From stimulus to philosophical inquiry
引入| English | 释义 | 拼音 |
|---|---|---|
| stimulus/ˈstɪmjʊləs/ | 刺激材料 | cì jī cái liào |
| empirical question | 经验性问题 | jīng yàn xìng wèn tí |
| conceptual question | 概念性问题 | gài niàn xìng wèn tí |
| personhood/ˈpɜːsənhʊd/ | 人格 | rén gé |
| Chinese room | 中文屋 | zhōng wén wū |
A robot citizen, October 2017
- In October 2017 Saudi Arabia announced citizenship for Sophia, a humanoid robot that could hold simple conversations. Many people laughed; others asked whether a machine could ever deserve rights.
- IB Philosophy Paper 1 gives you a stimulus 刺激材料 like this — a picture, a news story, a short text — and asks you to turn it into a philosophical question about being human.
Finding the philosophical question
- An empirical question 经验性问题 is answered by observation: "Can Sophia pass a test of conversation?" A conceptual question 概念性问题 asks what a concept means or requires: "Is consciousness necessary for being a person?"
- Philosophy works on the conceptual question. Choose one that is clear, open and can be argued both ways.
Classify each question.
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
Empirical questions are settled by observation; conceptual ones by analysing meaning.
Which is the best philosophical question for a stimulus showing a humanoid robot?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
It is conceptual, open and linked to the core theme.
Linking to the core theme
- The core theme, "Being human", covers mind and body, personhood, freedom and identity. Name the concept you will analyse — here, personhood 人格.
- Define it carefully. A common account: a person is a being with consciousness, reasoning, self-awareness and the ability to act on reasons.

Which features appear in common definitions of a person?
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
Definitions focus on mental capacities, not material.
Arguments on both sides
- Alan Turing (1950) proposed that if a machine's conversation cannot be told apart from a human's, we should say it thinks. On this view, behaviour is our only evidence for any mind.
- John Searle's Chinese room 中文屋 (1980) replies: a man following rules can give perfect Chinese answers without understanding a word. Producing the right outputs may not mean understanding.
What is the Chinese room meant to show?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
The man gives correct outputs without understanding Chinese.
Turing argued that we should judge whether a machine thinks by what it is made of.
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
Turing proposed judging by behaviour — whether its conversation can be told apart from a human's.
Worked example: planning a Paper 1 answer
Stimulus: a photograph of Sophia with a citizenship certificate. Plan an answer.
- Question and concept: "Must a being be conscious to be a person?" — personhood and consciousness.
- Argument: rights protect interests; only a conscious being can have interests (it can be harmed); so only conscious beings can be persons. Objection: we cannot directly know any other mind; we judge humans by behaviour, so a machine that behaves the same deserves the same judgement (Turing).
- Evaluation and conclusion: Searle shows behaviour can come apart from understanding, so behaviour is evidence, not proof. Conclude that consciousness is necessary, but admit that knowing whether it is present is hard.
Put the parts of a Paper 1 answer in order.
难度 3/5 · 今日首次完成可获 200 金币及少量额外奖励
Each part builds on the one before.
Evaluating and concluding
- Evaluate each argument: are the premises plausible, are there counterexamples, does it beg the question? Then reach your own conclusion and explain why the strongest objection does not defeat it.
- Refer to the stimulus throughout, but spend most of the answer on philosophy, not on describing the picture.
Describing the stimulus is not philosophy. "Sophia has a face like a woman and can talk" earns little. Use the stimulus to raise a conceptual question, then argue — with definitions, positions, objections and a judgement.
A detailed description of the stimulus earns most of the marks in Paper 1.
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
Marks come from philosophical analysis and evaluation.
In Paper 1, move from the stimulus to a conceptual question linked to "Being human", define the key concept, set out an argument and its strongest objection, evaluate both and reach a justified conclusion. Turing and Searle show how arguments about machine minds work.
Stimulus: a photograph of a person in a coma. Write a question, an argument and an objection.
Practise the structure on a new stimulus.