Quantitative comparison and number reasoning
Introduced| English | Meaning |
|---|---|
| quantitative comparison/ˈkwɒntɪteɪtɪv kəmˈpærɪsn/ | A question type asking which of two quantities is greater for all allowed cases, whether they are always equal, or whether the relationship cannot be determined. |
| counterexample/ˈkaʊntəreɡzæmpl/ | A specific example that shows a general claim is false. |
Compare a relationship without knowing the price
- A supplier offers one pack at price p and another at $1.1p$, with $p>0$. You do not know either price, but the second must cost more. Unknown values do not automatically mean an unknown relationship.
- Quantitative comparison 数量比较 asks which relationship holds across all cases allowed by the information. Read the domain first: real, positive, integer and nonzero are different restrictions.
Distinguish the four relationships
- The GRE choices are: (A) Quantity A is greater; (B) Quantity B is greater; (C) they are equal; (D) the relationship cannot be determined. A, B or C must hold for every allowed case. Practice below uses the full relationship descriptions.
- Strictly greater is different from greater than or equal. If A equals B in one allowed case and exceeds B in another, none of A, B or C is always true: choose D. You do not need a case where B exceeds A as well.
One counterexample rejects a claim, not every answer
- A counterexample 反例 is an allowed case that makes a proposed universal claim false. One case against “A is always greater” rules out that claim; it does not by itself distinguish B, C and D.
- For real x, compare $x^2+1$ with $x^2$. At $x=0$, the values 1 and 0 refute “B is always greater.” Yet the correct relationship is A: the difference is always 1. A failed guess does not force D.
If two allowed cases give different comparison outcomes, the relationship cannot be ____.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Different outcomes can be greater versus less, greater versus equal, or less versus equal. Two different numerical values with the same comparison outcome do not suffice.
Finding one counterexample to a proposed “A is always greater” claim automatically proves that the relationship cannot be determined.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
It only refutes that proposed claim. The correct result could still be B always greater, equality always, or an undetermined relationship. Two distinct allowed outcomes establish the last option.
Work the original unrestricted comparison
- Let x be any real number. Quantity A is $x^2$ and Quantity B is x. At $x=2$, A is 4 and B is 2. At $x=1/2$, A is $1/4$ and B is $1/2$. These two allowed cases already establish D.
- At $x=1$, the quantities are equal. One equality cannot establish C for all real x, just as one strict comparison cannot establish A or B. You need not test every value once two different outcomes are established.
Let $x$ be any real number. Quantity A: $x^2$. Quantity B: $x$.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
At x = 2, A is greater; at x = 1/2, B is greater. Both values are allowed, so two different outcomes establish an undetermined relationship.
Explain all cases with a difference
- Subtract the quantities: $x^2-x=x(x-1)$. The zeros are 0 and 1. For $x<0$, both factors are negative, so A is greater. For $0<x<1$, the factors have opposite signs, so B is greater.
- For $x>1$, both factors are positive, so A is greater. At 0 and 1, the quantities are equal. This sign analysis explains the whole real line; testing selected numbers only illustrates its cases.
Restrict the domain before choosing examples
- With $x>1$, the original comparison has A greater for every allowed x. With $0<x<1$, B is greater. With $x\in\{0,1\}$, they are always equal. A forbidden value proves nothing about the restricted question.
- With $x\ge1$, equality at 1 and A greater at 2 give D. Test included boundaries. A positive integer can be 1; a positive real can also be a fraction. Do not silently replace one domain with the other.
Compare x squared with x at this value
For each stated real value, compare Quantity A = x² with Quantity B = x. These are individual cases, not universal claims.
$x > 1$. Quantity A: $x^2$. Quantity B: $x$.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
For x > 1, both x and x − 1 are positive, so x² − x = x(x − 1) > 0 for every allowed value. This proves A is greater.
$x\ge1$. Quantity A: $x^2$. Quantity B: $x$.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
At x = 1 they are equal; at x = 2 A is greater. Equality versus a strict comparison suffices for an undetermined relationship.
