Doppler effect: separate source motion from wave speed
引入| English | 释义 | 拼音 |
|---|---|---|
| Doppler shift/ˈdɒplə ʃɪft/ | 多普勒频移 | duō pǔ lēi pín yí |
| wavefront/ˈweɪvfrʌnt/ | 波面 | bō miàn |
What would explain this observation?
- An approaching sound source is heard at a higher pitch even when the source produces a constant frequency.
Build the model
- Doppler shift 多普勒频移 arises from relative source-observer motion.
- A moving source compresses wavefront 波面 spacing ahead and increases it behind.
- For sound in a stationary medium, the wave speed relative to that medium need not change.
- Doppler shift: Change of observed frequency due to relative motion.
- wavefront: A surface joining points with the same wave phase.
Why is pitch higher in front of an approaching sound source?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
An approaching source emits each wavefront closer to the previous one in the direction of travel, so the spacing - the wavelength - shrinks in front, and at fixed wave speed a shorter wavelength means a higher pitch.
Match each technical term to its precise meaning.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
Use the definitions to distinguish related quantities and processes.
Choose evidence that can test it
- For a source approaching a stationary observer along the line of sight, f observed = f source × v/(v−v source).
- Recession uses v+v source in the denominator.
- These are sound-wave models; light requires its appropriate relation.
In the lab: Use a simulation or recorded data with stated source and observer directions. Draw wavefronts before choosing signs. Avoid demonstrations near moving traffic or unsafe high-volume sources.
Which two habits make the investigation or model in this case more defensible?
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
Stating the conditions and assumptions lets others repeat the work exactly, and recording the supporting evidence lets them check the conclusion. Hiding disagreeing results removes the evidence that could challenge a wrong conclusion, and one measurement can never establish a wider claim.
Work from known quantities
- Known: source frequency 500 Hz, sound speed 340 m/s, source approaches at 20 m/s.
- Observed frequency = 500 × 340/(340−20) = 531.25 Hz.
- The increase is 31.25 Hz; it is not the source frequency changing.
Your turn: A 600 Hz source approaches a stationary observer at 20 m/s. Use v = 340 m/s. Find observed frequency. Give the frequency to three significant figures.
Move the source, keep the sound speed fixed
Source motion changes the wavelength and observed frequency while sound speed stays fixed.
A 600 Hz source approaches a stationary observer at 20 m/s. Use v = 340 m/s. Find observed frequency. Give the frequency to three significant figures.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
The result is 638 Hz. Known: source 600 Hz approaching a stationary observer at 20 m/s; v = 340 m/s. Use observed frequency = source frequency x v/(v - source speed). f = 600 x 340/(340 - 20) = 637.5 Hz. The source frequency itself never changed. The unrounded 637.5 Hz rounds to 638 Hz to three significant figures.
Check the conclusion and its limits
- A stationary source and moving observer require the observer-motion relation.
- Do not use the same denominator formula for every arrangement or import a sound formula into relativity.
Not true: The Doppler effect always means the wave speed in the medium changed. The wave speed in the medium is fixed by the medium. The Doppler shift comes from relative motion changing the spacing of wavefronts (moving source) or the rate they meet the observer (moving observer) - not from a change in wave speed.
- Doppler shift arises from relative source-observer motion.
- For a source approaching a stationary observer along the line of sight, f observed = f source × v/(v−v source).
- Watch for: A stationary source and moving observer require the observer-motion relation.
The Doppler effect always means the wave speed in the medium changed.
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
The wave speed in the medium is fixed by the medium. The Doppler shift comes from relative motion changing the spacing of wavefronts (moving source) or the rate they meet the observer (moving observer) - not from a change in wave speed.
Change of observed frequency due to relative motion: write the technical term.
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
Doppler shift means Change of observed frequency due to relative motion.
Write from the data: find the observed frequency
- A 450 Hz source approaches a stationary observer at 40 m/s. The wave speed is 340 m/s.
- Find the observed frequency. The wave speed in the medium does not change.
A 450 Hz source approaches a stationary observer at 40 metres per second, and the wave speed is 340 metres per second. What frequency is observed, and why has the wave speed in the medium not changed?
For a source approaching a stationary observer, f′ = fv/(v − uₛ). The denominator is 340 − 40 = 300 m/s, so f′ = 450 × 340/300 = 510 Hz. Source motion shortens wavefront spacing; the unchanged medium still carries sound at 340 m/s.
In a still-air model, a 450 Hz source moves directly toward a stationary observer at 40 m/s. Sound travels at 340 m/s relative to the air. What frequency does the observer hear?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
340 minus 40 is 300, and 450 times 340 divided by 300 is 510 Hz. Other options — 637.5 Hz (the lesson example's result for a 600 Hz source at 20 metres per second); 450 Hz (the source frequency).
Set the medium frame before choosing a Doppler equation
- A sound wave propagates through a medium, so specify both source and observer motion relative to that medium. The examples here are invented, use stationary uniform air with sound speed v = 340 m/s, and treat source and observer on one line. Source motion changes the emitted front spacing in the air; observer motion changes the front encounter rate. These mechanisms give different exact classical formulas.
