Taxas relacionadas e limites quocientes removíveis
Introduzido| English | Significado |
|---|---|
| related rates/rɪˈleɪtɪd reɪts/ | taxas relacionadas |
| removable/rɪˈmuːvəbl/ | removível |
| cross-section/krɒs ˈsekʃn/ | seção transversal |
The same fall can mean different outflows
- A spherical tank's level falls by a quarter of a metre per minute. A depth sensor alone cannot give the volume leaving: the area of the water surface matters at that instant.
- Related rates 相关变化率 connect changing quantities through a geometric equation. Later, removable 可去的 quotient limits show another distinction: filling a hole can restore continuity without giving a derivative.
State the physical model before differentiating
- Use a fixed tank with a horizontal liquid surface. Let $h(t)$ be depth above the bottom, $V(h)$ the volume below that level and $A(h)$ its horizontal cross-section 横截面 area. At an interior level, the chain rule gives $dV/dt=A(h)\,dh/dt$.
- Assume incompressible liquid and $A(h)>0$. A falling level gives a negative net volume rate. If there is no inflow, the positive outflow is $q=-dV/dt$. An instantaneous rate is not total volume divided by elapsed time.
In a fixed tank with positive horizontal area at the current interior level, $dh/dt<0$. The signed net volume rate $dV/dt$ é
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
The chain rule gives $dV/dt=A(h)\,dh/dt$. A positive area times a negative depth rate is negative; this is a net rate, not necessarily the outlet flow.
Work the original cylinder example
- For an upright cylinder with fixed radius $r$, $V(h)=\pi r^2h$ and $A(h)=\pi r^2$. Differentiate before inserting the depth; the factor multiplying $dh/dt$ is an area, not the entire cylinder's volume.
- In the original exercise, $r=2\,\mathrm m$ and $dh/dt=3\,\dfrac{\mathrm m}{\mathrm{min}}$. Thus $dV/dt=12\pi\,\dfrac{\mathrm m^3}{\mathrm{min}}$. The sign is positive because the tank fills. Area times depth rate has the required volume-rate units.
An upright cylinder of fixed radius $2\,\mathrm m$ fills with depth rate $3\,\dfrac{\mathrm m}{\mathrm{min}}$. Its volume rate is $k\pi$ cubic metres per minute. Find k.
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
The current area is $4\pi$ square metres. Thus $dV/dt=4\pi(3)=12\pi$ cubic metres per minute, so $k=12$.
Derive the sphere's surface radius
- Fix the sphere radius $R>0$ and measure depth from its lowest point, so $0\le h\le2R$. In a vertical section, the centre is $R$ above the bottom. If the water-surface radius is $a$, Pythagoras gives $a^2+(h-R)^2=R^2$.
- Therefore $a^2=2Rh-h^2=h(2R-h)$ and $A(h)=\pi h(2R-h)$. This is the area of the horizontal water disc; $4\pi R^2$ is the sphere's curved surface area and is the wrong factor here.
A sphere has fixed radius $3\,\mathrm m$ and water depth $1\,\mathrm m$ from its bottom. Give the square of the water-disc radius, in square metres.
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
$a^2=R^2-(h-R)^2=9-4=5$. The disc area is $5\pi$, while the disc radius is $\sqrt5$.
Build the spherical-cap volume from discs
- A thin layer at height $s$ has area $\pi(2Rs-s^2)$. Integrate from the bottom: $V(h)=\int_0^h A(s)\,ds$, hence $V(h)=\pi(Rh^2-h^3/3)$. Differentiation checks $V'(h)=A(h)$ and the lower endpoint gives $V(0)=0$.
- At $h=2R$, this becomes the full sphere volume $4\pi R^3/3$. At $h=R$, it is $2\pi R^3/3$, half the sphere. These checks also confirm that h is depth from the bottom, not distance from the centre.
At depth $h=R$ in a sphere, write the water volume as $k\pi R^3$. Give k.
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
$V(R)=\pi(R^3-R^3/3)=2\pi R^3/3$, so $k=2/3$. This is half of the full sphere volume.
Work the original spherical-tank rate
- Use metres and minutes, with $R=3$, $h=1$ and $dh/dt=-1/4$. The current area is $A=\pi(6-1)=5\pi$ square metres, so the signed volume rate is $dV/dt=-5\pi/4$ cubic metres per minute.
- With no inflow, the positive outflow is $5\pi/4$ cubic metres per minute. The original figure shows this level on the left and a separate quotient corner example on the right; the two panels illustrate different ideas.
Check a second level and the widest section
- For the original exercise with $R=5$, $h=2$ and $dh/dt=-1/2$, the area is $\pi(20-4)=16\pi$. The signed volume rate is $-8\pi$ cubic metres per minute; without inflow, the outflow is $8\pi$ cubic metres per minute.
- Since $A(h)=\pi[R^2-(h-R)^2]$, the largest area is $\pi R^2$ at $h=R$. Mirror depths h and $2R-h$ have equal areas. For $R=3$, depths $1$ and $5$ both give $5\pi$, while the equator gives $9\pi$.