A universal answer needs a reason
- Several examples with the same outcome do not prove that outcome for every allowed value. For the unrestricted $x^2$ versus x comparison, testing only 2, 3 and 4 would miss fractions and equality.
- A universal comparison may have a short proof. Compare $x^2+3$ with $2x$: their difference is $(x-1)^2+2$, which is strictly positive for every real x. Thus A is greater even though neither quantity has a fixed value.
For any real $x$, compare Quantity A: $x^2+3$ with Quantity B: $2x$. Give a proof covering the full domain and explain why a few trials are not enough.
Use the checklist to compare your domain checks, proof or witness cases with the model.
Simplify without losing the comparison
- Adding or subtracting the same real expression from both quantities preserves their relationship at each allowed input. For $6x+5$ versus $6x+2$, subtract $6x$ from both: 5 exceeds 2 for every real x.
- Comparing the difference with zero often avoids solving for x. Positive difference means A is greater; negative means B is greater; zero means equal. If different signs or zero occur across allowed cases, check which distinct outcomes that produces.
Let $x$ be any real number. Quantity A: $6x+5$. Quantity B: $6x+2$.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Subtract 6x from both quantities; 5 is always greater than 2. No sign restriction on x is needed for this subtraction.
Positive, negative and zero scaling behave differently
- Multiplying or dividing both quantities by the same positive number preserves order. A negative multiplier or divisor reverses strict order while preserving equality. For example, $2<5$ becomes $-4>-10$ after multiplication by $-2$.
- Multiplication by zero makes both results zero and loses the original comparison. Division by zero is undefined. A transformation used to infer the original relationship must retain the needed information; a shared operation is not automatically reversible.
An unknown sign requires cases
- For real x, compare A = x with B = $2x$. If $x>0$, B is greater; if $x<0$, A is greater; if $x=0$, they are equal. Do not divide by x while ignoring its sign or whether it is zero.
- If the question states $x<0$, division by x is allowed, but reverses order: the comparison of 1 with 2 must be reversed when returning to the original quantities. Splitting known sign cases is valid; treating an unknown-sign factor as positive is not.
If the sign of $x$ is unknown and $x$ may be zero, dividing both quantities by $x$ and keeping the original inequality direction is not a valid general step.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
A negative divisor reverses strict order, and division by zero is undefined. Separate positive, negative and zero cases or use another reversible comparison.
$x<0$. Quantity A: $x$. Quantity B: $2x$.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Since x is negative, x − 2x = −x > 0. Alternatively, division by x reverses the comparison of 1 and 2. A is greater.
Squares and roots can hide a sign
- Squaring is order-preserving for nonnegative inputs, but not for all real inputs: $-2<1$ while $(-2)^2>1^2$. Do not square two unknown-sign quantities and assume their original order survives.
- The principal square root is nonnegative: $\sqrt{x^2}=|x|$, not always x. Solving $x^2=9$ allows both 3 and $-3$ unless another condition excludes one; $\sqrt9$ itself is 3.
Prove the original square-remainder result
- Let n be a positive integer. If $n=2k$, then $n^2=4k^2$ has remainder 0 on division by 4. If $n=2k+1$, then $n^2=4k(k+1)+1$ has remainder 1. These even and odd cases exhaust the domain.
- Quantity A, the remainder, is therefore either 0 or 1. Quantity B is 2, so B is always greater. A changes value, but its relationship to 2 does not change. This is B, not D.

$n$ is a positive integer. Quantity A: the remainder when $n^2$ is divided by 4. Quantity B: 2.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
An even n has square divisible by 4; an odd n has square one more than a multiple of 4. The remainder is always 0 or 1, both less than 2, so B is greater.
Use prime factors to express divisibility conditions
- If a positive integer n is divisible by both 12 and 18, use $12=2^2\cdot3$ and $18=2\cdot3^2$. It must contain at least two factors of 2 and two of 3, so $n=36k$ for a positive integer k.
- The least possible n is 36. But comparing an arbitrary such n with 36 gives D: n can equal 36 or exceed it, as at 72. “Least possible value” and “any allowed value” ask different questions.
