Philosophy and contemporary issues
Introduzido| English | Significado |
|---|---|
| hidden premise | An assumption an argument needs but does not state. |
| accountability/əˌkaʊntəˈbɪlɪti/ | prestação de contas |
| conceptual analysis/kənˈseptʃuːəl əˈnæləsɪs/ | Clarifying a concept by examining its meaning, assumptions and use in arguments. |
| reflective equilibrium | A method of adjusting general principles and judgements about cases until they fit together. |
A score that decided sentences, 2016
- In 2016 the news organisation ProPublica examined COMPAS, software used by US courts to predict which defendants would reoffend. It found that Black defendants who did not reoffend were almost twice as likely as white ones to be wrongly labelled high-risk.
- The company replied that its scores were equally accurate for both groups. Both sides used numbers; they disagreed about what "fair" means. That is a philosophical question.
What HL Paper 3 asks
- HL Paper 3 gives an unseen text about philosophy or a contemporary issue and asks: what is philosophy, and how should it be done? You compare the text's view with your own experience of doing philosophy.
- Good answers name the philosophical method the text uses, evaluate it and connect it to the issue.
Hidden premises
- A hidden premise 隐含前提 is an assumption an argument needs but does not state. Finding it is often the most powerful move in philosophy.
- "The algorithm is more accurate, so it should decide every case" assumes that accuracy outweighs every other value — fairness, accountability, the right to be heard.

"Exams measure ability, so universities should admit students by exam scores alone." What is the hidden premise?
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
The conclusion needs the unstated claim that exam ability is the only relevant factor.
"Self-driving cars cause fewer crashes, so human driving should be banned." Which hidden premise does it need?
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
A ban follows only if safety overrides all other values.
Worked example: unpacking "fairness"
COMPAS was equally accurate for both groups, yet one group suffered more false "high-risk" labels. Which conception of fairness is each side using?
- Company: fairness as calibration — a score of 7 means the same chance of reoffending for everyone.
- ProPublica: fairness as equal error rates — innocent people in each group should face the same chance of being wrongly labelled.
- Philosophical point: when groups have different base rates, mathematicians have shown both cannot hold at once. Choosing between them is a value judgement, not a technical fix — and it should be argued openly.
Match each side to its idea of fairness.
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Calibration and equal error rates are different conceptions of fairness.
With different base rates between groups, an algorithm can always satisfy both conceptions of fairness at once.
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Researchers proved that, in general, both cannot hold together, so a value choice is needed.
Methods of philosophy
- Conceptual analysis 概念分析 clarifies terms like "fair" or "person". Thought experiments test them. Reflective equilibrium 反思平衡 (John Rawls, 1971) adjusts principles and judgements about cases until they fit together.
- Philosophy also questions its own methods: are intuitions reliable evidence? Can philosophy make progress the way science does?
Match each method to its description.
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
These are core tools of philosophical method.
Philosophy in public life
- Philosophers sit on medical ethics boards, write AI guidelines and advise on climate policy. Their job is to expose assumptions, clarify choices and test arguments, not to supply data.
- In a Paper 3 answer, show this role with a concrete issue and your own reflection on doing philosophy.
What can philosophers contribute to debates on AI in courts?
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Data collection is empirical work; philosophy examines concepts, values and arguments.
"Numbers settle the question" is wrong. Data can show how often an algorithm errs, but not which errors matter more or who should decide. Every policy built on data carries value assumptions; philosophy's task is to state and test them.
Accurate data are enough to decide whether an algorithm is fair.
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Data describe outcomes; deciding which outcomes count as fair is a value judgement.
HL Paper 3 asks what philosophy is and how it works. Expose hidden premises, clarify contested concepts such as fairness, and use methods such as conceptual analysis, thought experiments and reflective equilibrium. Data inform public issues, but the value choices behind them need philosophical argument.
Using an example, explain how philosophy differs from science in what it contributes to a public issue.
A Paper 3-style reflection on what philosophy is for.