- A source approaching a stationary observer at 30 m/s is therefore not equivalent to an observer approaching a stationary source at 30 m/s, even though their separation decreases at the same rate. At speeds much smaller than sound speed their first-order shifts are similar, but the full ratios differ. Do not replace sound speed with a relative closing speed or apply these equations to light.
Why do a source and an observer each approaching at 20 m/s in separate experiments not give the same exact classical shift?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
For a 600 Hz source, the examples give 637.5 Hz for source motion and about 635.294 Hz for observer motion. They agree only to first order at small motion speed.
Derive the source-motion denominator from one emission period
- Let the emitted period be T = 1/f. In one period the previous front travels vT while a source approaching the observer advances uₛT. The front spacing ahead is λahead = (v − uₛ)T = (v − uₛ)/f. A stationary observer receives these fronts at f′ = v/λahead, giving $f'=f\dfrac{v}{v-u_s}$. The minus sign follows from the shorter spacing, rather than from memorising a vague approach rule.
- Behind a source moving away, successive emission points increase the spacing: λbehind = (v + uₛ)/f, so $f'=f\dfrac{v}{v+u_s}$. For subsonic motion both denominators are positive. This simple front-arrival picture does not extend unchanged through uₛ = v into a supersonic shock-wave problem. The smaller approaching denominator also makes the upward shift larger than the downward shift at the same source speed.

Calculate source approach and recession separately
- For an invented 700 Hz siren moving at 30 m/s along the line of sight, approach gives f′ = 700 × 340/(340 − 30) = 767.742 Hz, about 768 Hz. Recession gives 700 × 340/(340 + 30) = 643.243 Hz, about 643 Hz. Their mean is not exactly 700 Hz; the shifts are about +67.7 and −56.8 Hz because source speed enters the denominator.
- The wavelengths in the stationary air are 310/700 ≈ .443 m ahead and 370/700 ≈ .529 m behind. Multiplying each by its corresponding received frequency gives the same sound speed 340 m/s. This is a useful independent check: a Doppler shift does not imply the wave travels through the air at 370 m/s in front and 310 m/s behind. The source itself continues to emit 700 oscillations each second in this classical model.
An invented 700 Hz source moves directly towards an observer stationary in uniform air at 30 m/s. With sound speed 340 m/s, find received frequency.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
The source shortens front spacing, so f′ = fv/(v − uₛ) = 700 × 340/310 ≈ 767.742 Hz. About 768 Hz is higher than the emitted frequency.
For the same invented 700 Hz source and sound speed 340 m/s, the source moves directly away at 30 m/s from a stationary observer. Find received frequency.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
Recession enlarges spacing: f′ = 700 × 340/370 ≈ 643.243 Hz. The downward shift is not equal to the upward shift for source approach at equal speed.
Infer source speed from an observed frequency
- An invented 400 Hz train horn is received at 420 Hz by a platform observer stationary in the air, so the source approaches. Start with 420 = 400 × 340/(340 − uₛ). Rearrangement gives 340 − uₛ = 400 × 340/420 = 323.8095 m/s, and uₛ = 16.1905 m/s, about 16 m/s at two significant figures. State source speed separately from the denominator, which is a front-spacing quantity per emitted period.
- Substitute the inferred speed back into the original ratio and check that the observed frequency is greater than emitted. A lower received frequency would instead require the receding denominator. If both on-axis approach and recession frequencies are measured at the same source speed, their asymmetry can test the source-motion model; averaging them is not a general method of recovering the emitted frequency.
An invented 400 Hz source approaches a stationary observer in air at 340 m/s sound speed. Received frequency is 420 Hz. Find source speed.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
420 = 400 × 340/(340 − uₛ). Multiply by the denominator and divide by 420: 340 − uₛ = 400 × 340/420 = 323.8095 m/s. Hence uₛ = 340 − 323.8095 = 16.1905 m/s. Substitution gives 400 × 340/(340 − 16.1905) ≈ 420 Hz.
Derive observer motion from the rate of crossing fixed wavefronts
- For a stationary 500 Hz source the wavefront spacing in air is λ = v/f = .680 m, regardless of how an observer moves. An observer approaching at speed uₒ crosses fronts at relative encounter speed v + uₒ, so $f'=f\dfrac{v+u_o}{v}$. Moving away replaces plus by minus because the encounter rate is smaller. Here observer speed enters the numerator, while the medium wavelength stays unchanged.
- For uₒ = 20 m/s, approach gives 500 × 360/340 = 529.412 Hz and recession gives 500 × 320/340 = 470.588 Hz. The shifts are equal in magnitude, ±29.412 Hz, for these two equal-speed observer cases. The observer's wavefront encounter speed is not the sound speed relative to the air. Keep that distinction explicit when using f′ = encounter speed divided by the air wavelength.