A positive integer $n$ is divisible by both 12 and 18. Compare $n$ with 36. Then compare the least possible $n$ with 36. Explain why the two answers differ.
Use the checklist to compare your domain checks, proof or witness cases with the model.
Ratios determine some relationships without fixing values
- For positive a and b with $a:b=2:3$, write $a=2t$ and $b=3t$ with $t>0$. Comparing $2a=4t$ with $b=3t$ gives A greater. Positivity justifies cancelling t without reversing order.
- The actual values remain unknown, but $a/(a+b)=2/5$ is fixed. Compare that ratio with $0.4$: they are equal. Keep the total $a+b$ in the denominator, rather than b.
Positive $a,b$ satisfy $a:b=2:3$. Find $a/(a+b)$ as a decimal.
Difficulty 2/5 · 140 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
Write a = 2t and b = 3t with t > 0. The fraction is 2t/(5t) = 2/5 = 0.4; its denominator is a + b, not b.
Percentage changes use different bases
- Start with a positive price p. A 20% increase gives $1.2p$; a subsequent 20% decrease gives $0.8(1.2p)=0.96p$. Compared with the original p, the final price is lower, so B is greater when A is the final price and B is the original.
- For a starting price of 100, the increase is 20 but the later decrease is 24, because its base is 120. The net change is a 4% decrease from the original. Equal percentage increases and decreases do not simply cancel.
An initial price $p>0$ rises by 20%, then falls by 20% of the raised price. Quantity A: the final price. Quantity B: $p$.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
The final price is 1.2 × 0.8p = 0.96p, less than p because p > 0. Thus B is greater.
State the range before comparing powers
- If $0<t<1$, multiplying a positive value by t makes it smaller. Hence $t^3<t^2<t$. For $t>1$, the inequalities reverse. At $t=1$, all three are equal.
- Do not extend the positive-fraction rule to every negative input. At $t=-2$, $t^3=-8<t$; at $t=-1/2$, $t^3=-1/8>t$. The domain and exponent both matter.
Compare Quantity A: $t^3$ with Quantity B: $t$ in each domain: (i) $0<t<1$; (ii) $t>1$; (iii) $t<0$. Prove the fixed relationships or give different allowed outcomes.
Use the checklist to compare your domain checks, proof or witness cases with the model.
A bound may still leave the GRE relationship undetermined
- For a positive integer n, the remainder of $n^2$ on division by 3 is 0 or 1. Multiples of 3 give 0; writing the other cases as $n=3k+1$ or $n=3k+2$ gives remainder 1 after squaring.
- Compare this remainder with 1. At $n=3$, B is greater; at $n=1$, they are equal. Therefore D, even though A never exceeds B. Knowing a non-strict bound need not select one of the three fixed strict/equality relationships.
Which relationship holds over the stated domain?
Each card supplies its domain and both quantities. Choose the relationship across every allowed case.
Let $n$ be a positive integer. Quantity A: the remainder of $n^2$ on division by 3. Quantity B: 1.
Difficulty 1/5 · 100 coins + a small bonus on first completion today
n = 3 gives remainder 0, so B is greater; n = 1 gives remainder 1, so the quantities are equal. Therefore the relationship cannot be determined.
For any real $x$, compare Quantity A: $|x|$ with Quantity B: $x$. Is the fact that $|x|\ge x$ enough to choose “A is greater”? Justify your final relationship.
Use the checklist to compare your domain checks, proof or witness cases with the model.
Recap
- Read every domain condition, compare a useful difference or ratio, and keep signs, zero and included boundaries. Give a general reason for a universal A, B or C answer.
- For D, exhibit two allowed cases with different outcomes. One counterexample refutes a proposed claim; changing numerical values alone does not mean the relationship changes.
- quantitative comparison: A question type asking which of two quantities is greater for all allowed cases, whether they are always equal, or whether the relationship cannot be determined.
- counterexample: An allowed case that shows a proposed universal claim is false.