Build an argument that can answer a challenge
Introduzido| English | Significado |
|---|---|
| argument/ˈɑːɡjuːmənt/ | argumento |
| relevant expertise | specialist knowledge and training in the specific field that a question belongs to |
| counterclaim/ˈkaʊntəkleɪm/ | A strong reason against your claim. |
The bridge that wobbled, 2000
- London's Millennium Bridge opened on 10 June 2000. As thousands crossed, it began to sway sideways, and people fell into step with the sway, making it worse. It closed after two days.
- The designers were leading engineers, yet they had not predicted this. Other engineers then tested the bridge with crowds, found the cause — walkers' sideways footfall locking onto the bridge's motion — and fitted dampers. It reopened in 2002. When should we trust experts? A good argument 论证 needs reasons that can survive cases like this.
Why did London's Millennium Bridge close two days after opening in 2000?
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Engineers later found the cause and fitted dampers.
Give the claim a scope
- "Always trust experts" hides the conditions. A more precise claim: trust a conclusion when the expert has relevant expertise 相关专长, uses transparent methods, and the result has been checked by others.
- Expertise is specific: a bridge engineer is not an expert on medicine.

Which give a reason to trust an expert's conclusion?
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Titles alone do not settle it.
A counterclaim tests the argument
- A counterclaim 反论点 is a strong reason against your claim. The Millennium Bridge is one against "experts get it right".
- Answer it honestly: the error was found and fixed by the same expert community, through testing — which supports trusting expert methods over individual titles.
A counterclaim is a strong reason against your claim.
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Answering it strengthens the argument.
Worked example: two experts disagree
Two engineers disagree about whether a footbridge in a town is safe. Engineer A cites an inspection carried out last month; Engineer B cites a photograph from ten years ago showing no cracks.
- Relevance and currency: A's evidence is recent and directly about the bridge's condition now; B's is old.
- Method: check A's inspection method — were the hidden supports examined? Was it reviewed by another engineer?
- Conclusion: A's view deserves more trust, if the method holds up. Both have the same title; the evidence and its checking settle the question, not their status.
In the worked example, why does Engineer A's view deserve more trust?
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Relevance, currency and method decide.
Revising the conclusion
- After a counterclaim, revise the claim rather than repeat it: "Trust expert conclusions that rest on transparent, checked methods — and expect experts to correct errors through further testing."
- A revised claim is stronger because it explains the difficult case.
Which is a revised, stronger claim?
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
The revision explains the difficult case.
Checking the line of reasoning
- Check each step: does the evidence support the reason? Does the reason support the conclusion? Have you assumed something you have not shown?
- Use a real example for each step, and say what it can and cannot show.
Order the checks on a line of reasoning.
Dificuldade 3/5 · Moedas 200 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Check every link.
One expert error does not mean experts cannot be trusted. The Millennium Bridge was fixed by experts using evidence. Distrust a conclusion for a reason — irrelevant expertise, hidden methods, no checking — not because errors are possible.
One expert error means experts cannot be trusted.
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Distrust for a reason, not because errors are possible.
A strong argument gives the claim a precise scope, tests it with a real counterclaim and revises it. Trust in experts rests on relevant expertise, transparent methods and checking by others — not on titles. Check each step of the reasoning with real examples.
Write a claim about trusting doctors, a real counterclaim, and a revised claim.
Claim, counter, revision.