Government failure
Introduzido| English | Significado |
|---|---|
| government failure/ˈɡʌvənmənt ˈfeɪlɪə/ | falha governamental |
| unintended consequences/ˌʌnɪnˈtendɪd ˈkɒnsɪkwənsɪz/ | Effects of an action or policy that were not its intended objectives. |
| administrative cost/ədˈmɪnɪstrətɪv kɒst/ | custo administrativo |
Paying for rat tails
- In 1902 the French rulers of Hanoi paid a reward for every rat tail brought in, to fight plague.
- People cut off tails and let the rats go free to breed more. Some even farmed rats.
- The policy made the problem worse. This is government failure 政府失灵.
What government failure is
- Government failure happens when intervention causes a net welfare loss — society ends up worse off than with no intervention, or worse off than with a better policy.
- It is the mirror image of market failure: a misallocation of resources caused by the state.
Government failure occurs when —
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
The intervention leaves society worse off.
Four causes
- Distortion of price signals: price controls and subsidies stop prices showing true scarcity.
- Unintended consequences 意外后果: people react in ways the policy did not expect, as in Hanoi.
- Excessive administrative costs 行政成本: running the policy uses more resources than it saves.
- Information gaps: the government does not know the true size of the external cost or benefit.
Match each case to the cause of government failure.
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
These are the four causes in the specification.
Worked example: net welfare change
A policy brings gross social gains of ¥1200. It uses ¥900 of resources and ¥400 of administration.
- Net change $= 1200 - 900 - 400 = -¥100$: government failure.
- If administration is cut to ¥150: $1200 - 900 - 150 = +¥150$ — now worthwhile.
- But if the gains were overestimated and are really ¥900: $900 - 900 - 150 = -¥150$. The verdict depends on information the government may not have.

When an intervention costs more than it gains
Gains 1,200 less resources 900 and administration 400 is a net change of −100: government failure here. Cut administration to 150 and it becomes +150; then lower gains to 900 for the overstated estimate and it falls to −150, so the judgement does not survive.
A policy has gross gains of ¥2000, resource costs of ¥1300 and administration costs of ¥500. What is the net welfare change?
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
$2000 - 1300 - 500 = +¥200$: the policy is worthwhile.
If gains turn out to be only ¥1600, what is the net change?
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
$1600 - 1300 - 500 = -¥200$: government failure.
A real case: rent controls
- A maximum rent below equilibrium aims to help tenants.
- But landlords supply fewer flats and spend less on repairs, waiting lists grow and black markets in tenancies appear.
- The tenants who already have a flat gain; those still looking lose.
Which are likely results of a maximum rent set below equilibrium?
Dificuldade 2/5 · Moedas 140 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
A ceiling below equilibrium causes a shortage, not a surplus.
Government failure does not mean the government should never intervene. It means a policy must be judged on its net effect, including its costs and side effects. The right comparison is between an imperfect market and an imperfect policy — not between a perfect market and a failed one.
The risk of government failure means governments should never intervene in markets.
Dificuldade 1/5 · Moedas 100 + pequeno bônus na primeira conclusão hoje
Policy should be judged on its net effect compared with the imperfect market.
Government failure is intervention that causes a net welfare loss. Its causes are distorted price signals, unintended consequences, excessive administrative costs and information gaps. Good evaluation compares the imperfect market with the imperfect policy.
Explain how a guaranteed minimum price for wheat could lead to government failure.
Link the policy to a named cause and to a net loss.