?
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
The nearby expression is $1+x$, so its limit is 1. Altering the isolated value cannot change that limit.
Continuous first derivatives can leave a quotient corner
- Let $f(x)=x|x|$ and $g(x)=x$. Here f is continuously differentiable: $f'(x)=2|x|$, including $f'(0)=0$. Also $g'(0)=1$. Thus these functions meet even the stronger continuous-derivative hypotheses.
- For $x\ne0$, the quotient is $|x|$, with continuous fill $0$. Its difference quotient at zero is $|x|/x$, equal to $-1$ from the left and $1$ from the right. The extension is continuous but not differentiable.
If $f/g$ has a finite limit at 0, its continuous extension is differentiable at 0.
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
False. With $f=x|x|$ y $g=x$, the quotient is $|x|$ away from zero. Its continuous fill is 0, but the one-sided derivatives there are $-1$ y $1$.
A derivative needs more than the filled value
- For $(x+x^2)/x$, the continuous extension is $1+x$, which has derivative $1$ at zero. In general, once the fill is L, test the limit of $(f(x)/g(x)-L)/x$ separately; the value L alone does not determine that limit.
- If f and g are $C^2$ near zero, with zero values there, write $a=f'(0)$, $c=g'(0)\ne0$, $p=f''(0)$ and $q=g''(0)$. Second-order Taylor expansions give extension derivative $(pc-aq)/(2c^2)$. These extra hypotheses exclude the preceding corner example.
A favor $x\ne0$, let $H(x)=(e^x-1)/x$. Find the continuous fill H(0) and its derivative at zero. Explain why the fill alone does not establish the derivative.
Compare the geometry, signs, hypotheses and one-sided calculations with the model and checklist.
A zero denominator derivative leaves the test undecided
- If $g'(0)=0$, the earlier nonzero-derivative test does not apply. Yet $f=x^3$, $g=x^2$ give quotient x away from zero and a smooth fill at zero. A failed sufficient condition is not a proof of failure.
- Other choices do fail: $f=x$, $g=x^2$ give $1/x$, with no finite two-sided limit; $f=x|x|$, $g=x^2$ give $|x|/x$, with opposite one-sided limits. Inspect the actual leading terms and the denominator's domain.
¿Qué puede ser el cociente en cero?
Todo cociente comienza en un número real no nulo x cercano a cero. Determine si existe una extensión continua, y luego si posee derivada.
A quotient with $f(0)=g(0)=g\prime(0)=0$ can still have a differentiable extension at zero.
Dificultad 1/5 · 100 monedas + un pequeño bono en el primer intento de hoy
True. With $f(x)=x^3$ y $g(x)=x^2$, the quotient equals x for $x\ne0$. Filling with 0 gives a smooth function, although the earlier nonzero-derivative test does not apply.
At zero compare the extensions of (i) $x|x|/x$; (ii) $x^3/x^2$; and (iii) $x|x|/x^2$, each initially defined for nonzero x. State the limit and differentiability where a continuous fill exists.
Compare the geometry, signs, hypotheses and one-sided calculations with the model and checklist.
Recap
- Relate volume to depth before differentiating. Multiply by the current horizontal area for a signed net volume rate; distinguish inlet, outlet and net change, and divide only where that area is positive.
- For the local quotient test, require differentiability, zero numerator and denominator values, and nonzero denominator derivative. A finite fill gives continuity at the point; differentiability requires a further check.
- related rates: Rates of changing quantities linked by an equation, usually connected by the chain rule.
- cross-section: The shape formed by intersecting a solid with a plane.
- removable: Describing a singularity that a finite value can fill to make a function continuous at that point.