当同伴更改计划时的伦理抉择
引入| English | 释义 | 拼音 |
|---|---|---|
| permission scope/pəˈmɪʃn skəʊp/ | 授权范围 | shòu quán fàn wéi |
| participant choice/pɑːˈtɪsɪpənt tʃɔɪs/ | 参与者选择 | cān yù zhě xuǎn zé |
| trade-off/treɪd ɒf/ | 权衡 | quán héng |
| data minimization/ˈdeɪtə ˌmɪnɪmaɪˈzeɪʃn/ | 数据最小化 | shù jù zuì xiǎo huà |
| revised agreement/rɪˈvaɪzd əˈɡriːmənt/ | 修订后的约定 | xiū dìng hòu de yuē dìng |
| ethical judgement/ˈeθɪkl ˈdʒʌdʒmənt/ | 伦理判断 | lún lǐ pàn duàn |
The activity can continue without the film
- A fictional team prepares a craft workshop with a community centre. The centre initially agrees to a short demonstration film. Before the session, it asks the team not to record participants. One pupil says the film is needed for a strong portfolio.
- The workshop purpose is helping participants try the craft. The film is one proposed record, not the purpose itself. Reconsider the record with the partner and school before continuing; this case describes a classroom proposal, not an approved CAS experience.
在这种情况下,研讨会的目的是什么?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
拟拍摄的电影是证据,而非该活动的目的。
Check what was actually agreed
- Permission scope 授权范围 describes the action and use that were agreed. Permission to film a demonstration does not automatically cover filming participants or posting the film publicly. Check the approved plan instead of assuming that all uses are included.
- The centre's new request changes the planned recording. Tell the responsible adult and coordinator, pause that part of the plan, and agree what remains appropriate. Do not pressure the partner to accept recording for the pupil's convenience.

同意拍摄演示会自动允许对参与者进行公开拍摄。
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
核实具体行动、用途及已批准的方案。
Preserve a meaningful choice
- Participant choice 参与者选择 means people can express a preference about taking part. A workshop visitor should not have to appear in a pupil's record simply to access the activity. Follow the centre's and school's approved participation process.
- Ask the partner how people can join, pause or choose another approved task without being singled out. A polite invitation can still create pressure if refusing it has an unfair consequence. Consider the situation from the participant's position.
哪种安排最能保留参与者的选择权?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
参与不应以出现在学生记录中为前提条件。
Compare alternatives by their effects
- The team proposes two alternatives: photograph only its own prepared materials before the session, or write an account of the instruction changes afterwards. Discuss whether these can support the learning claim without recording participants.
- A trade-off 权衡 is a choice between effects that cannot all be maximized at once. A film may show a demonstration clearly, but that does not override the recording restriction. Compare relevance, access, privacy and partner agreement, then obtain the required school approval.
将规划问题与其对应的核查项匹配。
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
一个有用的替代方案必须尊重边界,同时服务于活动及证据目的。
Keep only evidence you need
- Data minimization 数据最小化 means choosing evidence that uses no more personal information than its purpose needs. Draft instructions, the pupil's materials and an approved supervisor account may support particular actions without naming visitors.
- A name-free image can still identify someone through a face, voice or setting. Check the proposed evidence with the responsible adult. The class must not collect real participant data to complete this fictional exercise.
哪些关于证据的陈述是合理的?
难度 2/5 · 今日首次完成可获 140 金币及少量额外奖励
选择相关证据并检查其余识别信息。
Act on a change instead of hiding it
- A revised agreement 修订后的约定 records what changed, who must approve it and what the team will now do. Give each pupil a clear task: update instructions, prepare materials or check the agreed recording boundary with the adult.
- If recording already occurred contrary to the new plan, stop using or sharing it and tell the responsible adult. Follow the school's approved handling process; do not invent a deletion policy, secretly keep a copy or claim the issue never happened.
录音计划发生变化。学生应该怎么做?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
明确说明变更并在行动前获得适当批准。
Reflect on the reason for your decision
- An ethical judgement 伦理判断 explains whose interests are affected and why one action is more appropriate. “We did not make the film” describes an action. Explain the partner's request, the pressure a participant might face, the alternative chosen and its limits.
- Credit teammates' separate roles. If the workshop has not taken place, write that the revised plan is still a proposal. A good explanation does not turn planned action into evidence that participants benefited.
修订后的提案是一种计划,并非证明该工作坊已对任何人产生实际帮助的证据。
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
正确。计划中的行动不能作为经验确实发生或产生影响的证据。
Review with the people involved
- After an actual approved session, the partner may provide appropriate feedback on whether the instructions helped. Report mixed results and agree a useful next step. Evidence about one session does not establish benefit for every future participant.
- The school decides how authentic experiences and evidence support its CAS programme requirements. Online practice can develop planning and reflection; it cannot approve an experience, certify a learning outcome or replace the coordinator's review.
哪项反思解释了伦理决策?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
解释受影响的利益、理由、替代方案及其局限性。
谁审查真实的CAS经历和项目要求?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
网站仅练习推理,不能证明项目已完成。
The pupil recognizes that the film was a proposed record, while the workshop's purpose was helping visitors try a craft. The centre's request changes what may be recorded. The team pauses filming, informs its responsible adult and proposes evidence from its own materials and an approved account of the instruction changes. It checks that participation does not depend on being recorded. The pupil can explain the affected interests and why the alternative fits the purpose, but cannot yet claim a successful workshop: the revised plan still needs approval and actual action.
A portfolio preference does not override a partner's changed request. Removing names does not automatically make a recording anonymous, and an agreed plan does not prove that an experience occurred.
Keep the purpose clear, respect the agreed boundary, preserve participant choice and explain the reasons for an approved change.
Write from a withdrawn film
- The centre agreed to a demonstration film, then asks the team not to film. The craft workshop can still happen.
- The film is a record, not the purpose. Change the agreement with the partner.
社区中心撤回了对演示影片的许可。手工艺工作坊仍可举行。其目的为何,且需修改哪项协议?
即使没有影片拍摄,活动仍可继续进行。在遭到拒绝后仍进行拍摄将违背知情同意原则。
哪一项决定符合中心的诉求?
难度 1/5 · 今日首次完成可获 100 金币及少量额外奖励
该工艺即为目的。首次签订拍摄协议并非在撤回许可之后才获得授权。