A fixed sphere of radius $5\,\mathrm m$ contains water of depth $2\,\mathrm m$ measured from the bottom. There is no inflow, and depth falls at $0.5\,\dfrac{\mathrm m}{\mathrm{min}}$. The outflow is $k\pi$ cubic metres per minute. Find k.
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Área $A=\pi(2Rh-h^2)=16\pi$. The signed volume rate is $16\pi(-0.5)=-8\pi$; no inflow means positive outflow $8\pi$, so $k=8$.
Constant volume outflow does not mean constant depth speed
- With no inflow and constant outflow $q>0$, use $dh/dt=-q/A(h)$ for $0<h<2R$. A smaller area gives a larger fall speed. For $R=3$, $q=5\pi/4$, the fall speed is $1/4$ at depth $1$ but $5/36$ at depth $3$, in metres per minute.
- The sphere's area is zero at depths $0$ and $2R$, so this division is only valid at interior levels. The ideal constant-q model gives an unbounded depth speed as an endpoint is approached; it does not supply a finite endpoint derivative.
For a fixed spherical tank with no inlet and constant positive volume outflow, the water depth falls at a constant speed throughout the interior.
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
False. The depth rate is $-q/A(h)$, and the area changes with depth. Its fall speed is smallest at the equator and grows toward either endpoint in this ideal model.
For a radius-4 m sphere at water depth 2 m, the level falls at one quarter of a metre per minute and there is no inlet. Find the signed volume rate and positive outflow. If that outflow stays constant, find the signed depth rate at the equator.
Compare a geometria, sinais, hipóteses e cálculos unilaterais com o modelo e lista de verificação.
Net change is different from the outlet's flow
- If water also enters, write $dV/dt=q_{\rm in}-q_{\rm out}$, with both flow magnitudes nonnegative. A falling level measures their difference. It does not determine the outlet's flow unless the inlet flow is known.
- For $R=3$, $h=1$, inlet $2\pi$ and outlet $3\pi$ cubic metres per minute, the net rate is $-\pi$. Dividing by area $5\pi$ gives $dh/dt=-1/5$ metre per minute. The outlet still carries $3\pi$, rather than the net loss magnitude $\pi$.
At depth 1 m in a radius-3 m sphere, inlet and outlet rates are $2\pi$ e $3\pi$ cubic metres per minute. Give the signed depth rate in metres per minute.
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
The net volume rate is $2\pi-3\pi=-\pi$. Divide by current area $5\pi$ to obtain $dh/dt=-1/5=-0.2$.
A cone needs similar triangles first
- For a fixed upright cone with its vertex down, let its height be $H$ and top radius $r_0$. Similar triangles give $r/h=r_0/H$. Hence $V(h)=\pi(r_0/H)^2h^3/3$ and $A(h)=\pi(r_0/H)^2h^2$ for $0<h<H$.
- With $H=6$, $r_0=3$, $h=2$ in metres, the current area is $\pi$ square metres. An outflow $\pi/2$ cubic metres per minute and no inlet gives $dh/dt=-1/2$ metre per minute. The water-surface radius changes; it must not be treated as fixed.
Como a área horizontal atual varia com a profundidade?
Use tanques verticais fixos, profundidade a partir do fundo e o interior de cada tanque; cones e hemisférios têm a orientação declarada.
A fixed vertex-down cone has height 6 m and top radius 3 m. At water depth 2 m, outflow is $\pi/2$ cubic metres per minute and there is no inlet. Give the signed depth rate in metres per minute.
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Similar triangles give $r=h/2=1$, so $A=\pi$. Thus $dh/dt=-(\pi/2)/\pi=-1/2$.
A fixed vertex-down cone has height 8 m and top radius 2 m. At water depth 4 m, it drains with no inlet at $2\pi$ cubic metres per minute. Derive the depth rate using similar triangles before substituting the depth.
Compare a geometria, sinais, hipóteses e cálculos unilaterais com o modelo e lista de verificação.
Set up a quotient limit from derivatives
- Let f and g be defined near $0$, differentiable at $0$, and satisfy $f(0)=g(0)=0$. Suppose $g'(0)\ne0$. Differentiability gives $f(x)/x\to f'(0)$ and $g(x)/x\to g'(0)$ as $x\to0$.
- For $x\ne0$ where the quotient is defined, write $f(x)/g(x)=[f(x)/x]/[g(x)/x]$. This uses derivative definitions at the point. Continuous derivatives on a whole neighbourhood are sufficient but are not needed for this argument.
A nonzero derivative protects the denominator
- Put $c=g'(0)\ne0$. For sufficiently small nonzero x, convergence gives $|g(x)/x-c|<|c|/2$. Hence $|g(x)/x|>|c|/2>0$, so $g(x)\ne0$ throughout a punctured neighbourhood of zero.
- The ordinary quotient limit law now applies: the finite limit of $f(x)/g(x)$ is $L=f'(0)/g'(0)$. The nonzero derivative does two jobs: it gives a nonzero limiting denominator after division by x, and ensures the original quotient is defined nearby.