An observer approaches an invented stationary 500 Hz source at 20 m/s through stationary air with sound speed 340 m/s. Find received frequency.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
Source spacing stays .680 m. Encounter speed is 360 m/s, so f′ = 500 × 360/340 ≈ 529.412 Hz. Observer speed belongs in the numerator.
Solve an observer problem without changing the wavelength
- An invented stationary 500 Hz source is heard at 450 Hz by an observer moving on the source–observer line. The decrease means recession. From 450 = 500(340 − uₒ)/340, the encounter speed is 306 m/s and observer speed is 340 − 306 = 34 m/s away. Using the moving-source denominator would give a different value and answer a different physical problem.
- Compare two approach cases with f = 600 Hz and motion speed 20 m/s. Moving source: 600 × 340/320 = 637.5 Hz. Moving observer: 600 × 360/340 ≈ 635.294 Hz. The similar results can conceal a formula error, so inspect the diagram and which body moves rather than using closeness to an expected rounded answer as the only check.
An invented stationary 500 Hz source is heard at 450 Hz by an observer moving along the source line in air with sound speed 340 m/s. Find the magnitude of observer speed.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
The frequency is lower, so the observer moves away. From 450 = 500(340 − uₒ)/340, the encounter speed is 340 − uₒ = 450 × 340/500 = 306 m/s. Hence uₒ = 340 − 306 = 34 m/s away. Front spacing remains λ = 340/500 = 0.680 m in the air.
Project source motion along the emitted wave direction
- The one-dimensional source equations require motion directly towards or away from the stationary observer. In a passing-source model at finite sideways distance, use the source velocity component along the propagation direction from its emission position. This component varies even when road speed stays constant, producing the smooth drop in the illustrated frequency. The sound arrives later, so emission position and the source position at reception are different quantities.
- The graph uses a 700 Hz siren at 30 m/s on a straight road, a listener 8 m to the side and sound speed 340 m/s. Its horizontal axis labels source position at emission, not an observed clock time. Far before and after the closest emission point it tends towards the on-axis results; at the closest emission point the radial source component is zero and the associated received frequency is 700 Hz. This geometrical statement is about the classical sound model.

The passing-siren graph is indexed by source position when sound is emitted. At zero position the emitted wave travels perpendicular to the road towards the listener. What must be remembered?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
Finite propagation time separates emission geometry from reception timing. The zero-radial-component signal has emitted frequency in this classical stationary-observer model, rather than zero frequency.
Distinguish equation scope from a physical prohibition
- Problems here treat one moving body at a time to make the mechanisms explicit. Both source and observer can physically move through the medium; a complete model would combine source front spacing and observer encounter rate with consistent directions. Do not claim that such motion is impossible or that relative speed alone selects a general sound equation.
- The mechanical-wave formulas assume the specified wave speed, medium frame and suitable motion geometry. A moving medium requires its own velocity account. Light has no equivalent preferred air frame; its Doppler relation must be consistent with relativity. Likewise, reflected radar or ultrasound involves a receiver/reflector interaction as well as the outgoing wave, so a one-way example cannot be copied without examining the second leg and measurement direction.
Which statement correctly describes the one-moving-body equations taught here?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
A teaching scope is not a physical ban. Sound depends on motion relative to its medium; light requires its appropriate relativistic account, and supersonic sources need a different wavefront treatment.
Design a safe test that separates source and observer motion
- Use a simulation or a controlled recording with stated motion, source frequency and sound speed, rather than students approaching traffic or using unsafe sound levels. Compare an approaching and receding source at equal speed, then repeat with the source stationary and the detector moving. Record which frequency estimate came from which configuration and whether the detector samples the same line-of-sight geometry.
- A real siren may itself alternate notes, reflections may mix signals and air temperature changes sound speed. Use a steady source, identify a reproducible spectral peak, and compare uncertainty with the difference predicted by the two models. The shift alone is not proof that one body rather than the other moved: the experimental arrangement supplies that information.
Which comparison best tests source versus observer Doppler models?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
The arrangement identifies which body moves. Real alternating tones, reflections, geometry and sound-speed uncertainty can obscure the small difference between model predictions.
Test the complete mechanical-wave Doppler explanation
- Draw the medium frame, source and observer, assign motion directions and decide whether pitch should rise or fall. For a moving source derive λ = (v ∓ uₛ)/f, then obtain f′ from the stationary encounter speed v. For a moving observer retain λ = v/f and change the encounter speed to v ± uₒ. Carry units through any rearrangement and check the zero-speed limit f′ = f.
- Verify source-shift asymmetry and observer-shift symmetry for equal approach/recession speeds in their stated one-body models. Explain why v stays fixed while emitted or received frequency plays a different role. State the limitations for oblique motion, moving media, supersonic sources, reflected waves and light, rather than treating a memorised sign rule as a complete physical account.
Derive and compare the moving-source and moving-observer mechanical Doppler equations and state their conditions.
A correct formula is supported by the wavefront mechanism and its physical assumptions.