Work the original quotient limits
- In radians, take $f(x)=\sin(2x)$ and $g(x)=3x$. Both vanish at zero, with derivatives $2$ and $3$, so the quotient tends to $2/3$. The factor multiplying x inside the sine matters.
- In the original exercise, $f(x)=e^x-1$ and $g(x)=\sin(5x)$. Their derivatives at zero are $1$ and $5$, so the limit is $1/5=0.2$. The derivative-definition argument establishes the result directly.
Evaluate $\lim_{x\to0} \dfrac{e^x - 1}{\sin 5x}$.
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Both functions vanish at zero and are differentiable there. Their derivatives are $1$ e $5$, respectively. The nonzero denominator derivative permits the local quotient limit $1/5=0.2$.
Fill only the value that the limit permits
- If the quotient has finite limit L, keep its values for $x\ne0$ and set its value at zero to L. The resulting extension is continuous at zero. A different value there cannot be continuous, because changing a single value does not change the limit.
- For $(x+x^2)/x$, the nearby values are $1+x$ and the only continuous fill is $1$. Assigning the value $2$ at zero leaves a discontinuity. Replacing it by $1$ fixes continuity, but a separate derivative check is still required.
A favor $x\ne0$, let $H(x)=(x+x^2)/x$. Which value must H(0) have for continuity at zero?
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
The nearby expression is $1+x$, so its limit is 1. Altering the isolated value cannot change that limit.
Continuous first derivatives can leave a quotient corner
- Let $f(x)=x|x|$ and $g(x)=x$. Here f is continuously differentiable: $f'(x)=2|x|$, including $f'(0)=0$. Also $g'(0)=1$. Thus these functions meet even the stronger continuous-derivative hypotheses.
- For $x\ne0$, the quotient is $|x|$, with continuous fill $0$. Its difference quotient at zero is $|x|/x$, equal to $-1$ from the left and $1$ from the right. The extension is continuous but not differentiable.
If $f/g$ has a finite limit at 0, its continuous extension is differentiable at 0.
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
False. With $f=x|x|$ e $g=x$, the quotient is $|x|$ away from zero. Its continuous fill is 0, but the one-sided derivatives there are $-1$ e $1$.
A derivative needs more than the filled value
- For $(x+x^2)/x$, the continuous extension is $1+x$, which has derivative $1$ at zero. In general, once the fill is L, test the limit of $(f(x)/g(x)-L)/x$ separately; the value L alone does not determine that limit.
- If f and g are $C^2$ near zero, with zero values there, write $a=f'(0)$, $c=g'(0)\ne0$, $p=f''(0)$ and $q=g''(0)$. Second-order Taylor expansions give extension derivative $(pc-aq)/(2c^2)$. These extra hypotheses exclude the preceding corner example.
A favor $x\ne0$, let $H(x)=(e^x-1)/x$. Find the continuous fill H(0) and its derivative at zero. Explain why the fill alone does not establish the derivative.
Compare a geometria, sinais, hipóteses e cálculos unilaterais com o modelo e lista de verificação.
A zero denominator derivative leaves the test undecided
- If $g'(0)=0$, the earlier nonzero-derivative test does not apply. Yet $f=x^3$, $g=x^2$ give quotient x away from zero and a smooth fill at zero. A failed sufficient condition is not a proof of failure.
- Other choices do fail: $f=x$, $g=x^2$ give $1/x$, with no finite two-sided limit; $f=x|x|$, $g=x^2$ give $|x|/x$, with opposite one-sided limits. Inspect the actual leading terms and the denominator's domain.
O que o quociente pode se tornar em zero?
Todo quociente começa no x real não nulo próximo a zero. Decida se existe preenchimento contínuo, depois se possui derivada.
A quotient with $f(0)=g(0)=g\prime(0)=0$ can still have a differentiable extension at zero.
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
True. With $f(x)=x^3$ e $g(x)=x^2$, the quotient equals x for $x\ne0$. Filling with 0 gives a smooth function, although the earlier nonzero-derivative test does not apply.
At zero compare the extensions of (i) $x|x|/x$; (ii) $x^3/x^2$; and (iii) $x|x|/x^2$, each initially defined for nonzero x. State the limit and differentiability where a continuous fill exists.
Compare a geometria, sinais, hipóteses e cálculos unilaterais com o modelo e lista de verificação.
Recap
- Relate volume to depth before differentiating. Multiply by the current horizontal area for a signed net volume rate; distinguish inlet, outlet and net change, and divide only where that area is positive.
- For the local quotient test, require differentiability, zero numerator and denominator values, and nonzero denominator derivative. A finite fill gives continuity at the point; differentiability requires a further check.
- related rates: Rates of changing quantities linked by an equation, usually connected by the chain rule.
- cross-section: The shape formed by intersecting a solid with a plane.
- removable: Describing a singularity that a finite value can fill to make a function continuous at that point.